Smelter City State Bank (Durango, CO)

Episode Information

Episode UID
7141148091296
Episode Type
Suspension β†’ Closure
Bank Type
state
Bank ID
714114809 hash
Start Date
December 17, 1907
Location
Durango, Colorado (37.275, -107.880)

Metadata

Model
gpt-5-mini (chosen from majority vote of a three-model LLM ensemble)
Short Digest
5a28bc749ba4b2b5

Response Measures

None

Description

Suspended Dec 17, 1907 and placed in receivership; later wound up and paid dividends but did not resume as an operating bank.

Events (4)

1. December 17, 1907 Suspension
Cause
Local Shock
Cause Details
Indictments of prominent citizens on land fraud charges undermined public confidence and prompted suspension.
Newspaper Excerpt
The Smelter City bank of Durango, a state institution, capital $30,000, failed to open this morning... Lack of confidence, due, it is said, to the indictments of prominent citizens on charges of land frauds... led to the suspension of the Smelter City
Source
newspapers
2. December 22, 1907 Receivership
Newspaper Excerpt
Neither the Colorado State bank of Durango... nor the Smelter City State bank, also at Durango... will be able to reorganize and reopen, according to H. M. Beatty, state bank commissioner, who... placed the institutions in the hands of receivers to wind up their affairs.
Source
newspapers
3. January 2, 1908 Other
Newspaper Excerpt
The Smelter City bank of Durango, Colo., a state institution, capital $30,000, has closed its doors. Lack of confidence... led to the suspension.
Source
newspapers
4. March 4, 1909 Other
Newspaper Excerpt
PAYING SMELTER STATE BANK DIVIDENDS... the final agreement... provided for a total payment of 62 1/2 per cent in cash and notes, and 37 1/2 per cent in mining stock... Receiver Pingrey is able to pay at once a dividend of 54 6-10 per cent.
Source
newspapers

Newspaper Articles (20)

Article from Evening Times-Republican, December 17, 1907

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

LAND FRAUDS CLOSE BANK. Indictments Cause Loss of Confidence in Durango, Col. Durango, Col., Dec. 17.-The Smelter City Bank of Durango, a state institution, with a capital of $30,000, failed to open this morning. No statement was made but deposits are believed not to exceed $100,000. Charles McConnell, president of the bank, said all liabilities would be paid in full. Lack of confidence, due, it is said, to the indictment of prominent citizens on charges of land frauds under the federal laws, led to the suspension of the Smelter City as well as the Colorado Bank, which failed last week.


Article from Waterbury Evening Democrat, December 17, 1907

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BANK IS CLOSED Duraugo Institution Failed to Open Ils Doors For Business To-day. Durango, Col., Dec. 17.-The Smelter City bank of Durango, a state institution, capital $30,000, failed to open this morning. No statement of its assets or liabilities has been given out but the deposits are believed not to exceed $100,000. Charles McConnell, president of the bank, said that all liabilities would be paid in full. Lack of confidence, due, it is said, to the indictments of prominent citizens on charges of land frauds under the federal laws led to the suspension of the Smelter City bank, as well as the Colorado bank, which failed last week.


Article from Deseret Evening News, December 17, 1907

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

DURANGO BANK FAILS. The Smelter City, a State Institution, With Capital of $30,000. Durango, Colo., Dec. 17.-The Smelter City bank of Durango. a state institution, capital $30,000, failed to open this morning. No statement of its assets or liabilities has been given out, but the deposits are believed not to exceed $100,000. Charles McConnell, president of the bank, said that all liabilities would be paid in full. Lack of confidence due, it is said. to the indictments of prominent citizens on charges of land frauds under the federal laws, led to the suspension of the Smelter City AS well as the Colorado bank, which failed last week.


Article from Omaha Daily Bee, December 18, 1907

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

SMELTER CITY BANK CLOSES State Institutio nat Durango, Colo., Suspends Becouse of Land Fraud Cases. DURANGO Colo., Dec. 17.-The Smelter City bank of Durango, a state institution. capital $30,000, failed to open this morning. No statement of Its assets or liabilities has been given out, but the deposits are believed not to exceed $100,000. Charles McConnell, president of the bank, said that all liabilities would be paid in full. Lack of confidence, due, it is said, to the indictments of prominent citizens on charges of land frauds under the federal laws, led to the suspension of the Smelter City, as well as the Colorado bank, which failed last week.


