17187. Brotherhood of Railway Clerks National Bank (Cincinnati, OH)

Bank Information

Episode Type
Run → Suspension → Reopening
Bank Type
national
Bank ID
12446
Charter Number
12446
Start Date
June 24, 1930
Location
Cincinnati, Ohio (39.103, -84.515)

Metadata

Model
gpt-5-mini
Short Digest
34e04575

Response Measures

Full suspension, Books examined

Other: Receivership appointed then assets sold to Central Trust; receivership later lifted.

Receivership Details

Date receivership started
1930-06-26
Date receivership terminated
1930-07-02
OCC cause of failure
Other

Description

Deposit withdrawals (~$1,000,000) following resignations and revelations of A. W. Shafer's check-kiting/forged collateral forced directors to close the bank June 26, 1930; a receiver was appointed and the institution was sold to Central Trust and reopened as its branch on July 5, 1930. Cause tied to bank-specific adverse information (Shafer's kiting/forged collateral).

Events (9)

1. September 29, 1923 Chartered
Source
historical_nic
2. June 24, 1930 Run
Cause
Bank Specific Adverse Info
Cause Details
Heavy withdrawals triggered by revelations tied to A. W. Shafer's check-kiting and forged Cities Service stock collateral; resignations of bank officials precipitated panic.
Measures
Directors met emergency; attempted to meet withdrawals but anticipated cash difficulty due to illiquid loans; subsequently voted to shut down and turn assets to Comptroller/receiver.
Newspaper Excerpt
depositors withdrew over $1,000,000
Source
newspapers
3. June 26, 1930 Receivership
Source
historical_nic
4. June 26, 1930 Receivership
Newspaper Excerpt
J. W. Pole, comptroller of the currency, appointed Ira Fulton ... as receiver for the Brotherhood of Railway Clerks Bank which closed its doors ... Fulton will take immediate charge.
Source
newspapers
5. June 26, 1930 Suspension
Cause
Bank Specific Adverse Info
Cause Details
Directors voluntarily closed the bank after heavy withdrawals and concerns arising from Shafer's kiting operations and alleged forged collateral; assets placed with Comptroller of the Currency and receiver appointed (Ira Fulton).
Newspaper Excerpt
failed to open for business today. The notice was signed by national bank examiner
Source
newspapers
6. July 2, 1930 Other
Newspaper Excerpt
acquisition by Central Trust Company; receivership lifted and acquisition authorized by J. W. Pole, Comptroller of Currency
Source
newspapers
7. July 2, 1930 Restored To Solvency
Source
historical_nic
8. July 5, 1930 Reopening
Newspaper Excerpt
The Brotherhood of Railway Clerks' National Bank ... was reopened today as a branch of the Central Trust Co.
Source
newspapers
9. August 22, 1930 Voluntary Liquidation
Source
historical_nic

Newspaper Articles (21)

Article from The Bismarck Tribune, June 26, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BROTHERHOOD BANK CLOSES IN OHIO Run on Institution Follows Sudden Change in Official Personnel Cincinnati, June 26.-(P)-The Brotherhood of Railway clerks National bank failed to open for business today. William Taylor, Cleveland, federal bank examiner, recently completed an audit of the Brotherhood Bank and on last Monday two changes were made in the official personnel of the bank shortly after directors said the institution was in sound condition. Michael G. Heintz was named vice president succeeding Lyman Norris, resigned, and William L. Luebbe, was appointed assistant cashier in place of Harry Rosenblum, who also resigned. Closing of the Brotherhood bank came 16 days after another Cincinnati bank, the Cosmopolitan bank and Trust company, was forced to close on account of the $1,000,000 peculations of A. W. Shafer, former district manager of the H. L. Doherty company. Deposits at the bank were said to total $4,800,000. After the change in officials was made Monday, the board of directors said, depositors withdrew over $1,000,000.


Article from Spokane Chronicle, June 26, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

80 Killed in Bolivian Revolt Women and Children Mowed by PoliceCorpses Paraded. ARICA, Chile, June 26. (AP) The conductor of the international train arriving from La Paz last night said that a grave disturbance had occurred in the Bolivian capital Sunday, and that 80 persons had been killed, of whom 17 were students. Strictest censorship prevails. AREQUIPA. Chile, June 26. (AP)Travelers arriving here from Bolivia today said that police in La bers of meeting of workers and students Sunday. Among the dead were said to have been women and The demonstrators took the corpses and afterwards exhibited them in the streets. The travelers said the city was tense when they left and it was feared further trouble would occur when the victim's bodies were buried. RUN ON BANK CLOSES DOORS CINCINNATI, Ohio, June 26. (P)The Brotherhood of Railway Clerks' National bank, the majority of whose stock is owned by 120,000 members of the Brotherhood of Railway and Steamship Clerks, freight handlers and station employees, was closed today after $1,000,000 in deposits had been withdrawn following the resignation of two bank officials three days


