9373. Second National Bank (Saginaw, MI)

Bank Information

Episode Type
Suspension → Closure
Bank Type
national
Bank ID
1918
Charter Number
1918
Start Date
February 14, 1933
Location
Saginaw, Michigan (43.419, -83.951)

Metadata

Model
gpt-5-mini
Short Digest
4dc3a0d6

Response Measures

None

Description

Articles (June 27, 1933) report the Second National Bank of Saginaw was closed after the Michigan banking holiday (Feb. 14) and placed in receivership; the receiver later sold the bank (sale price cited as $400,000). There is no explicit description of a depositor run on this specific Saginaw bank in these pieces. Cause for suspension attributed here to government_action (state banking holiday/official actions and subsequent receivership).

Events (3)

1. January 11, 1872 Chartered
Source
historical_nic
2. February 14, 1933 Suspension
Cause
Government Action
Cause Details
Bank did not reopen after the Michigan statewide banking holiday (Feb. 14, 1933); closed in the holiday's aftermath and placed under official control/receivership according to coverage.
Newspaper Excerpt
the Guardian National Bank of Commerce, which, with the First National did not reopen after the Michigan banking holiday
Source
newspapers
3. * Receivership
Newspaper Excerpt
The bank finally was purchased by R. Perry Shorts... The bank's receiver, however, held out for $500,000 and finally accepted $400,000, Wilkin testified.
Source
newspapers

Newspaper Articles (10)

Article from The Courier-Journal, June 27, 1933

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

DRAWING OF PROPOSED BREWERY derstood Jones was connected with but while he was testifying word was received from and from officials of the Houston bank that the R F. C. chairman had no connection with the Texas institution Firmly and with curt answers, Wilkin gave his story what he termed Wall Street plot.' in questioning Toy. before Judge Harry B Keidan, sitting as the is holding pubWilkin who remained on the stand all day. charged that the assets of the Second National Bank of Saginaw were undervalued by Federal Bank Examiners and charged was for the purpose of co-operating with 'fellows who wanted the bank back at price which was not equitable Most the Saginaw bank's stock was held by the Guardian group. The bank finally was purchased by R. Perry Shorts director of the New National Bank of Detroit. and group of associates Wilkins saving the price was He said their first of fer was 40 000 and after the group went into receivership. they reduced the offer to The bank's ceiver however held out for 000 and finally accepted $400,000. Wilkin Discussing trip to Washington. in which he conferred with G. Awalt then Comptroller of the Currency Wilkin said Awalt told him been too easy on you birds over the country. Now. we're going to be tough Did they get tough in any place except Michigan asked Judge Keidan can't find any other place,' he said But they were tough here?" "Yes sir plenty tough,' said Wilkin Mayor Frank Couzens. son of Senator and Mrs. Couzens, said this afternoon that Wilkin's testimony has been reported to correctly reveals that possession of only a part of the facts. Senator Couzens is in London delegate to the World Economic Conference and Mrs. Couzens is with him "no funds were transferred from the National Bank of Commerce any other bank with any that banking holiday would take During session Judge Keidan signed formal order di- rected to Secretary of the Treasury William H. Woodin requesting the appearance here of more than dozen Federal Secretary Woodin and Former Secretary Ogden L. Mills to testify before the jury concerning the banking holiday and events following it.


