Click image to open full size in new tab
Article Text
of the previous question, at about 7 o'clock, when the
vote was taken-ayes 78, noes 40. So the House has
virtually determined that the Banks shall resume before
the 1st of January next. Successive motions were then
made to fill the blank with the months of April, May
and November; but, without taking a vote, the House
adjourned. The action of the Legislatures of Pennsyl-
vania and Maryland has doubtless exercised considerable
influence upon the decision of this question-the former
having passed a law requiring instant resumption, and
the latter extending the period to the 1st of May. I
shall not be surprised if the same day be fixed here; al-
though it is probable that the 1st of August will finally
be agreed upon. I hope we shall get through the bill on
Monday.
The debate took a wide range of course, involving
federal politics as well as State policy. The last
speech of Mr. Holleman, which occupied about two
hours in its delivery, though conflicting with all my
opinions, was ingenious, able and effective. In his first
speech he had expressed his gratification that the mob of
Cincinnati had taken the matter into their own hands,
and referred, with a triumphant air, to the effect which
the late tumultuary meetings in Baltimore had exerted
upon the conduct of the Banks in that city-qualifying
his remarks, however, by a rather contradictory expres-
sion of his disapprobation of the mobocratic principle.-
In other words, he thought mobs wrong in the abstract;
but in the particular instance referred to he was glad that
it had taken place. Nor did I see any thing, in his sub-
sequent defence, to extricate himself from the awkward
dilemma in which he was involved. It is in vain for a
man to say that mobs are to be deprecated, when in the
very next breath he expresses his delight that one has
just taken place, by which houses were demolished,
vaults broken open and robbed, and the books and pa-
pers of the objects of its vengeance destroyed and scat-
tered to the four winds of heaven. To-morrow, indeed,
this same mob, or another, incited to action by its success
might take it into its head that every man of wealth
ought to be despoiled of the fruits of enterprize and in-
dustry, to be equally divided among those to whom fu-
tune had been more parsimonious, or who had wasted
their substance by idleness and profligacy. How could
a man condemn the latter, who had, in his legislative
seat, expressed his gratification at the triumph of the
former? Is he always to judge when they are right,
and when wrong? And may not others approve where
he condemns, and denounce where he defends? Of all
countries in the world, our's is the last in which a mob
can be justified, because our's is a government of laws,
emanating directly from the people, who always hold in
their own hand, the power of correcting mischiefs ori-
ginating in bad law, by a discreet and wise exercise of
the elective franchise. And yet in our country, above all
others, is the mobocratic spirit most easily aroused and
put into action, from the absence of that despotic ener-
gy and summary punishment which it is certain to en-
counter under other governments. Public opinion is its
main restraint here; and hence the impolicy, not to say
the danger of the avowal of such sentiments, even quali-
fied as they were, such as those which Mr. Holleman
thought proper to utter, shocking his own friends as well
as others. For he not only said he was "glad" that the
Cincinnati mob had occurred, and that the premonitory
symptoms of a similar outbreak had awed the Banks of
Baltimore into resumption, but he declared that here, in
Virginia, there must be prompt resumption, or liquida-
tion, or a like manifestation of popular indignation and
resentment-which, indeed, it seemed, from the tenor
of his remarks, he was prepared to justify and defend.
Mr. Hiden, of Orange, took up the same note, and read
a letter from one of his constituents, who declared that he
was prepared to join a force for the purpose of marching
to the Banks, and forcing them, by violence, to open
their vaults, or to close their doors. To make no com-
ment upon the atrocity of such sentiments-atrocious
under any circumstances, but doubly so when it is re-
membered that the Banks have been justified in the pol-
icy of suspension by the repeated sanction of the law-
making power, the question naturally occurs, of whom
are these mobs generally composed? Do men who have
any stake in society participate in, or lead them on?-
No: they are for the most part constituted of the very
dregs of the city sewers-"the cankers of a rude world
and a long peace"-such as would have followed Jack
Cade in his crusade against "reading and writing" as
the most abominable crimes, and done honor to Falstaff's
shirtless regiment. Of the mob in Cincinnati, for ex-
ample, it has been estimated by those who saw the mot-
ley throng of which it was composed, that all of them
together had not a hundred dollars of the notes of the
institutions which they were so eager to sack for specie,
and from which they plundered more than they could
have earned by a year's wages; while the character of
the throngs in Baltimore may be inferred from the fact
that one of their oracles-one who addressed them on the
evils of a paper currency, and led the way in the great
work of reform, had not finished his harangue, before,
being hurried off to the police office, he was recognized
as a petty thief, who had a few days before, in the ex-
cess of his love for the precious metals, stolen a set of
silver spoons! Precious reformers of the currency, these!
Of vast importance must it be to them that the Banks
shall speedily resume specie payments!
But, in my estimation, however beneficial this mobo-
cratic action may have been in Baltimore; and it is not
unlikely that the apprehension of it may been equally
influential in Philadelphia,-in facilitating a resumption
of specie payments, a system of policy, based upon it,
ought to have exerted no sort of influence upon the course
of the Virginia Legislature, in hastening specie payments
here. I know it has all along been said that our Banks
were ready and willing to resume cotemporaneously with
those of Philadelphia and Baltimore; but this opinion
was based upon the supposition that the banks of those
cities would not resume until, from an enlightened sur-
vey of the whole field, and after a comparison of their
resources with their liabilities they were convinced that
they could maintain their ground-not that they would
be forced to resume prematurely, against their wish-
es, and with doubts and fears as to the result, under
the coercive influence of an apprehension that they
would be visited by a similar mob.