Article from San Angelo Evening Standard, June 26, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Brotherhood Bank Closed Institution for Railway Clerks at Cincinnati Fails to Open CINCINNATI, June 26.(P)-The Brotherhood of Railway Clerks Na. tional Bank failed to open for business today. First information that the institution would not open came from a notice posted on the institution's door saying the bank was closed. The notice was signed by a nationbank examiner William Taylor Cleveland, federal bank examiner, recently completed an audit of the brotherhood bank and on last Monday two changes were made in the official personnel of the bank shortly after directors said the institution was in sound Michael G. Heintz was named vice president succeed ing Lyman Norris, resigned, and William L. Luebbe was appointed assistant cashier in place of Harry Rosenblum, who also resigned. Closing of the brotherhood bank came sixteen days after another Cincinnati bank. the Cosmopolitan Bank & Trust Company, was forced to close on account of the $1,000,- 000 speculations of A. W. Shafer, former district manager of the H. L. Doherty Company. The brotherhood bank recently announced it had increased its rate of interest paid on deposits from four to five per cent. Deposits at the bank were said to total $4,800,000 and after the change in officials was made Monday the board of directors said depositors withdrew over 1,000,000. The unusually heavy withdrawal was the reason given by the directors for closing the bank. They said they voted to shut down the bank and place the assets in the hands of the comptroller of currency for liquidation. J.J. Castillini is president of the bank. The majority of the bank's stock is owned by the brotherhood of railway and steamship clerks. freight handlers. express and station employes, of which there are 120,000 members in the United States. The bank was established at a convention of the brotherhood held at Dallas in 1922. The local building was constructed immediately and opened its doors in 1923. Many labor unions were said to deposits in the bank. A statement issued March 27 gave the bank's capital stock at $400,000, surplus and undivided profits $65 Deposits on that date were $4,740,281 A sum of $400,000 had been made against contingent liability The loans and discounts amounted to 143,565. Among the assets were bonds and securities estimated worth $1,803,743. Total resources were given as $5,659,363. The book value of the stock was listed at $141 48 share. National bank examiners said Shafer had an account with the brotherhood bank but did not disclose whether it was a large or small sum. The district attorney said he believed the bank should pay out satisfactorily. WASHINGTON, June 26 (P)-J. W. Pole, comptroller of the currency, appointed Ira Fulton, a national bank examiner, today as receiver for the Brotherhood of Railway Clerks Bank which closed its doors in Fulton will take immediate charge.


Article from The Tulsa Tribune, June 26, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Railway Workers' Bank Closes After Rather Heavy Run Echoes Failure of Another Bank Following Arrest of Doherty Manager CINCINNATI, Ohio, June Brotherlfood of Railway Clerks National bank, the majority of whose stock is owned by 120,000 members of the Brotherhood Railway and Steamship Clerks, Freight Handlers and Station Emwas closed today after $1,000,000 in deposits had been withdrawn following the resignation of two bank officials three days Rumors difficulties were ported at the bank after Bank & Trust Co. closed 16 days The latter stitution a result the $1,000,000 of manager of the Henry L. Doherty United States District Attorney Haveth Mau said that an account Shafer carried in the Brotherhood bank had been under investigation for two Shafer was found to be short $623,000 in his accounts with the Cosmopolitan bank but federal bank examiners would disclose the size of his account the Brotherhood bank? Mau said Shafer collateral with the Brother hood bank consisted of Cities Servstock certificates which bore forged Deposits at the bank were said total Nelson Hamilton county loans approximating secured by alleged forged securities had been to by bank. The led him to that no other bank was involved in Shafer's tions. Castillini is president the It of the held in The local diately and its doors in 1923 Many unions were said in The bank its rate on deposits from per cent. March the capital stock surplus and profits on that were of had liability The loans and discounts amounted to were bonds and Among assets securities estimated worth Total $5,659,363 The book value of listed at The district bebank should W the Ira bank for the closed doors in Cincinnati take BANKERS ARRESTED The secretary and former treasurer of Vineland Trust Co by the department of 10 were day BROWNWOOD The State to open its today Bank closing to withthe few days The established in and the $129,000 a of


Article from Ledger-Star, June 26, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

