Article Text
-MURPHY JUDGES, INC. A FEW CORPORATION LAWYERS ON "CLEAN BENCH" TICKET. M. Warley Platzek, Counsel for Beer Trust Firm, Which Hearst Papers Attacked -Erlanger for Theatrical Combine -Was a Friend of David Rothschild. Mr. Hearst and his newspapers have repeatedly referred to the judiciary ticket put by the Nominators as "a tioket made up entirely of corporation attorneys." He professes to favor a clean, upright bench entirely free from corporation control, but hehas remained silent about the charges brought in this line against some of the candidates running on the ticket which was the result of a bargain between himself and Charles F. Murphy. M. Warley Platzek, who was put on the ticket for Supreme Court Justice by order of Murphy, long has been engaged in defending corporations and he is himself the and director one at the president least, Fidelity Coal in and corporation Iron Comof Tennessee. He was active as counpany Govsel in the criminal proceedings of the ernment against the beef trust in Chicago and was connected in a legal way with the case of the Schwarzschild & Sulzberger Company. which finally entered a plea of guilty, upon which four of its officers were fined $25,000 by Judge Humphrey on Sentember 21 of last year. Mr. Hearst's newspapers have time and again scored the beef trust for its methods of doing business. Mr. Platzek also is said to be counsel for the United Cigar Stores, about whose business methods so many retail tobacco dealers complain. Another corporation lawyer on the Murphy-Hearst ticket is Mitchell L. Erlanger. He is a brother of the theatrical manager and is attorney for the theatrical trust, the Klaw & Erlanger Building and Construction Company and the New York Theatre Company. It was the theatrical trust that barred James Metcalfe, the dramatic critic, from its theatres. Erlanger was a friend of David Rothschild, who wrecked the Federal Bank and the Globe Security Company, in which many people on the East Side lost the savings of their lives. Erlanger was a depositor there personally and he also deposited in the bank some of the funds that he held as Sheriff. But he got the money out before the crash came. When Erlanger was running for Sheriff Rothschild sent out hundreds of personal letters begging his friends to help the Tammany candidate. These letters read: 'As my friend Mitchell L. Erlanger has been nominated by the Democratic party for Sheriff of the county of New York, and as I am greatly interested in the success of his candidacy as well as the success of the entire Democratic ticket, [should esteem it a personal favor if you would contribute something toward the expense of the campaign. "Please draw your check to the order of James W. Gerard, chairman finance com- will mittee, and mail the same to me and I personally attend to its delivery. "DAVID ROTHSCHILD." Erlanger has since denied that he was friend of Rothschild or that he ever got a a cent of campaign money from him. Another candidate on the Murphy-Hearst ticket who had close corporation connections is J. J. Brady. whose nomination was made as a favor to Louis F. Haffen, the Tammany boss of The Bronx. Brady, it is said, has had a finger in every real estate pie that has been cut in The Bronx in the He last ten years and be is now a rich man. is a director and an active worker in the Geiszler-Haa Realty Company. which has put through some big deals recently. He is also interested largely as a stockholder and director in the Sound Realty Company, the Manhattan Mortgage Company and the Bronx Borough Bank Charles L. Guy, another candidate on the Murphy Hearst ticket. is also a corporation man, being director in the Washington Heights Realty Company. And even John the Ford, one of the men who were put on adticket through the demand of Hearst, mitted yesterday that he was a corporation lawyer, too, being counsel for the Queen Accident and Guarantee Corporation of London, which does an accident, burglary and credit insurance business all over the world. He said he was sorry that he did not have more corporations to represent and that he would not draw the line at even the sugar trust. He hastened to add that he was no friend of the predatory corporations such the Ryan-Belmont merger, the beef as trust and the gas combine but said that he believed that corporations when properly conducted were good things.