Article from The Vinita Daily Chieftain, December 18, 1907

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

The Smelter City Bank of Durango, Colo., suspended Tuesday morning. The deposits exceed $100,000. The cause is attributed to lack of confidence.


Article from The Birmingham Age-Herald, December 18, 1907

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Durango Bank Fails. Durango, Col., December 17.The Smelter City bank of Durango, a state institution, capital $30,000, failed to open this morning. No statement of its assets or liabilities has been given out, but its deposits are believed to not exceed $100.000. Charles McConnell, president of the bank, said that all liabilities would be paid in full. Lack of confidence, due, it is said, to the indictments of prominent citizens on charges of frauds under the federal laws led to the suspension of the Smelter City as well as the Colorado bank, which falled week.


Article from The Salt Lake Herald, December 18, 1907

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

LAND FRAUD CHARGES CAUSE BANK'S FAILURE Durango, Colo., Dec. 17.-The Smelter City bank of Durango, a state institution, capital $30,000, failed to open this morning. No statement of its assets or liabilities has been given out, but the deposits are believed not to exceed $100,000. Charles McConnell, president of the bank, said that all liabilities would be paid in full. Lack of confidence due, it is said, to the indictments of prominent citizens on charges of land frauds under the federal laws, led to the suspension of the Smelter City as well as the Colorado bank, which failed last week.


Article from The Red Cloud Chief, December 20, 1907

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

SMELTER CITY BANK CLOSES Institution at Durango, Colo., Suspends Because of Land Fraud Cases. Durango, Colo., Dec. 18.-The Smelter City bank of Durango, a state institution, capital $30,000. failed to open. Lack of confidence, due, it is said, to the indictments of prominent citizens on charges of land frauds under the federal laws, led to the suspension


Article from Albuquerque Morning Journal, December 23, 1907

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

COLORADO STATE BANKS HOPELESSLY INSOLVENT Receivers Wind Up Affairs of Durange Institutions Closed Last Week. Devenr. Dec. 22.-Neither the Colorado State bank of Durango and its branch bank at Pagosa Springs, nor the Smelter City State bank. also at Durango, both of which closed their dogre the week before last, will be able to reorganize and re-open, according to H. M. Beatty, state bank commissioner. who returned from Durango yesterday, after placing the Institutions in the hands of receivers to wind up their affairs. The liabilities of the Colorado State and its Pagosa branch are $330.000, which do not include a capital stock of $75,000. The assets have a face value of $450,000. but are of such character as to fall very far short of meeting the indebtedness of the institution.


Article from Omaha Daily Bee, December 23, 1907

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

DURANGO BANKS STAY CLOSED Examiner Says Institutions in Hands of Receiver Will Not Be Reopened. DENVER. Colo., Dec. 22.-Neither the Colorado State bank of Durango and its branch bank at Pagosa Springs, nor the Smelter City State bank. also at Durango, both of which closed their doors week before last, will be able to reorganize and reopen, according to H. M. Beatty, state bank commissioner, who returned from Durango yesterday, after placing the institutions in the hands of receivers to wind up their affairs. The liabilities of the Colorado State and its Pagosa branch are $330,000, which do not include a capital stock of $75,000. The assets have a face value of $450,000. but are of such character as to fall very short of meeting the indebtedness. The liabilities of the Smelter City State are $142,000; assets, $172,000; capital stock, $30,000. The assets are also of such character as not to meet the indebtedness of the institution.