Article from News-Press, June 27, 1933

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Witness Says Closing Of Detroit Banks Was Plotted By Wall Street DETROIT. June witness' charge that ing Street plot Henry Ford financially was directbehind the closing of two tional banks in Detroit, tonight rested in the records of grand jury investigating the involved banking affairs. The charge made by Herbert Wilkin, Detroit banker, detailing his knowledge of affairs leading to the closing of the Guardian National Bank of Commerce, which, with the First tional Bank-Detroit, did not open after the Michigan banking holiday. Would Tie Up Ford Money Street believed it had chance. by tying up Ford's posits the Michigan banks." clared Wilkin, so deplete his working capital that he must deal them go broke. think they realized that here was the time to finish what they had started. But they were very sadfooled." Previously in his testimony the witness had startled his hearers the declaration that $4,000.was removed from the two banks before the statewide holiday was proclaimed He said two such withdrawals were those of Mrs. James Couzens, wife the Michigan senator, and the Second National Bank of Houston, Tex. Clear Checks After Holiday He also asserted that many checks had been cleared through the Detroit clearing house after the bank holiday had been de. clared. Houston, he said, was the home corporation. He proceeded in link the failure the Guardian National bank, from which he said the money was obtain an loan, with the the Houston with. saying the made, got the pression' weren't going to get the Jones No Connection In Wilkin said he understood Jones was connected the Houston bank, but while he was testifying word was ceived from Jones himself in Washington, and from officials Houston bank, that the chairman had no the Texas institution Firmly, and with curt gave his story of what he termed Wall Street in questioning by Prosecutor Harry Toy, before Judge Harry Keidan, sitting as the which holding public Bank Assets Undervalued who remained the stand day, charged that the assets the Second National bank of Seginaw were undervalued by federal bank examiners, and charged for purpose cooperating with "fellows who wanted the bank back price which was equitable." Most the Saginaw bank's stock was held by Guardian group. The bank finally was purchased Perry Shorts, director new National Bank of Detroit, group associates, Wilkin the price He said their first offer and, after the group into receivership, they duced the offer to The receiver, however, held for and finally accepted $400,000, Wilkin testified. Discussing trip to Washingin which he conferred with (Continued on Page Two)


Article from The Orlando Sentinel, June 27, 1933

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

FAILURES STREET (Continued from Page One) Jones himself Washington, and from officials of the Houston bank, that the chairman had connections with the Texas institution. UNFOLDS PLOT Firmly, and with curt answers, Wilkin story what termed the plot," tioning by Harry before Judge Harry ting the jury, which holding public sessions. remained on stand charged the assets of the second National bank Saginaw were federal bank and charged was the with "fellows wanted the bank price which equitable.' Most the Sagiheld by the Guardian The bank finally purchased Perry of the bank Detroit, and group Wilkin the price He said the group into the offer 000. The bank's receiver, held for and finally cepted $400,000. Wilkin testified. Discussing Washington, which he conferred with Awalt. then comptroller the Wilkin Awalt told been easy on birds the Now. going they tough any place except Michigan?' asked Judge dan. can't find any other they were tough here?" plenty tough, Wilkin.


Article from The Tampa Tribune, June 27, 1933

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BANK CLOSINGS LAID TO PLOT AGAINST FORD Detroit Banker Blames Wall Street DETROIT June Associated witness' charge that long-standing Wall street plot "strangle" Henry Ford financially lay directly behind the closing of two national banks in Detroit tonight rested in the one-man grand jury investigating the city's involved banking affairs. The charge made by Herbert R. Wilkin, Detroit banker, in detailing his knowledge of affairs leading up the closing of the Guardian National Bank which, with the First National did not reopen after the Michigan banking holiday. "Wall street believed it had chance, by tying up Ford's deposits in the Michigan banks," declared Wilkin. "to so deplete his working capital that he must deal with them go broke think they realized that here was the time to finish what they had started. But they were very sadly Previously in his testimony the witness had startled his hearers with the declaration that $4,000,000 was removed from the two banks before the statewide holiday was proclaimed Feb. He two such withdrawals were those Mrs. Jares Couzens, wife of the Michigan senator, and the Second National bank of Houston, Tex. Checks Cleared After Holiday He also asserted that many checks had been cleared through the Detroit clearing house bank holiday had been declared. Houston. he said, was the home town Jesse H. Jones, chairman of the Reconstruction Finance corporation. He proceeded in testimony link the failure of the Guardian National bank, from which he said the money withdrawn, to obtain loan, with the Houston withdrawals, saying "when the withdrawals were made, got the impression we weren't going to get the loan." In testimony, Wilkin said he understood Jones was connected with the Houston bank. but while he was testifying word was received from Jones in Washington, and from officials of the Houston bank, that the R. chairman had no connection with the Texas institution. Tells of "Plot" Firmly, and with curt answers, Wilkin gave his story of what he termed "the Wall street plot," in questioning by Prosecutor Harry S. Toy, before Judge Harry B. Keidan, sitting as the one-man jury, which is holding public sessions. Wilkin, who remained on the stand all day, charged that the assets of the Second National bank of Saginaw were under-valued by federal bank examiners, was for the purpose of cooperating with "fellows who wanted the bank back at price which was not equitable. Most of the Saganaw bank's stock was held by the Guardian group. Finally Purchased The bank finally was purchased by Perry Shorts, director the new National Bank of Detroit, and group of associates, Wilkin saying the price was $400,000. He said their first offer was $140,000, after the group went into receivership, they duced the offer to $54,000. The bank's receiver, however, held out for $500.- 000 and finally accepted Wilkin testified Discussing trip to Washington, in which conferred with F. G. Awalt, then comptroller of the currency Wilkin said Awalt told him: been too easy on you birds. all over the country. Now, goin. to be tough.' "Did they get tough in any place except Michigan?" asked Judge Keidan. can't find any other place," he said. "But they were tough here?" "Yes, sir, plenty tough,' said Wilkin. Couzens' Son Comments Mayor Frank Couzens, son of Senator and Mrs. Couzens, said this afternoon that 'Mr. Wilkin's testimony, if it has been reported to me correctly, reveals that in possession of only part of the facts. in London as delegate the world economic conference and Mrs. is with him. "Certainly. Mayor Couzens continued, "no funds were transferred from the National Bank Commerce or any other bank with any knowledge that banking holiday would take place.'


