7971. Peninsular Bank (Detroit, MI)

Bank Information

Episode Type
Suspension โ†’ Reopening
Bank Type
state
Start Date
October 1, 1857
Location
Detroit, Michigan (42.331, -83.046)

Metadata

Model
gpt-5-mini
Short Digest
b07f4353d24c62c2

Response Measures

None

Description

Article 1 describes Peninsular Bank (chartered 1849) suspending payments Oct 1, 1857 due to injunction proceedings by the attorney general (insufficient securities), then resuming operations Feb 15, 1858. Later it discontinued operations in 1870 (appears voluntary winding down after National Bank Act). No run is described.

Events (3)

1. October 1, 1857 Suspension
Cause
Government Action
Cause Details
Injunction proceedings instituted by the state attorney general alleging securities insufficient to protect billholders; bank suspended payments Oct. 1, 1857.
Newspaper Excerpt
the suspension of the bank by reason of injunction proceedings instituted by the attorney general because the securities not deemed sufficient to protect the billholders.
Source
newspapers
2. February 15, 1858 Reopening
Newspaper Excerpt
On February 15, 1858, resumed its operations.
Source
newspapers
3. January 1, 1870* Other
Newspaper Excerpt
in 1870 discontinued operations. All outstanding bank bills were paid, the stockholders getting back about 20 per cent of their investment.
Source
newspapers

Newspaper Articles (2)