Article from Semi-Weekly Herald, December 23, 1907

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

e trict court in Pagoca Springs returned last evening. -0Lloyd Sheets, who returned from Denver Tuesday evening, will be on hand to assist the receiver and depositors in untangling the Smelter 3 City State bank affairs. -0-Mrs. R. W. Solomon. who was at Mercy hospital several days has SD far recovered as to be able to return to the ranch at Tiffany this morning. -0The Misses Francis and Marian Bell and Miss Ethel Sheets came in from Columbia. Mo., last evening where they afe attending Stephen's college. will be here during the holidays when they return to resume their studies. State Bank Commissioner H. M. Beatty having contpleted his business with the banks here and departed for Denver this morning. We trust he will never have occasion to visit this section on a similar mission. The condition of the failed banks may be bad. but until criminal crookedness is shown we are going to give the men every opportunity to straighten the tangle and pay depositors dollar for dollar. The man who jumps a board bill is liable to bump up against the real thing. Sheriff Palmquist of Silverton convinced two men of this fact in Ditrango yesterday who were willing to pay all expenses as well as the board bill which they attempted to "jump." John Gaylord, county clerk. along with three others who examined the books and paper of the Bank of Pa. gosa. make the statement that the bank is in excellent shape and if the Durango institution turns out as weil as expected the people of Archuleta county will be paid dollar for dollar in the long run. Last night Durango lodge No. 46. A F. & A. M., installed officers as follows: C. L. Russell, W. M.; T. H. Ballard. S. W.: G. H. Chariton, J. W.: W. C. Leisenberg, treasurer: Glenn Scouten. secretary: G. W. Moody, S. D.: S. D. Henderson, J. D. W. F. Ballreich. S. S.: J. T. Graham. J. S.: J. J. Biggs tyler. Owing to thef act that the Elks lodge has $1,500 tied up in the Smelter City State bank the plan to secure quarters for a club room and home has been abapdoned for the present. It will doubtless be raken in later,


Article from The Springfield Herald, December 27, 1907

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Bank Receivers Appointed. Durango.-District Judge Pike, while holding court at Pagosa Springs for Archuleta county, appointed Owen F. Boyle receiver of the Colorado State bank, fixing his bond at $50,000. Rowe Pingrey was named as receiver of the Smelter City State bank, his bond being $25,000. Both will immediately furnish bonds, begin work and will report on the conditions of the two institutions in a short time. The combined deposits of the two banks are about $325,000.


Article from The Daily Sentinel, December 28, 1907

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

DURANGO BANK MAY PAY 10 CENTS ON THE DOLLAR (Special to The Sentinel.) Durango, Colo., Dec. 28.-Charles E. McConnell, president of the defunct Smelter City State Bank, who was arrested Wednesday night on a charge of receiving deposits while knowing that the bank was insolvent, has been released by Justice of the Peace H. J. Hechtman under $3.000 bond. It was expected that other depositors would file complaints against McConnell, but this was not done. The bank of which he was president is in a very bad condition, according to Rowe M. Pingrey, the recelver, who says its assets will not pay the depositors more than 10 cents on the dollar. The prosecution against McConnell has been directed by a committee of the depositors, and what further action the committee will take Is not known. McConnell stated today that if he were let alone he would concentrate his life toward paying the liabilities of the bank. The excess of the liabilities over the assets, according to the figures furnished by the receiver, are about $125,000. Where the money has gone is not known. Among the assets of the bank is alleged to be a large amount of outlawed paper.