LABOR CLOSED Pronounced In Sound Condition After Recent Federal Audit Cincinnati, June 26 Brotherhood of Railway Clerks National Bank failed to open for business today. First information that the bank would not open came from notice posted on the institution's door saying the bank was closed. The notice was signby national bank examiner. Taylor, Fedbank examiner, recently pleted audit of the Brotherhood Bank Monday two changes made the official personnel of the shortly after directors sound condition. Michael Heintz named Lyman Norris, resigned, and William Luebbe was pointed assistant cashier of Harry Rosenblum, who also signed. Closing of the Brotherhood Bank came days nati bank, Cosmopolitan Bank and Trust Company, was forced to close account the peculations Shafer, of the Doherty Company. The Brotherhood Bank recently had its interest paid deposits from cent. bank said total and after the change Monday, the board directors depositors withdrew The unusually heavy withdrawal reason the directors closing the bank. They said they voted shut down the bank and place the the hands of the of currency for District Attorney Haveth Mau said that Taylor Fulton, another Cleveland National bank examiner been conference with him concerning the bank's fairs weeks. Castillini president. majority of the bank's stock owned by Railway Steamship Freight handlers, express and station employes, which there 120,000 United The bank established the brotherhood held Dallas, 1922. The local mediately and opened its doors in Many labor unions were said to have deposits bank. Receiver Appointed Washington, June W. Pole, comptroller the Ira Fulton, National bank today receiver Railway Clerks Bank which closed its doors in Cincinnati. Fulton take mediate charge.


Article from The Cincinnati Enquirer, June 27, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

DRAINS On Deposits Serve To Make Closing An Advisable Step. Two Former Officials Arrested On Charges Conspiring To Misapply Funds Of Institution Action Of Directors Follows Runs Induced By Exaggerated Rumors-Receiver Appointed. Exaggerated and incorrect rumors regarding its condition forced the closing of the Brotherhood of Railway Clerks National Bank, Court and Vine Streets, yesterday morning, despite the fact that national bank examiners previously had found that the bank itself actually was solvent. Heavy withdrawals by depositors, alarmed by the city-wide undercurrent of rumor regarding this particular bank, and possibility that the withdrawals would continue in volume, forced this action upon the DIrectors three days after they had effectually met the emergency which had given rise to the rumors. It was case, officials said, of bank bridging serious situation completely and then being compelled quit business because of wave of hysteria among depositors not aware of the facts of the situation. Bank Is Solvent. That the bank actually is in sound condition financially was indicated by the statement of representative of the bank yesterday. Although the emergency met by the Directors arose through the stock manipulations of Amor W. Shafer, former district sales manager of Henry L. Doherty Co., which already had forced the closing of the Cosmopolitan Bank, Fifth and Walnut Streets, it was said that the situation at the Brotherhood Bank was entirely different from that at the Cosmopolitan Bank. "Kited" checks and drafts brought about the closing of the Cosmopolitan. The situation at the Brotherhood Bank developed through the bank's guarantee of indorsement of signatures of stockholders of the Cities Service Company on certificates handled through that bank by Shafer and afterward. it is alleged, found to have been forged. Not To Exceed $517,000. Last night was said that the maximum liability of the bank, even if all the Shafer certificates turn out to be forgeries, could not exceed $517,000. Against this the bank had set up $650,000, with $600,000 more available if needed. making total of well over $1,000,000 available to meet this liability. This was more than double the amount needed to insure the bank against any loss whatever through the stock transactions, it was said. This phase of the situation was arranged last Monday. Then began the rumors which sent hundreds of depositors to the bank Tuesday and Wednesday, with possibility that the "run" would continue indefinitely. So heavy were these withdrawals that the bank anticipated difficulty in raising immediate cash to meet all of them, due to the fact that much of its funds, in common with all banks, was loaned and could not be regained until the loans became due. Two Are Arrested. Numerous conferences were held by the Directors, the national bank examiners and other bankers, in an attempt to straighten out the situation. These conferences brought about the/resignations three officials of the bank and the arrest yesterday of two of them on charges of conspiracy in misapplying funds of national bank. The two arrested were Lyman E. Norris, 38 years old, Executive Vice President of the bank until few days ago, and Harry Rosenblum, 28 years old, Cashier until the same time. Officials said the two men had admitted dealings with Shafer in which they had made personal profits of $60,000 in the last few months, in connection with his stock transactions through the bank. Morris and Rosenblum were arrested by United States Deputy Marshals on warrants sworn to by Haveth E. Mau, United States District Attorney. When arraigned before United States Commissioner A. Siemon they pleaded not guilty. Mau asked that their bonds be set at $25,000 each. Although the specific charge was the misapplication of $10,000, it was said that several similar charges could be filed. Commissioner Siemon set their bonds at that amount and fixed their hearing for July 26. Morris gave his address as 7075 Ridgeway Avenue, and Rosenblum his address as 3870 Marburg Avenue. While District Attorney Mau was promising of the special grand jury to investigate the case within the next weeks, it was learned that Shafer's transactions with the Cities Service stocks had under way since last November,


