Article Text
FRAUD CHARGED IN MINING SUIT W. A. Twitchell and Lindsay Estate Sue Heirs of James McGarry. LARGE AMOUNT AT STAKE MINING CLAIMS IN IRON SPRINGS DISTRICT INVOLVED. A series of frauds extending over a period of seventeen years are alleged in a suit over the title to $100,000 worth of mining claims in the Iron Springs district, Iron county, Utah, brought in the district court yesterday by William A. Twitchell and Alice Lindsay, administrators of the estate of James R. Lindsay, against James C. McGarry, E. e. McGarry, Lillian M. Wilson, J. E. Harper, Elizabeth E. Harper, Edna S. McGarry, J. F. Younger, J. M. Wicks, Sherman McGarry, Sheridan McGarry and Elizabeth McGarry. As a result of the filing of the suit, Judge Armstrong appointed the Salt Lake Security & Trust company receivers for $54,000 due the defendants on a sale of the property to Patrick Ryan for $100,000, and payable at McCornick & Co.'s bank before Aug. 13. 1907. Claims Are Relocated. It appears, that in 1830 the property was located by Twitchell, Lindsay and James McGarry, deceased. McGarry, it is said, represented to Lindsay and Twitchell that he had procured a purchaser for the claims for a large sum of money and induced them to give him a trust deed in order that he might sell. In the event of a failure to self, McGarry was to still retain the trust and spend the option money in improving the claims. The sale was not consummated, but McGarry, it is said, violated his trust agreement and allowed the titles to over half of the claims to lapse by reason of failure to do the assessment work, and then relocated the properties to which, it is claimed. Twitchell and the Lindsay estate are still entitled to a one-third interest. McGarry died intestate in 1903, but prior to his death conveyed all his title and interest in the properties to the defendants named in this suit. The interest of the plaintiffs, it is further claimed. were known by all the defendants when they secured the alleged title to the property through McGarry. Sold for $100,000. In February, 1906, the defendants, it is said, agreed in writing to sell the claims for $100,000 to Patrick Ryan, which sum was to be paid in sundry partial payments at McCornick's bank. Of this amount $45,000 has already been paid and divided among the defendants, and there is still $54,000 due, and, according to the assertion made, must be paid before Aug. 13. It is for this amount that the plaintiffs ask the receiver until their rights in the properties can be adjudicated. The complaint goes on to state that the defendants, "as a part of said fraudulent intent to defraud the said Twitchell and Lindsay, concealed the fact of making the sale to Ryan until after they had secured $45,000. Then, as the story goes, the defendants, James McGarry and Ernest McGarry, "as a part of said fraudulent purpose," represented to Twitchell that they could sell the claims for a small sum of money, and represented that his share would be $1,000. Thus, it is claimed, they acknowledged his title. Before the alleged offer was accepted Twitchell discovered the scheme and the suit is a consequence. The value of the one-third interest held by the plaintiffs is placed at $75,000.