Article from The Idaho Recorder, January 2, 1908

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

NORTHWEST NOTES After being closed for coinage purposes for more than twelve years, the United States mint at Carson City, Nevada, may be reopened within the next few months. Negotistions between the labor unions of Butte and the Rocky Mountain Bell Telephone company are apparently off, the situation indicating a to struggle # faish. The break in the transmission wires of the Nevada Power company, which threw Goldfield into darkness, and which was charged to the striking permo SEA Mou = miliers, by a snowslide. General Funston has ordered a general courtmartial to convene at Goldfield. This order would indicate, say army men. that the troops now on duty at that place would be held there for come of emm euros Judge Bourquin of the state district court at Butte instructed the jury to acquit A. B. Clements, cashier of the failed Aetna bank, on a felony charge growing out of the alleged receipt of deposits when he knew the bank was insolvent. A dispatch from Denver says that James R. Barber and Summer G. Moon. the millionaire lumbermen of Eau Claire, Wis., indicted with Senator Borah for alleged conspiracy in 01 taken eq ABUI for trial. Colonel William Crooks, assistant to the general manager of the Harriman lines in the Pacific northwest, died in Portland on the 17th of complications growing out of a cold contracted about six weeks ago. He was "PIO Years 92 The supreme court of Montana has granted a writ of habeas corpus in the case of G. S. E. Wisner, an Anaconda bank employee, who had been convicted on the charge of receiving deposits when he knew his principal to be insolvent. The Smelter City bank of Durango, Colo., a state institution, capital $30,000, has closed its doors. Lack of confidence, due, it is said, to the indictments of prominent citizens on the charges of land frauds under the federal laws, led to the suspension. 'a T pus clerk chile Datisa, O o McLeod, at the head of the survey department in the office of United States surveyor general in Helena, have been arrested. The indictment alleges forgery and conspiracy to defraud the government of the United States. The state board of pardons of Montana has approved the action of Gov. or perdon E up Toolele Jou.19 Elizabeth Morrison, a Butte woman, -UBUI 8 uo contriction uodn 'OUM slaughter charge for the killing of Richard Finnegan, had been sentenced to the penitentiary for three years. The Hamilton Powder company's works blew up Sunday morning at Departure Bay, B. C. The loss is $40,000. No one was killed or injured. In Van. couver, thirty-five miles away, houses were shaken so badly that it was believed an earthquake had occurred and many persons rushed to the street in alarm. Pelia DI Ria was arrested at Seattle, together with two discharged employees of the Seattle Electric E THE charged 'Xueduoo to take the life of Tony Restove, fore man of construction work for the Sesip oqa 'Aueduros eme charged the men for incompetency from the construction gang. In an address issued by the exec I utive committee of the Western Fed eration of Miners, labor union men e are urged to rally to the defense of e officers and members of the federation q charged with the murder of former Governor Steunenberg of Idaho, and other crimes, and of the Goldfield miners who are on strike. d Michael C. Carroll, a pioneer guide, I died at his home in Laramie, Wyo., last week. He selected the site for Fort Sanders, three miles south of Laramie, in 1866, when the Union Pa. cific railroad was being built. and acted as mediator with the Indians, going unarmed to meet Chief Friday, . pus a em uo SUM oqn 3 ing a slaughter of whites. In an opinion rendered last week, # Attorney General Albert J. Galen . ruled that Christmas songs cannot be 1 barred from the public schools of Montana on the ground that "such use constitutes denominational or sectarian teachings." The decision was made at the request of the state su 2 perintendent of public instruction. James R. Kirwan, who had been # acting secretary-treasurer of the Western Federation of Miners, tendered his P resignation last week, on account of III health. and Ernest Mills, a member of the executive board from British Columbia, assumed the duties of that office. Martin O'Brien, a prominent lawyer of Rawhide, Nevada, while under the # influence of liquor, shot and killed 20 Bessie Gardiner, a woman of the half 8 pepunom pus mord O'Brien had become infatuated with em SEM supply am pus "ившом em jo Then


Article from Semi-Weekly Herald, January 9, 1908

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

y PARESIS OF THE BRAIN t When a man is suffering with paresis of the brain and is permitted to run at large by the authorities the public must necessarily take chances and S liable to attack at any time. As David F. Day is thus afflicted we suppose our good people must stand it. They must take chances of the man breaking out in a new place at any time. The Herald is prepared to prove that Dave Day in his Democrat will not tell the truth nor right a wrong or a misstatement. although day after day he prates about his honesty and assertions that he never failed to make a retraction. Some days ago he stated that Chas. E. McConnell borrowed $10,000 at the First National bank by putting up Smelter State bank securities and then pocketed the money, when the facts were that the money borrowed was through private security and for the benefit of the Smelter City State bank. He also caused this statement to go to the Pueblo Chieftain and we noticed the same lie published in other papers. Has a solitary individual seen a retraction? No. The man who runs the Democrat has not the decency or honor to make an honest correction. Again, Day has asserted several times that Mr. McConnell sold out the railway survey to the Southern Pacific and pocketed $25, 000. Will the Democrat have the deceny to correct this? No. The day before the Smelter bank closed Mr. Day guaranteed depositors to the extent of $17,500. If he fails to keep this guarantee he is just as much a deceiver as any of the bank officers. Will he keep his promise? No. Again, have you noticed how quick he shuts up when he gets back a patron. He keeps digging until he gets them. Then not a word. It's wonderful the effect a little advertisement or a 50,000 run on job work has with this honest new3paper man. And talk about being servile. All Durango remembers how he came out with a tirade against the appointment of Messrs. Pingrey and Boyle as receivers of the closed banking institutions. He does not tell how it hap. pened he stopped suddenly and what was said to him. No, he leaves this out. Just now a few, very few. creditors of the closed banks are listening to him and will sacrifice their holdings for a song even in the Colorado State. And among this number are some who have berated him all over the country