Article from Standard-Speaker, June 27, 1933

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

derstood Jones was connected with the Houston bank, but while he was testifying word was received from Jones himself in Washington, and from officials of the Houston bank, that the R. F. C. chairman had no connections with the Texas institution. Firmly, and with curt answers, Wilkins gave his story of what he termed "the Wall Street plot,' in questioning by Prosecutor Harry S. Toy, before Judge Harry S. Keidan, sitting as the one-man jury, which is holding public sessions, Wilkin, who remained on the stand all day, charged that the assets of the Second National Bank of Saginaw were under-valued by federal bank examiners, and charged it was for the pupose of cooperating with "fellows who wanted the bank back at a price which was not equitable." Most of Saginaw bank's stock was held by the Guardian group. The bank finally was purchased by R. Perry Shorts, director of the new National Bank of Detroit, and a group of associates, Wilkin saying the price was $400,000. He said their first offer was $140,000, and, after the group went into ership, they reduced the offer to $54,000. The bank's receiver, however, held out for $500,000 and finally accepted $400,000. Wilkin testified. Discussing trip to Washington, in which he conferred with G. Awalt, then comptroller of the currency, Wilkin said Awalt told him: "We've been too easy on you birds all over the country. Now, going to be tough." "Did they get tough in any place except Michigan," asked Judge Keidan. "I can't find any other place," he said. "But they were tough here "Yes, sir, plenty tough," said Mayor Frank Couzens, son of Senator and Mrs. Couzens, said this afternoon that "Mr. Wilkin's testimony, if it has been reported to me correctly, reveals that he is in possession of only a part of the facts." Senator Couzens in London as a delegate to the world economic conference and Mrs. Couzens is with him. "Certainly," Mayor Couzens continued, "no funds were transferred from the National Bank of Commerce or any other bank with any knowledge that a banking holiday would take place." He said that while his father's family was living in Washington, "the Detroit Trust Company was used to collect monies from coupons and each month the collected funds were transferred through the National Bank of Commerce to the Riggs National Bank in Washington. This had been the custom over a period of several years." The mayor added that "I certainly do not know what was behind his (Wilkin's) statement." BRITAIN IS BEING PRESSED BY FRANCE (Continued From Page One.) LONDON, June 26. France is bringing tremendous pressure on Great Britain to hitch the pound sterling to the franc, it was learned on high authority tonight, in an effort to form stabilized currency bloc with the dollar excluded. The French were laboring to prevent Holland and Switzerland from leaving the gold standard as an international ring of exchange bear operators were blamed in gold bloc quarters for today's heavy fall in the guilder from 8.46½ to 8.58 Dutch guilders to the pound. Such a stabilization, the high authority said, would mean direct opposition to the apparent American plan to induce the world to accept President Roosevelt's price-raising program which the gold bloc believes would mean depreciation of their currency. The speech of Senator James Couzens, of Michigan, before the world economic conference today was interpreted by the gold bloc as an announcement of the intention of Raymond Moley, assistant United States secretary of state, who will arrive tomorrow, to ask Europe "to move in concert with the United States." The French worked persistently today to set up an European stabilized currency group, it was said, about which Scandinavian satellites of sterling could find a haven. The British answer to the French move has not yet been made, it was learned. The British, it was said, were hesitating to peg sterling until they are certain the rise of prices in America will be sufficient to offset the dollar's depreciation. If prices fail to rise high enough to prevent American dollars selling too cheaply in world markets, the British, it was declared, were unwilling to fix the pound at definite point. "The French plan would settle the franc and sterling rate at the present level," the high banking authority asserted, "and it would mean the de facto stabilization of the pound on gold. "The sterling has not fluctuated widely recently in relation to the franc, and the French scheme would, therefore, be freezing the existing ratio. The French idea is to let the dollar run loose by ignoring it, as sterling was ignored shortly after Great Britain left gold.' The French believe Europe should go ahead and stabilize despite America's refusal to peg the dollar momentarily. Bankers at the world economic conference said discussions on monetary policy with several out-and-out partisans of inflation tended to shake confidence of the currencies still on gold. Dutch delegates, among them President Tripp of the Netherlands Bank, said that with 67 per cent gold coverage Holland could withstand asaults of the speculators as long as the Dutch themselves keep confidence. Swiss fears of depreciation were expressed to the Associated Press by President Bachmann of the National Bank, who declared: "Our financial authorities and the public in general are opposed to monetary tampering because they know currency depreciation is just palliative which brings a lower standard of life and a general loss of savings." Feeling against "the internaitional speculative ring" ran high among the gold bloc delegates. The president of one national bank said, "I would like to hang the entire ring." LONDON, June 26. (P)-Senator James Couzens, American delegate, said today it was time the world economic conference made a concrete move to relieve debtors, raise prices and increase the demand for raw materials. Both the Michigan Senator and Neville Chamberlain, British Chancellor of the Exchequer, urged negotiations between debtors and creditors, in speeches before a monetary sub-commission. The conference appeared to be hitting its stride at the start of the third week with pronounced progress toward international COoperation to rehabilitate wheat and silver. Australian adherence to the American wheat acreage restriction plan, along with Canada and Argentina, the other big exporters, appeared nearer tonight after conference between Henry L. Morgenthau, Sr., American representative, and Stanley M. Bruce, of Australia. India, world's largest holder of silver, indicated adherence to the American silver rehabilitation plan. China, Mexico and South American countries are backing the Americans and Canada is the only other big producer to be heard from. Delegates from the gold standard