Article from Detroit Free Press, May 10, 1931

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

The Old Financial Center ment plus a surplus of 13 per cent. BANK OF ST. CLAIR. This bank was chartered in March 28, 1836, capital $250,000. It was located Palmer, St. Clair county, with John Clark as president, and Wesley Trusdail as cashier. In 1842 the bank moved to Detroit with Jesse Smith as president, and took quarters in the old Michigan State Bank building on Jefferson avenue, between Woodward avenue and Bates street. In 1842, A. S. Williams became president. as successor to Jesse Smith. and in turn was succeeded in 1845 by Levi Cook. In this year the bank failed. DETROIT SAVINGS BANK. This bank was incorporated on March 1848. and still survives under the hustling initiative of Walter L. Dunham. The bank began busi ness in May. 1849, with Elon Farnsworth as president, and H. N. Walker as vice-president. Among its directors were David Smart. Samuel Lewis nad Levi Cook, and B. B. Kercheval. Its first place of business was northeast corner of Griswold and Woodbridge streets under the name "Detroit Savings Fund Institute.' After moving successively to the west side of Woodward avenue (next to George Kirby's leather store). to Griswold street in the Waterman block, the bank finally in July, 1871. occupied its own building at the northeast corner of Griswold and Larned streets, where it continued until it moved to the Chamber of Com merce building recently purchased for the purpose. Its old building at Griswold and Larned was two years ago torn down to make room for the new Union Trust building The bank started without capital but in July, 1871, upon the com pletion of its then new building. it assumed the name "Detroit Sav ings bank." and was capitalized at $200,000 (since increased to $1,500.000). At first the bank was only open on Mondays. Wednesdays and PENINSULAR BANK. This bank was chartered March 28. 1849. capital $100,000 Among the incorporators were Charles Howard. Gurdon Williams, Benjamin B. Kercheval, Henry P. Bridge. Brown Charles Howard was elected president, and H. H. Brown. cashier. moved into the Farmers and Mechanics bank building which it has purchased for $2,000. On April 28. 1856, the capital was increased to $350,000 and in August an extra dividend of 25 per cent from surplus profits was divided among the stockholders. But after this, business fell off and losses multiplied. The panic of 1857 came on and on October 1, 1857, the president an nounced to the directors, the suspension of the bank by reason of injunction proceedings instituted by the attorney general because the securities not deemed sufficient to protect the billholders. The business was then placed in the hands of committee of four directors. and H O. Mass was elected as president Messrs. George K. Johnson and H. P. Pulling were thereafter chosen succes sively in his stead The office of cashier was successively filled by H. H. Brown. C. M. Davison, E. Wendell and M. F. Dow. On December 19, 1857. the stockholders were invited to lend to the bank 25 per cent of their stockholdings The bank accordingly on February 15, 1858, resumed its operations. After the passage of the National Bank Act, the bank did little business and in 1870 discontinued operations All outstanding bank bills were paid, the stock holders getting back about 20 per cent of their investment. FIRST NATIONAL BANK. The First National bank was the first bank in Detroit to be organized under the national bank act of 1863. It was largely promoted by the efforts of Philo Parsons. A preliminary meeting for organization was held on June 21, 1863. It was followed August 5 by the first meeting of stockholders, at which articles of association. by-laws, etc., were adopted. Its directors included Philo Par sons, W. McPherson, I. Mills, John James, E. G. Merrick, M. B. Kean, J. N. Ford and John Hosmer On November 16 the bank opened for business in the old office of Parsons & Fisher in the Rotunda building, southeast corner of Gris wold and Larned streets. In De cember, 1864, the franchise was purchased by the officers of the State Bank of Michigan, and on January 1. 1865, the bank was reorganized and moved to the southeast corner of Jefferson ave nue and Griswold street, the place it occupied for 41 years, in 1908 it moved to the Ford build ing and again in 1922 to its own. the First National Bank building, the site of the old Russell house, later the Pontchartrain hotel. Its official staff is too well known to need repetition here. SECOND NATIONAL BANK. Second National bank was opened for business November 4, 1863. with capital of $500,000. H. P. Baldwin, president: C. cashier. and C. H. Buhl. E B. Ward. Duncan Stewart, Chancery James F. Joy, John remained in its first location in the the First National bank In the were added to the directorate. AMERICAN NATIONAL BANK. American National bank was organized in 1865 with a capital of $250,000. soon increased to $400.000. with directors who included A. H. Dey, president: Franklin Moore. M Mason, Eber Ward. John J Bagley, Charles Root, M. S. Smith, Edward Kantin and Jacob S. Far rand. W. Morton was the first cashier, followed in a short time by George B. Sartwell. To the directors were added Simon J. Mur phy. Alex. Chapoton, S. Heavenrich, Thomas W Palmer and William A. Moore. The bank first OCcupied quarters at No. 89 Griswold street, then moved to the Newberry & McMillan building. then to the Union Trust building. where it was taken over by the Old Detroit National and eventual ly passed into the First National organization. PEOPLES SAVINGS BANK. Peoples Savings bank was organized January 1, 1871, capital $30,000. with Francis Palms as president, and Charles Ducharme, Patrick Fitzsimmons, A. Kaarer, J. Schulte, A. Putte, M. W. O'Brien, Jeremiah Dwyer. F. F. Palms and William B. Moore among the directors Originally located at 37 Jefferson avenue, on April 22. 1872, it moved to the southeast corner of Congress and Griswold streets, whence it moved to the Moffat building at the southwest corner of Griswold and Fort streets. The bank later was merged with the State Savings as the Peoples State bank, now the Peoples Wayne County bank. George H. Barbour was one of the first directors of the Peoples Savings. and at this writing enjoys the distinction of being the oldest (in point of service) bank director in Detroit. WAYNE COUNTY SAVINGS BANK. Wayne County Savings bank was organized October 2. 1871, capital $30,000. soon increased to $150,000. William B. Wesson was the first president: H. Kiefer, vice-president; S. Dow Elwood secretary and treasurer The directors or trustees included William B. Wesson, S. D. Elwood, John J. Bag ley, William A. Moore. Jerome Croul, Jefferson Wiley, M. S Smith, D. M Ferry. P Knight, Paul Gies, Traugott Schmidt, W. C. Dun can, T. W Palmer. H Kiefer, K. C. Barker and J. S. Farrand. Located first at the northwest corner of Griswold and Congress streets, the bank on December 5, 1876, moved to its own building on Congress street in rear of its first place of business Later this bank merged with the Home Sav ings bank under the title Wayne County and Home Savings bank subsequently merged into the Peoples Wayne County bank In 1879, when was admitted to the bar, the outstanding bankers of the Detroit First were National Emory Wendell of bank: Alexan der H of the American tional bank, and S. Dow Elwood Na of bankers con ing not 80 much to financial state ments as to the confidence in his own judgment of men. It might be said of him. was once said of Sidney D. Miller A borrower would prefer to be refused by him rather than to have his loan grant ed by another Mr. Dey was strong-featured man. gruff in man ner but kindly of heart. Mr. El wood was pioneer of savings banking Of those who followed the greatest banker was Alexander McPherson, of the Second National bank. Mr. George H. Russel of the Peoples. now the Peoples Wayne County bank, typified the human banker who understood hu man nature and thereby won host of friends without risk to his Today mergers or consolidations are the order of the day The banks of Detroit today consist of the two major groups: (a) The First National Group composed of the Peoples Wayne County bank, the First National bank, the Bank of Michigan the Peninsular State bank, the Detroit Trust company, (b) The Guardian Detroit Union Group, composed of the Guardian Detroit bank. the National Bank of Commerce, the Guardian Trust company and the Union Trust com pany, the Keane Higbie company and the Michigan Industrial bank There should also be added the independent banks. such as the Detroit Savings bank This realignment of recent origin is too well known to require elab oration.