Article from The Dolores Star, January 10, 1908

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

From the reports given out by the receivers of the defunct Duraugo banks it would appear that the financial panic just came in time to give these banks an excuse for closing as neither could have run over the first of the year when the banking law went into effect. The report of the receiver of the Smelter City bank shows that the depositors can not hope for more than ten or fifteen cents on the dollar Aut of the assets of that institution. The re: port as published in the Democrat gave the total assets at $110,665.54, of this amount $29,601.03 is considered good, $12,257.00 doubtful, and $48,809.52 worthless. The liabilities are only $155,117.13.


Article from Semi-Weekly Herald, January 13, 1908

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

NOTICE OF DEPOSITORS' MEETING There will be a meeting held of depositors only of the Smelter City State bank at Durango city hall. January 14 at 8 o'clock p. m. to hear report of the receiver, and discuss such other matters of importance as may be deemed necessary relative to the interests of the depositors and looking towards the best means of winding up the affairs of said bank. R. E. SLOAN, Chairman. January 10, 1908.


Article from Semi-Weekly Herald, January 16, 1908

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

SMELTER CITY BANK Largely Atte ing of Depos Last Night Depositors of the Smelter City State bank met at the city hall last evening of listening to the reReceiver Pingrey and port for the of purpose Mr. Pingrey that of the advisory committee. read the synopsis of his report which has already been published. then E. C. Lightner read the report of the advisory committee as follows: "We have examined every resource at our command to devise ways and means of securing the most money out of the assets of the Smelter City bank, and in this we have been ably assisted by Mr. Pingrey, the receiver who has allowed us free access to all the books and papers connected with the bank and while we hardly think it necessary to comment on the situa tion at this time, as you no doubt are fully as conversant with the re ceiver's report as the advisory board is, however, we would like to state, that the total liabilities of the bank amount to $155,000. and the total as sets, which the receiver has deemed wise to place in three distinct col umns: a The good $27,000 $14,000 The doubtful $68,000 The worthless Total assets of $109,000 as against $155,000 liabilities. To the good as sets can be added the lot on Main street, situated near the Jackson Hardvalued at $2,500 and in the Farmington ware the lots company. valued addition at $500, in Farmington, N. M., making a total of $30,000 which can be considered as good assets. From this amount we have deducted $15,000 for securities hypothecated in Denver i and which are not available at the present time, leaving a net amount of t assets, which can be classed as good of $17,600 then the amount which Mr McConnell claims that he can get re leased from the indebtedness of the bank by giving his own personal note the influence of certain would leave a net friends, or through liability in sight of $113,000. and the receiver has $17,600 with which to pay this $113, 000 liabilities. "We have as stated before the ad visory board, has executed every known means at its command to arrive at some agreement that would be satisfactory to the depositors in general, and we beg to submit to you the following proposition to which Mr. McConnell and his attorneys have agreed and we will leave this matter with you for your consideration." After the reading of the above the chairman had the secretary read the proposed agreement between the committee and McConnell, which is as fol lowe: "This agreement made and entered into this day of January, A. D. 1908, by and between Charles E. Me Connell of the city of Durango, La Plata County. Colorado, party of the first part and R. E. Sloan, E. C. Light ner and F. R. Graham, of the said city, county and state, parties of the second part, witnesseth: "WHEREAS, the said Charles E. Mc Connell was the president of the Smelter City State bank of Durango, Colo., and the owner of certain stock in said bank, and "WHEREAS, the said Smelter City State bank of Durango, Colo., has be come financially embarrassed, and un able to meet its financial obligations, and was placed in the hands of the state bank commissioner of the state of Colorado, and "WHEREAS, the said state bank commissioner has heretofore applied to the district court of the sixth judicial district of the state of Colorado, in and for the county of Archuleta, for a receiver of said bank, and "WHEREAS, Rowe N. Pingrey has been by said court heretofore duly ap pointed receiver for said bank, and has duly qualified as such receiver and entered upon the discharge of his duties as such receiver and is now in possession of all the property of said bank, as provided by law, and "WHEREAS, the said R. E. Sloan, E. C. Lightner and F. R. Graham have been heretofore selected as a committee the creditors of said bank to the condition with said sugascertain to advise by receiver thereof, means and and gest plans, and ways and by which the greatest amount of money might be realized out of the assets of said bank for the purpose of protect-