Article from The Miami Herald, June 27, 1933

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

THREAT OF FISTICUFFS MARKS BANK HEARING Continued From Page "very hot and stuffy" in the crowded little room, and the hearing was sumed. Later Dodds and Neely shook hands. BANKER REVEALS PLOT AGAINST HENRY FORD DETROIT, June 26. (/P)-A witness' charge that long-standing Wall Street plot to "strangle" Henry Ford financially was directly behind the closing of two banks in tonight rested in the records of a oneman grand jury investigating the city's involved banking affairs. The charge made by Herbert R Wilkin, Detroit banker, in detailing his knowledge of affairs leading up to the closing of the Guardian National Bank of Commerce, which, with the First National did not reopen after the Michigan holiday. "Wall Street it had chance, by tying up the Michigan declared Wilkins, "to so deplete his working capital that he must deal with them or go broke. think they realized that here was the time to finish what they had started. But they were very sadly fooled. Previously in his testimony the wit. ness had his hearers with the declaration that was from the two banks before the statewide holiday was proclaimed February 14. He such withdraw were those of Mrs. James Couzens, wife of the Michigan senator, and the Second National Bank of Houston, Texas He also asserted that many checks had been cleared through the Detroit Clearing House after the bank holiday had been declared. Houston, he said, was the home town of Jesse H. of the Reconstruction Finance He proceeded in testimony to link the failure of the Guardian National Bank. from which he said the money was withdrawn. to obtain C. loan, with the Houston withdrawals, saying, "When the withdrawals were made, got the impression we weren't going to get the loan. In testimony. Wilkin said he understood Jones with the Houston bank, but while he was testifying word received from Jones himself in Washington, and from officials of the Houston bank that the Reconstruction Finance chairman had no connections with the Texas institution. Firmly. and with curt answers, Wilkin gave his story of what he termed "the Wall Street plot," in questioning by Prosecutor Harry S. Toy, before Judge Harry B. Keidan, sitting as the one-man jury, which is holding public sessions. Wilkin, who remained on the stand all day, charged that the assets of the Second National Bank of Saginaw were by federal bank examiners, and charged it was for the purpose of co-operating with "fellows who wanted the bank back at a price which was not equitable. Most of the Saginaw bank's stock was held by the Guardian group. The bank finally was purchased by R. Perry director of the New Bank of Detroit, and group of associates, Wilkin saying the price was $400,000. He said their first offer $140,000, and, after the group went into receivership, they reduced the offer to $54,000. The bank's receiver, however, held out for $500,000 and finally accepted $400,000. Wilkin testified Discussing trip to Washington, in which he with then comptroller of the Wilkin said Awalt told him: been to easy on you birds all over the country. Now, we're going to tough. "Did they get tough in any place except Michigan,' asked Judge Keidan. can't find any other place," he said. "But they were tough here?" "Yes, sir, plenty tough," said Wilkin.