Article from The Cincinnati Enquirer, June 27, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

No Other Banks Are Involved, Is Assurance Of State Officials Positive assurance was given people of Cincinnati yesterday by Edward Schorr. Director of Commerce, that no other banks in Cincinnati are involved in the financial dealings that caused the Cosmopolitan Bank Trust Co. to close its doors other than the Brotherhood of Railway Clerks National Bank which ceased functioning yesterday. Mr. Schorr "There absolutely no occasion for alarm the part of anyone cerning any the banks in Cincinnati. The careful investigation of the affairs of the Cosmopolitan Bank Trust which has been made by the State Banking Department, headby Gray, and by the State Securities Division, headed by Geissinger, us that banks Cincinnati other than the Bank Trust Co. and the Brotherhood Railway Clerks National Bank are in any way involved. "Rumors concerning other any bank are absolutely unfounded and false. of had edge for days, fairs of the Bank therefore. has been us to make any general statement prior to this concerning the banks Cincinnati. "Since the Brotherhood Bank has closed, now possible for us that no other banks are involved and that there is no occasion whatsoever for alarm on the part of anybody concerning other banks. Gray, State Superintendent of Banks: Frank Ambrose, Assistant State of Banks: Geissinger, Chief of the State Divi sion and Jack Nida, Chief the State Division Securities. fully concur with me in this statement.' large deposits, were keeping their posits intact, but that large number of the smaller depositors were withdrawing their accounts in heavy volume. Knowing this condition could not continue indefinitely without temporarily affecting the bank's cash finances. the directors met Wednesday night and drafted closing resolution, after which formal approval of their action was sought from the Comptroller of the Currency. The examiners who had gone through the bank records had left the city, meanwhile. The Brotherhood Bank was established labor union bank 1922 the Dallas, Texas, convention the Brotherhood Railway and Steamship Clerks. Freight Handlers. Express and Station Employees. in its new building 1923, and soon became the deposi- tory for the funds of number of Cincinnati labor unions and union representatives. Only few weeks ago it raised its interest rate from per cent. which is said to have the brought large increase in deposits to the bank. Its statement as of March showed capital stock, $400,000; sur plus, $100,000. and undivided profits $65,958. The deposits that day were $4,740,281. gain of $600,000 from the December statement and attributed directly to the increased interest rate. Loans and discounts amounted to bonds securities of $1,803,743. The total sources given $5,659,363 The book value of the stock as of that date was set $141.48. was learned yesterday that the Board of Education had $400,000 the bank January holding bank the deposit. This collateral safe deposit vault bank. Hamilton County also has $400,000 deposit there, $427,000 collateral covering This collateral safe deposit vault. The City of Cincinnati, however, said to have had no posit there. Stephen W. City Treasurer said withdrew $250,000 from the bank June matter of routine,' accordance with the requirements his office. He holds $270,000 of bank collateral in the safe deposit vaults. he said, protect city deposits. He said he had been instructed by the Bank aminers hold the securities for the present.