Article from Semi-Weekly Herald, December 21, 1908

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

8 means 100 cents on the dollar and about $3,000 over to pay the receivership expenses, but should the receivership expenses run to $7,500 as agreed to in a signed card. then it means 96 to 97 cents on the dollar. Just what the receiver and attorneys will be allowed is a matter for the court, but in placing the limit at $7,500 we do so on account of the card of the receiver and attorneys published recently. This morning the court entered the order authorizing the transfer of the bank assets and all Mr. Boyle has to do is to disburse the cash and this should be forthcoming to morrow or by the outside Saturday enabling depositors to spend a happy Sabbath. The court this morning or dered a dividend paid to depositors but did not fix the amount, not having decided on the sum to be allowed the receiver and attorneys, the size of dividend being left to the discretion of the receiver, and this being the case we presume the dividend will not be less than 95 per cent. Thus it is with great pleasure The Herald announces the happy outcome. It is a source of great gratification to all immediately concerned as well as the people at large-those having no direct pecuniary interest. Coming right down to facts, every citizen has a pecuniary interest in the settlement, because the turning loose of this sum of money at the present time will aid every Durangoite as the money will keep changing hands until it pays obligations five or six times more than the original. Now we trust that Mr. McConnell will be able to get the affairs of the Smelter City State bank settled in the near future and then Durango will again rejoice. After entering the order in the Colorado State bank matter this morning, all criminal cases were continued until the April term to which time court adjourned. 1


Article from Semi-Weekly Herald, March 4, 1909

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

PAYING SMELTER STATE BANK DIVIDENDS. It is gratifying to the people of Durango that the affairs of the Smelter City State bank have been settled much more satisfactory than at first appeared possible. At one time it did not look as though the bank would pay over 10 or 15 cents on the dollar, but the advisory committee and others interested kept at the good work without being discouraged. Many of the depositors took stock in the Nevada mining property at a reduced rate that may net them double value, and the final agreement reached between the advisory committee, depositors, Mr. McConnell and Mr. Reynolds, provided for a total payment of 621/2 per cent in cash and notes, and 37 1/2 per cent in mining stock. The depositors were to receive the above clear of receivership expenses according to the agreement, and after the depositors had agreed to the proposition Mr. Reynolds came to the front with the amount of cash agreed on with the result that Receiver Pingrey is able to pay at once a dividend of 54 6-10 per cent, which means turning loose imme. diately in the neighborhood of $50, 000. About 8 per cent more will be paid in 18 months as per notes given by Mr. McConnell and endorsed by Mr. Reynolds, while the 37 1/2 per cent in stock will be issued at once. If re ports are anywhere near correct, from those who have personally inspected the Nevada property and those who know the conditions, there is little doubt but that depositors will finally es receive at least dollar for dollar and possibly more. It would certainly be gratifying if those who took stock for their entire deposit would make double on the investment. is Of course with the settlement all n criminal proceedings were dismissed le