Article from Lansing State Journal, September 20, 1933

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BANKS MAY PAY OUT Couzens Claims He Was Prevented from Giving Additional Testimony (Concluded from page finance in the management of the banks whose affairs came before him." The findings the judge, made Monnight after conclusion of testimony, were that there was evidence of criminality moral turpitude in the conduct the banks, and that the institutions were solvent the time they closed. "Prosecutor Harry S. Toy. however. quoted as saying the grand jury hearings forever disposed of holding companies for banks." said the senator's "The holding company plans for the control of banks never should been permitted and the creation of them was obviously for the purpose of getting around the intent In his first appearance before the jury the senator criticized the "orgy of through holding which, he said, large extent for Detroit banking difficulties. He had defendthe government's closing the banks. and stated that officials of institutions knew their banks were insolvent long before they closed. "My primary object continuing this, what many people call some fight, prevent by statute and public opinion possibility recurrence of these conditions," said the statement. "While may be nied forum in my own state, have the senate forum to expose and discuss unethical and improperpractices. tend to available means command to inform the people the banking practices engaged in all Detroit banks, and the the Detroit Bankers company and the Guardian Detroit Union The statement of the senator declared that up to this time, have not but fraction the reprehensible practices engaged they will have patience to pend judgment the Detroit bankers until all available information mitted, have no fear of the ultimate verdict of public opinion," said the senator. Text of Statement The statement follows the grand jury has concluded, liberty matters which not feel free discuss while the grand jury was was nothing in the grand jury hearing which any way, understand affected payoff There much money as the receivers had, with whatever amount the reconstruction finance corporatation could advance on adequate My advice from the comptroller of the currency was that his concern over the jury hearing related only to the openof the old press reports now seems that the drive to get much money for the through from the possible, and with that in hearty accord. When comes the consideration of whether the old banks are to be opened obvious that the comptroller of the currency must take into consideration who are run the and when they are opened That was the emphasis made by the comptroller of the rency the several talks had with him, plus, of assesshe had made and which are being the courts. "Prior my going on the grand witness stand all had in conference with bankers and in writing plan the First National bank. On August 1933, Mr. Edward McDonald Miller. Paddock and Stone wrote letter inclosing copy plan for reorganization of the First Mr. of the and of the currency Mr. MacDonald's letter said: relating to sessment liability modified (although the plan was not rewritten) the further suggestion that the assessment stand levied 100 percent. 10 percent to be paid cash and 90 percent in the earnings on stock allocated to the depositors until they were paid full. Another Letter "Then on August Mr. MacDonald wrote another letter which he plan for the the First National only change of any consequence is in Paragraph two, which in effect withdraws the proposal for compromise of assessliability. The features of this ment plan were vigorously objected to Comptroller O'Connor me over the telephone primarily the sessment not to go positors. but was retained by the stockholders. This being the last status of any negotiations, correspondence the banking group, of course did not know was contemplated by them only to for payoff through advances from the "This, therefore, seems to me to leave the matter ready immediate action, on assumption. press reports are correct, that the the comptroller and the through have concluded their appraisal assets sufficiently to them how much they can adfor the payoff. know of no vance reason why this cannot be immediatedone "When it comes to consideration of the the old banks, however, if consideration to be given to then vitally important to the government, to the depositors, and to people as to who the bank. Let us look for moment to who are responsible for the of the Detroit Bankers that who signed the notices stockholders the Peoples' Wayne County bank, First National bank 'in Detroit. Detroit Se. curity Trust company. Bank of Michigan and Peninsular bank This circular. dated October 1929. urged the surrender stock in these state and national and trust companies for stock the Detroit Bankand signed Julius H. Haas, John Bodde Emory W. D. Dwight Douglas, Ralph Stone Albert Green, Mc. Pherson Brownsing John Ballantyne, Livingstone, E. J. and H. Hits Holding Companies sincerely regret that Judge Keidan, his opinion, did not with the orgy of high finance in the management the banks affairs came before him. However, according press reports night, Prosecuting Attorney Toy quoted as saying the grand hearings forever disposed holding companies for banks. The holding company plans for control banks never should have been permitted and the creation of them obviously for the purpose of getting around the intent the hope there no misunderstanding between Judge Keidan me. wrote him the following letter on September 15: gather from the press that you have concluded the ing the Detroit Bankers National Detroit group, are now proceeding with the Detroit Union group. During with Prosecuting Attorney Toy pressed the hope that might be permitted to go on the witness stand to submit new evidence in connection with the Detroit Bankers First National Detroit group, before you concluded, other before started with the Union Detroit group. that seems not have met your view have considerable evidence concerning the Guardian Detroit Union and am writing to ask you for permission submit this before you the grand jury hearing. May have advice as may be permitted to testify?' "On Sunday, September heard indirectly that Judge Keidan proposed the jury September 18. Learning that Judge Keidan not in his 16, the day my letter should have rived there, alarmed for fear he would close the grand jury before my letter was received. which in all probability would not receive until Monday morning. September 18 therefore contacted him Sunday night and advised him had writen this letter and asked that be permitted again go on the witness stand. not only reply the charges that had against me during the past month. but evidence "Judge Keldan disinclined to do this but an with me Frank Couzens' home at September farm to keep Judge Keidan then argued against appearing on the witness stand for the reason that might introduce new which would cause the bankers again quest and fur. ther delay the conclusion of the grand jury we left he advised me he would think over m. Monday telephoned me that would permitted the but my evidence would replying to those had attacked me since was last on the witness he would not consent to any other of being anxious to have that opportu"Later in day, that is. before went on the witness with Judge the testimony advised had not at that time been able secure transcript of the testimony given by Longley and Kanthe previous September the testimony that had been the morning of September Then Judge Keidan handed copy testimony taken September contained approximately 100 have an opportunity before going on the witness Neither to see transcript the taken the was submit all the testimony had collected particular respect Guardian Detroit Group. nor marshal my facts the statements made by