Article from The Indianapolis Star, June 27, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BANK CLOSED Shafer Again Blamed for Check Kiting-2 Former Officials Arrested. CINCINNATI, O., June 26.-The Brotherhood of Railway Clerks National bank, of the country's largest labor banks, failed to open for business today. Haveth E. Mau, United States district attorney, said the bank's closing was direct result of the $1,000,000 check kiting operations of A. W. Shafer, who under indictment for having embezzled $210,162.50 of his firm's money and charged with having caused the closing of the Cosmopolitan Bank and Trust Company sixteen days ago by his alleged pecFifty-one per cent of the Brotherhood stock was owned by United States and Canadian members the Brotherhood of Railway and Steamship Clerks. Freight Handlers and The Brotherhood bank board of rectors voluntarily closed the institution after depositors withdrew $1,000, 000 in the last three days The run followed resignation of three high bank Monday. Two Officials Arrested. Two of those former officials, Lyman E. Norris, vice president, and Harry Rosenblum, cashier, were arrested late today warrants sworn by District Attorney Mau, which charged conspiracy to violate the national banking act. They pleaded not guilty and were held under $25,Federal county officials expressed belief that the bank probwould meet obligation fully and that the assets were turned over for liquidation the controller of the currency of the United slight run existed at the bank directors said That was the date the locked upon that Shafer, manager of the H. DoherCities Service securities dealers, was short $623,000 in his account with the bank. Deposited Forged Collateral. Mau said Shafer had deposited Cities Service collateral bearing forged indorsements with the Brotherhood bank. The exact amount disclosed but was reported to not run from $225,000 $375,000. Shafer, besides being short $623,000 with the Cosmopolitan bank. was short that much more the Doherty concern. He admitted ten ago that the money gambling the trying recoup $700.000 fortune lost in the market crash last fall. The Brotherhood bank had deposits 659 of $400,000. surplus $100,000 and undivided profits of Despite the forged with Brotherhood the instituthe tion was said by directors to be sound condition in report issued The bank was opened in 1923. MANY LOCAL DEPOSITORS. None of Funds of Indianapolis Unions on Deposit There. A number of Indianapolis had funds on deposit in the Brotherhood of Railway Clerks National bank, Flannagan, secretary of one of the locals here, said last night. Mr. Flannagan unable give depositors who in the Indianapolis, number was he able to estimate the amount None the funds the IndianapBrotherhood of locals of Steamship Clerks, Railway Handlers Station Freight ployes deposit in the bank far as he knew, said. ANDERSON FUNDS WATCHED. Ind., June 26. Approximately $40,000 in life insurance of fifty Anderson and $400 savings members of the Brotherhood of RailMail Clerks believed being or partly lost the closing of result National bank at CinBrotherhood's cinnati, O., today.


Article from Lansing State Journal, June 27, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BANKS CLOSED BY SHAFER DEALS Explesion Two Men Are Held for Viola. tions after Institution Fails to Open Doors HUGE RUN IS STOPPED Examiners Promise Depositors Will Be Paid When Books Are Straightened CINCINNATI, O., June 27 (P)-A second Cincinnati bank closed two of its former officers were under arrest Friday result the alleged million dollar check kiting operations of Shafer, discharged district manager for the Henry L. Doherty The failure of the Brotherhood of Railway Clerks National to Thursday was followed by the arrests of Lyman former vice ident, and Harry former cashier. charges of conspiracy to violate the act. They were held in default of $25,000 they entered pleas of not guilty. Had Been Removed Norris, Rosenblum and Joseph Castellini, president, were removed by the Monday. United States District Attorney Haveth E. Mau said Shafer's alleged manipulations were direct cause the bank's closing. Shafer, Mau said, Service forged It this to to between $375,000, that involved Norris and The bank came under the scrutiny of investigators June when was the bank carried an account for Shafer. On that day the Bank and Trust company also alleged shortage of $623,000 in Shaaccount and Shafer arrested charge of more than the Doherty company, his Million Withdrawn The removal of the three officials of bank also resulted in withdrawal of $1,000,000 by depositors although statement was issued saying the institution good Directors said closing of the bank was the best and investigators said every obligation probably would Providence Savings Bank and study of Trust company experienced heavy but Chicago law kept open time to satisfy depositors. State Director of Commerce Edward D. Schorr announced no other banks her were involved by Shafer and the Cin- son Raymond. cinnati Clearing House promised support all the rest of the banks. The brotherhood bank established in 1923 by the of STATE OF Railway and Clerks and 51 matter per cent of the stock was owned by state members of the union. was capitalized at and had deposits of $4,800,000 and total resources of $5,659,363.


Article from The Richmond Item, June 27, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

LABOR BANK AT CINCINNATI IS SHUT IN CRASH Shafer's Check Kiting Blamed For Two Institutions' Closing CINCINNATI O., June The Brotherhood of Railway Clerks' National bank, one of the country's largest labor banks, failed to open for business today. Haveth E. Mau. United States district attorney, said the bank's closing was direct result of the $1,000,000 check kiting operations of A. W. Shafer, who under indictment for having embezzled $210,162.50 of his term's money and charged with having caused the closing of the Cosmopolitan Bank and Trust company 16 days ago by his alleged speculations. Fifty-one per cent of the Brotherhood stock was owned by 122,000 United States and Canadian members of the Brotherhood of Railway and Steamship Clerks, Freight Handlers and Station employes. The Brotherhood bank board of directors voluntarily closed the institution after depositors withdrew 31,000,000 in the last three days. The run followed the resignation of three high bank officials last Monday. Two of those officials, Lyman E Norris, vice president, and Harry Rosenblum, cashier, were arrested on warrants sworn by United States District Attorney Harveth E. Mau. which charged conspiracy to violate the national banking act. They pleaded not guilty and were held under $25,000 bond each. Federal and county officials expressed belief that the bank would probably fully meet \every obligation and that the assets were turned over for liquidation to the comptroller of the currency of the Unied States A slight run existed at the bank since June 10. directors said. That was the date the Cosmopolitan locked its doors upon disclosure that Shafer, former manager of the H L. Doherty company, City Service securities dealers, was short $623,000 in his accounts with the bank. Mau said Shafer had deposited Cities Service collateral bearing forged indorsements with the Brotherhood bank. The exact amount was not disclosed but was reported to run from $225,000 to $375,000. Shafer idmitted ten days ago that he lost the money gambling in the stock market trying to recoup $700,000 fortune lost in the market crash last fall.


