Article Text
METHODIST CHURCH CONTROVERSY SETTLED BY SUPREME COURT Taylor Street Edifice May Be Locked Up Says State's Highest Court The first Methodist church controversy of Portland and the suit of the state superintendent against L. O. Ralston were the principal cases handed down by the supreme court this morning. The decision of Judge Gatens in the circuit court was affirmed and the decision of Judge R. G. Morrow in the banking case was modified though the main contentions were sustained. The trouble in the church case arose over the consolidation of the Grace Methodist church at Twelfth street and the First Methodist church at Third and Taylor streets in 1912. After half a century of separate congregations the two bodies joined at the Ashland conference four years ago and were consolidated. Both congregations had churches and for a while the congregation held services at one church and then were transferred back to the oth. er. Each transfer found some of the congregations of the original church who refused to worship in the other building. Finally the board of trustees of the church decided to hold the main services at the church on Twelfth street and to close up the church at Third and Taylor streets. A number of the members of the Mirst Methodist church brought suit to enjoin the board from closing up the Taylor street church and in the lower court it was decided against the plaintiffs and the board was given the right to close up the Taylor street church and the plaintiffs appealed. In an opinion Justice Harris held that the lower court was not in error and only modified the decisions of Judge Gatens in that neither party should recover costs in the supreme court. Other Opinions Rendered. The suit of Mary Jacobs against oJhn Jacobs, a suit for Givorce, appealed from Linn county, opinion by Justice Renson, Judge Perey R. Kelly, affirmed. R. N. Doolittle, respondent, against Pacific Coast Safe and Vault works, appellant, an action for damages, appealed from Multnomah county, opinion by Justice Bean, Judge G. N. Davis, affirmed. B. M. Lombard, appellant, against M. B. Kies, receiver of Commercial Bank of Vancouver, Wash., respondent, action for breach of contract, appealed from Washington county, opinion by Justice Benson, Judge J. A. Eakin, reversed. Peter G. Carlson and J. A. Kallstram, appellants, against M. H. O'Connor, suit for specific performance of a contract to sell land, appealed from Multnomah county, opinion by Justice Bean, Judge C. U. Gantenbein, affirmed. Thomas Kay, appellant, against the City of Portland, respondent, suit to recover money alleged due for services rendered, appealed from Multnomah county, opinion by Justice McBride. Judge W. N. Gatens, affirmed.