Article from The Lexington Herald, June 27, 1933

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

"WALL STREET PLOT" CLAIMED BY WITNESS FROM PAGE ONE holiday had been he said. the home Jesse H. Jones, chairman Finance CorHe proceeded in to link the failure of the National from he said the money was to C. loan the Houston "when the made, got the impression going get the Wilkin said he unJones was with Houston but while he the was testifying was received from Jones himself in from officials of the Houston and bank, that the R. no connections with the Texas institution. Firmly, and with curt answers, gave his story of what he termed "the Wall Street plot," in questioning by Harry before Judge Harry B. Keidan, sitting the jury. which is holding public ses. Wilkin, who remained on the stand all day, charged that the assets of the Second National Bank Saginaw were under-valued by federal bank examiners, and charged It was for the purpose of co-operating with "fellows who wanted the bank back at price which was not equitable.' Most of the Saginaw stock was held by the group. The bank finally was purchased Perry Shorts, of the National Bank of Detroit, and of Wilkins sayprice was He said their first offer was and, after the group went into ship, they reduced the offer to $54,000. The bank's receiver, how. ever. held out for $500,000 and finally accepted $400,000, Wilkin testified. a. trip to Washington, in which he conferred with F. G. Awalt, then comptroller of the currency, Wilkin said Awalt told him: "We've been too easy on you birds all over the country. Now going to be tough.' "Did they get tough in any place except Michigan? asked Judge Keidan. can't find any other place," he "But they were tough here?" "Yes, sir, plenty tough," said Wilkin.


Article from Henryetta Daily Free-Lance, June 27, 1933

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Witness Says Plan to Cripple Him Back of Closing IRREGULAR CHECK ACTION CHARGED Planned of His Working Capital, Is Allegation June witness charge that long-standing Wall Street plot to "strangle" Henry Ford directly behind the closing of two national banks in Detroit today the records of one-man grand jury investigating the city's banking affairs. The charges the most sensational in weeks of open testimony, was made by Herbert Wilkin, Detroit banker, in detailing his knowledge of affairs leading to the closing of he Guardian National Bank of Commerce, which, with the First National Bank, Detroit did not reop after the Michigan banking holiday. Street believed had chance, by tying up Ford's déposits the Michigan banks," declared Wilkto so deplet his working capital that he must deal with them broke. think they realiezd that the time finish what they started. But they were sadfooled." in his testimony the had startled hearers with the declaration that moved from the two banks before the holiday proclaimed He said two such of Michigan senator, and the Record National bank of Texas. He also asserted that many checks had been cleared through the Detroit clearing house after the bank holiday had been declar Houston, was the home town Jesse H. Jones, chairman of the Reconstruction Finance Corp. He ceeded in testimony to link failure of the Guardian National Bank, from which he the money was withdrawn, to obtain loan with the Houston withdrawals, 'when the withdrawals were made, the impression we going get the loan." In testimony, Wilkin said he derstood Jones connected with the Houston bank, but while he was tustifying word was received from Jon himself, Washington, from ofthe Houston bank that the R. chairman had no connections with the Texas institution. Firmly, and with curt answers, Wilkin gave his story of what termed Wall plot," in ques. Moning by Prosecutor Harry Toy before Judge Harry Keidan, sitting the one-man jury, which holdsessions. Wilkin charged that the assets of the Second National Bank of Saginaw by federal bank xainmers, and charged for the purpose of co-operating with "fellows who wanted the bank stock price which not Most of he bank's stock was held the Guardian group. hTe bank finally was purchased by Perry of the New National Bank of and group Wilkins saying the price He said their first and, after the group into r veivership, they reduced offer to $54,000. The bank's however held out for $500,000 finally accepted $400,000, Wilkins