Article from The Plain Speaker, June 27, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

ARREST FORMER BANK OFFICIALS Failure of Brotherhood of Railway Clerks Institution Leads to Prosecution. CINCINNATI, O., June 27 (AP) A second Cincinnati bank was closed and two of its former officers were under arrest today as a result of the alleged million dollar check writing operations of A. W. Shafer, discharged district manager for the Henry L. Doherty Company. The failure of the Brotherhood of Railway Clerks National Bank to open yesterday was followed by the arrest of Lyman E. Norris, former vice president and Harry Rosenblum, former cashier, on charges of conspiracy to violate the national banking act. They were held today in default of $25,000 bond each set after they entered pleas of not guilty. room from high government offiNorris, Rosenblum and Joseph J. cials and from many parts of the Castellini, president, were removed world, expressing sympathy and by the directors Monday. solicitude. United States District Attorney Haveth E. Mau said Shafer's allegfred Sze, Chinese Ambassador to ed manipulations were the direct London, who was associated with cause of the bank's closing. Shafer, Mr. Porter in the narcotic conference Mau said, had deposited Cities Service collateral bearing forged in- in Geneva. dorsements. It was this stock, reported to amount to between $225,000 and $375,000, that involved Norris and Rosenblum. The Brotherhood Bank came under the scrutiny of federal investigators June 10 when it was learned the bank carried an account for Shafer. On that day the Cosmopolitan Bank and Trust Company closed because of an alleged shortage of $623,000 in Shafer's account and Shafer was arrested on a charge of embezzling more than $210,000 from the Doherty Company, his former employers. The removal of the three officials of the bank also resulted in withdrawal of $1,000,000 by depositors although a statement was issued saying the institution was in good condition. Directors said closing of the bank was the best way to proBathing tect depositors and investigators said every obligation probably would be met. Suits The Provident Savings Bank and Trust Company also experienced a heavy run yesterday, but kept open over time to satisfy depositors. $1.69 State Director of Commerce Edward D. Schorr announced no other banks were involved by Shafer and the Cincinnati Clearing House Association promised support of all the rest of the county's banks. The Brotherhood Bank was established in 1923 by the Brotherhood of Railway and Steamship Clerks and 51 per cent of the stock was owned by members of the union. It was capitalized at $400,000 and had deposits of $4,800,000 and total resources of $5,659,363.


Article from The Spokesman-Review, June 27, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BIG LABOR BANK CLOSES DOORS Cincinnati Institution Suffers Through A. W. Shafer's Kiting Operations. $1,000,000 IN 3 DAYS Heavy Withdrawals by Deposftors Last Straw-Had Resources of $5,600,000. Brotherhood of Railway Clerks' National bank, one of the country's largest labor banks, failed to open for business today. Federal District Attorney Mau said the bank's closing was direct result of the check kiting under indictment for having embezzled $210,162.50 of his firm's money and charged with having caused the closing of the Cosmopolitan Bank and Trust 16 days ago by his alleged speçulaFifty-one per cent of the Brotherhood stock was owned by 122,000 United States and Canadian members of the Brotherhood of Railway Clerks, Freight Handiers and Station Employees. The Brotherhood bank board of directors voluntarily closed the institution after depositors withdrew the last three days. The run followed the resignation of three high bank officials last Two of those former officials. Lyman E. Norris, vice president, and Harry Rosenblum, cashier. were arrested on warrants by federal District Attorney H. E. Man, charged conspiracy to violate the national banking act. They pleaded not guilty and were held under $25,000 bond each. Likely to Pay in Full. Federal and county officials ex. pressed belief the bank would probably fully meet every obligation. The assets were turned over for liquidation the comptroller of the currency of the United alight run existed at the bank since June 10, directors said. That was the date the locked its doors upon disclosure that Shafer former manager of the H. L. Doherty company, Cities Service securities dealers, waseshort $623,000 in his account with the bank. Mau said Shafer had deposited Cities Service bearing forged the Brotherhood bank. The exact amount was not disclosed but was reported to run fr $225,000 to $375,000. Due to Stock Gambling. Shafer, besides being short $623.000 with the Cosmopolitan was short that much more with the Doherty He admitted days ago he lost the money gambling in the stock market trying to recoup $700,000 fortune lost in the market crash last The Brotherhood bank had desurplus of and vided profits of $65,958 Despite the forged signatures on Shafer's col. lateral with the bank, the was said by directors to be in sound condition in report Issued Monday


