Article Text

# WITHOUT PREJUDICE OR COSTS. Case of Receiver of Seattle National Bank vs. Old National Bank of This City Dismissed. A decision has just been handed down by the United States Circuit Court of Appeals in Boston by Justices Putnam, Webb and Lowell dismissing without prejudice and without cost the case of Charles H. Baker, receiver of the Seattle (Wash.) National bank, and the Old National bank, Francis A. Cranston, cashier, of Providence, R. I. Mr. Cranston as cashier of the Old National bank some time ago accepted 100 shares of stock of the Merchants' National bank of Seattle as collateral on a loan made to a local party. When the Seattle bank went into the hands of Receiver Charles Baker each share of its stock was assessed for 75 per cent. of its par value. Receiver Baker called for $7500 upon the stock held by Mr. Cranston as cashier of the Old National bank, which Mr. Cranston refused to pay, declaring that he held the stock merely as collateral on a loan. Mr. Baker then entered suit for the amount, and Judge Brown of the United States District Court, sitting in Providence, rendered a decision on May 28, 1898, that neither Mr. Cranston as cashier nor the Old National bank was liable for the amount. Mr. Baker then carried the matter to the United States Circuit Court of Appeals in Boston, with the foregoing result.