Article from Okmulgee Daily Times, June 27, 1933

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Wall Street Plot to Whip Ford Behind Bank Closings In Detroit, Banker Charges ETROIT June 26. (/P)-A witness' charge that long-standing Wall street plot to "strangle" Henry Ford lay directly behind the closing of two national banks Detroit tonight rested one-man grand jury investigating the city's involved banking affairs. The charge, the most sensational in two weeks of open testimony. made by Herbert R. Detroit detailing his knowlaffairs leading to the closing of the Guardian National up Bank Commerce, which, with the First National did not reopen after the Michigan WITHERING HEAT holiday. street believed it had chance by tying up Ford's deposits in the Michigan banks," declared Wilkin, "to so deplete his working capital that he must deal with them or go broke. think they REGION WIDE realized that here was the time finish what they had started. But they were sadly fooled." Slight Relief Promised in Previously in his testimony the witness had startled his hearers with the declaration that $4,000,000 removed from the two banks before the statewide holiday was proclaimed Feb. 14. He said two such withdrawals were those of Mrs. James Couzens, wife of the Michigan senator, and the Second National bank of Houston. Texas. He also asserted that many checks had been cleared through the Detroit clearing house after the bank holiday had been declared. Houston, he said, the home of Jesse H. Jones, chairman of the Finance He proceeded in testimony to link the failure of the Guardian National bank, from which he said the money was withdrawn, obtain loan with the Houston withdrawals, saying "when the withdrawals were made, the impression going get the In testimony, Wilkin said he Jones connected with the Houston bank, but while testifying word ceived from Jones himself Washington, and from officials of the Houston bank, that the R. chairman had connections with the Texas institution. Firmly, and with curt answers, Wilkin gave story what termed "the Wall street in questioning by Prosecutor Harry Toy, before Judge Harry B. Keidan, sitting the jury, which is holding public sessions. Wilkin, remained the stand day, charged that as the Second National bank of Saginaw were undervalued by federal examiners, and charged for the purpose of cooperating with wanted the bank stock price which was not equitable.' Most the Saginaw stock held by the Guardian group. The bank finally was purchased by Perry Shorts, bank of Detroit, and group of ing the price was $400,000. He said their first offer was and, after the group went into they reduced the offer $54,000. The bank's receiver, however, held out for finally accepted $400,000, Wilkin testified.


Article from Florence Morning News, June 27, 1933

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Declares Wall Street Sought Bankrupt Ford CONTINUED FROM PAGE ONE the impression we weren't going to get the loan. In testimony, Wilkin said he unJones was connected with the Houston bank, but while he was testifying word was received from Jones himself in Washington. and from officials the Houston bank, that the R. F. chairman had no connections with the Texas institution. Firmly and with curt answers, Wilkin his story what he termed Wall street plot, in questioning by prosecutor Harry Toy. before Judge Harry B. Keidan, sitting as one-man jury, which is holding public sessions. Wilkin, who remained on the stand charged that the as sets the Second National Bank of Saginaw were under by federal bank examiners, and charged was for the purpose cooperating with "fellows who wanted bank back at price which was not equitable Most the Saginaw Bank's stock was held the Guardian group. The bank finally was purchased by Perry Shorts, director of the National Bank of Detroit. and group of associates, Wilkin ing the price was $400,000. He said their first offer was $140,000. and, after the group went into re- ceivership. they reduced the offer to $54,000. The bank's receiver. however, held out for $500,000 and finally accepted $400,000, Wilkin Discussing trip to Washington, in which he conferred with F. Awalt. comptroller the currency, Wilkin said Awalt told been too easy on you birds all over the country. Now. going to be tough "Did you get tough in any place except Michigan,' asked Judge Keidan. can't find any other place," he said. "But they were tough here?" "Yes. sir, plenty tough,' said Wilkin.