Article from The Salt Lake Tribune, June 27, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

LABOR BANK SHUT AFTER CHECK KITING Second Cincinnati Institution Hit by Shafer Operations. CINCINNATI, June 26 of the country's largest labor banks. the Brotherhood of Railway Clerks' National bank closed today as rect result of the checkkiting operations of A. W Shafer whose peculations also forced the Cosmopolitan Bank and Trust company to close sixteen days ago. Fifty per cent of the brotherhood stock was owned by 122,000 United States and Canadian members of the Brotherhood of Railway and Steamship Clerks, Freight Handlers and Station Employees. The brotherhood bank board of directors voluntarily closed the institution after depositors withdrew $1,000,000 in the last three days. The run followed the resignation of three high bank officials last Monday Two of those former officials, Lyman E. Norris, vice president, and Harry Rosenblum. cashier, were ar- PAYSON GIRL MARRIED. PAYSON-The marriage of Miss Della Pickering, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Samuel Pickering, and Albert Francom, son of Mr. and Mrs. Will Francom, took place at Provo early this week They will make their home at Payson. violate the national banking act. They pleaded not guilty and were held under $25,000 bond each. Federal and county officials expressed belief that, the bank would probably fully meet every obligation and that the assets were turned over for liquidation to the comptroller of the currency of the United States. slight run existed at the bank since June 10. directors said That was the date the Cosmopolitan locked its doors upon disclosure that Shafer former manager of the H. L. Doherty company, Cities Service securities dealers, was short $623,000 in his account with the bank Mau said Shafer had deposited Cities Service collateral bearing forged indorsements with the broth crhood bank The exact amount was not disclosed. but was reported to run from $225,000 to $375,000. Shafer, besides being short with the Cosmopolitan bank, was short that much more with the Doherty concern He admitted ten days that he lost the money gambling in the stock market trying to recoup a $700,000 fortune lost in the market crash last fall The brotherhood bank had deposits of $4,800,000: total resources of $5,659 363 capital stock of $400, 000; surplus of $100,000 and undivid ed profits of $65,958 Despite the forged signatures on Shafer' collateral with the brotherhood bank. the institution was said by directors


Article from Chattanooga Daily Times, June 27, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BROTHERHOOD BANK FORCED TO SUSPEND Railway Clerks' Institution Victim of $1,000,000 Run. Plight Traceable to Peculations of Shafer, Who Wrecked Cosmopolitan Bank. CINCINNATI, O., June 26 Brotherhood of Railway Clerks National bank, one of the country's largest labor banks. failed to open for business today. Haveth E. Mau, United States district attorney, said the bank's closing was a to the home and funeral will be held here.


Article from Fort Worth Record-Telegram, June 27, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Brotherhood Bank Closed, Two Ex-Officials Arrested CINCINNATI. June 26.-One of the country's largest labor banks, the Brotherhood of Railway Clerks National Bank, closed today as direct result of the $1,000,000 check kiting operations of A. W. Shafer, whose speculations also forced the Cosmopolitan Bank and Trust Company to close 16 days ago. Fifty-one per cent of the brotherhood St ck was owned by 122,000 United tates and Canadian members of De Brotherhood of Railway and Ste hiship Clerks, Freight Handlers and Station Employes. The brotherhood bank board of directors voluntarily closed the institution after depositors withdrew $1, 000,000 in the last three days. The run followed the of three high bank officials last Monday. Ex Officials Arrested. Two of those former officials, Lyman E. Norris, vice president, and Harry Rosenblum, cashier, were arrested on warrants sworn by United States District Attorney Haveth E. Mau, which charged conspiracy to violate the national banking act. They pleaded not guilty and were held under $25,000 bond each. Federal and county officials expressed belief that the bank would probably fully meet every obligation and that the assets were turned over for liquidation to the Comptroller of the Currency of the United States. A slight run existed at the bank since June 10. directors said. That was the date the Cosmopolitan locked its doors upon disclosure that Shafer, former manager of the H. L. Doherty Company City dealers. was short $623,000 in his account with the Forged Indorsements. Mau said Shafer had deposited Cities Service collateral bearing forged indorsements with the brotherhood bank. The exact amount was not disclosed but was reported to run from $225,000 to $375,000. Shafer, besides being short $623,000 with the Cosmopolitan bank, was short that much more with the Doherty He admitted 10 days ago that he lost the money gambling in the stock market trying to recoup $700,000 fortune lost in the market crash last Fall. The brotherhood bank had deposits of $4,800,000 total resources of $5, 659,363, capital stock of $400,000. surplus of $100,000. and undivided profits of $65,958. Despite the forged signatures on Shafer's collateral. with the bank, the was said by directors to be in sound condition in report issued Monday. The bank was opened in 1923.


