Article Text
RETRENCHMENT THE RULE
How Trusts and Labor Unions Have Reacted on Each Other. Collier's Weekly. The trusts have been, in all, far worse sinners than the unions. The trusts expanded inordinately in both capital and the demand for labor. Both have collapsed. The harvester combine is about to discharge 5,000 men, and the Acme Harvester Company, one of the biggest in the country, has failed. The Lake Superior ore mines are cutting down labor one-half. The steel trust continues retrenchment. Freight shrinking, the Pennsylvania Railroad shuts down $10,000,000 of improvement. By January any one will be able to run over a list of side-tracked road betterments which will tally a round $100,000,000. The Amalgamated Copper trust is loaded with heavy copper stocks, accumulated in pegging up the price of Lake copper, and it has made an adverse judicial decision on a single mine an excuse for shutting down all its mines and throwing 15,000 men out of work. Such things are always compromised and adjusted, but unless all was shrinking such a shut-down would never have occurred. Judge Clancy's decision in favor of John McGinnis's suit to protect his property and the injunction against the Amalgamated is only one step in a long struggle, which has brought at Butte one trust and one union face to face, amicably keeping up miners' wages and copper quotations at the same time. The attempt has failed. It is bound to fail everywhere, but the difference is that when the miners make a mistake they lose, but when the trust makes a mistake the public loses. The various collapses of trusts and other risky attempts to discount the future closed, as a beginning, two trust companies in Baltimore (Maryland and Union) and two banks in Pittsburg (First National and Federal). One of these banks was an attempt to organize a "chain" or trust in a series of country banks. It collapsed as the other attempts toward partial monopoly have. Pittsburg, more than any other center, is affected by the monopoly expansion of iron and steel capitalization. There, the Amalgamated Association of Iron, Steel and Tin Workers and the Steel Trust divide the field. The Federation of Labor comes to its annual meeting at Boston, therefore, with the entire round of the industries it represents affected. Railroads, iron and steel, iron ore, copper, anthracite, Western mines, agricultural implements, building trades, carpenters, lumber-all show shutdowns. In all, the demand for labor is decreasing. Pennsylvania Railroad trainmen, New York Elevated motormen, and others, are in conference with the managements, but these things are small beside the great movement in the ebb of industry, an ebb due to the extravagant high tide of trusts. When the lack of work has spread, the fact will be plain that the unregulated organization of industry by trusts cannot continue. First trusts expand, then labor, naturally aroused by the spectacle of vast paper profits, strikes, dislocating industry, and after a year and a half of strikes, beginning with anthracite, men are thrown out of work by tens of thousands, in the reaction from the unregulated action of great combinations of capital and labor. A single trust like Amalgamated Copper deadlocks a State. Should it?