Article from Omaha World-Herald, June 27, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

LABOR BANK CLOSES AFTER A 3-DAY RUN Is Laid to Check Kiting by Ex-Official of Doherty Firm. TWO ARE ARRESTED Cincinnati, O., June 26 The Brotherhood of Railway Clerks National bank, one of the country's largest labor banks, failed to open for business today. Haveth Mau, United States district attorney, said the bank's closing direct result of the one million dollar check kiting operations of A. W. Shafer. who is under indictment for having embezzled $210,162.50 of his firm's money and charged with having caused the closing of the Cosmopolitan Bank and Trust company 16 days ago by his alleged speculations. Fifty-one per cent of the brother hood stock was owned by 122 thou sand United States and Canadian members of the Brotherhood of Railway and Steamship Clerks. Freight Handlers and Station Employes. The brotherhood bank board of directors voluntarily closed the institution after depositors withdrew one million dollars in the last three days. The run followed the resignation of three high bank officials last Monday Jail Two Ex-Officials. Two of those former officials. Lyman E. Norris. vice-president. and Harry Rosenblum, cashier, were arrested on warrants sworn by United States District Attorney


Article from The Omaha Morning Bee-News, June 28, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Spurway Rail Bank Receiver SHENANDOAH, Ia., June Spurway, of First bank, has been appointed receiver of the Brotherhood of Railway Clerks National bank, Cincinnati, which closed Thursday. Spurway has been here four years, being receiver of banks in Shenandoah, Malvern and Plattsmouth.


Article from The Pittsburgh Press, July 3, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

CENTRAL TRUST GETS CINCINNATI BANK CINCINNATI-The Brotherhood of Railway Clerks National Bank. which was closed a week ago, following a heavy run on the bank, has acquired by the Central Trust Company. third largest bank here It will hereafter be operated as branch of the Central Trust. Depositors of the brotherhood bank will be fully protected and their accounts will have the same status as before the institution closed. The receivership has been lifted and acquisition by J. W Pole, Comptroller of Currency. Farm Prices Lower WASHINGTON- decline of one point from May 15 to June 15 OCcurred in the Index of The General Level of Farm Prices, according to the Agricultural Department.


Article from Pittsburgh Sun-Telegraph, July 3, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Midland United Co. Trust Company Gets Brotherhood Bank Acquires Property The Midland United Company the larger part of the properties of the Union Traction Company of In. diana operates more than 400 of CINCINNATI July The Brotherhood of Railway Clerks National Bank which was closed week ago following a heavy run on the bank has been acquired by the Central Trust Company third largest bank here " will here. after be operated as & branch of the Central Trust Depositors of the Brotherhood bank will be fully protected and their accounts will have the name as before the The receivership has been lifted and acquisition authorized Pole. comptroller of cur rency


Article from Evening Star, July 6, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

RAILWAY CLERKS' BANK REOPENS DOORS AGAIN Is Now a Branch of Central Trust Co., One of Cincinnati's Largest State Institutions. By the Associated Press. CINCINNATI, Ohio, July 5.-The Brotherhood of Railway Clerks' National Bank, closed by its directors a week ago following a run of depositors, was reopened today as a branch of the Central Trust Co. There were some withdrawals, it was said, but these were more than offset by a large number of deposits in the first hour of business. The Central Trust Co. is one of Cincinnati's largest State banks. Its last published statement reported resources of $44,741,000.


Article from The Llano Colonist, July 19, 1930

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

CLERKS BANK SOLD, DEPOSITORS SAFE CINCINNATI-(FP)- All within the period of a week the Brotherhood of Railway Clerks Natl. Bank experienced the effects of a general Cincinnati bank panic, the withdrawal of $1,500,000 by depositors, the closing of the bank, the assurance of fed ral examiners that it was solvent, the lifting of the receivership and finally its sale to the Central Trust Co. Closed on June 26, it was pronounced thoroughly sound by the comptroller of the currency and turned over to its board, which sold the institution July 2. It reopened July 5 as a Cen-