Article Text
"Such a tax is not needed to 'equalize' competition between the 'big fellows' and the 'little fellows' who operate the filling stations.
"The filling stations is already subject to heavy and oppressive taxation.
"The filling station is not a 'store' as that term is commonly used.
"The volume of sales of a filling station is small as compared with that of a chain store. For this reason, such a tax is confiscatory and out of all proportion to the amount of business done.
"State and federal courts have held that the state legislature may set up a distinction between filling stations."
Campbell said that a department store doing a business of several millions of dollars a year would pay a single store tax of $1, while the company operating filling stations, if not exempted under the chain store law, "would be taxed $50 on a small fraction of the volume of business done by the department store."
Fernald contended that the gasoline companies would not pass the tax assessment on to the consumer with Campbell insisting that the companies would of necessity have to do so.
Payment of the state of a $6,000 claim of the closed First National bank of Portland was asked by Arthur D. Welch, Portland lawyer, who appeared before the committee on behalf of a bill for that purpose. Chairman C. Carroll Blaisdell of the committee indicated he believed the bank's receivers might well take the matter to the courts after having received permission from the legislature to sue.
"The volume of sales of a filling station is small as compared with that of a chain store. For this reason, such a tax is confiscatory and out of all proportion to the amount of business done.
"State and federal courts have held that the state legislature may set up a distinction between filling stations."
Campbell said that a department store doing a business of several millions of dollars a year would pay a single store tax of $1, while the company operating filling station, if not exempted under the chain store law, "would be taxed $50 on a small fraction of the volume of business done by the department store."
Fernald contended that the gasoline companies would not pass the tax assessment on to the consumer with Campbell insisting that the companies would of necessity have to do so.
Payment by the state of a $6,000 claim of the closed First National Bank of Portland was asked by Arthur D. Welch, Portland lawyer, who appeared before the committee on behalf of a bill for that purpose. Chairman C. Carroll Blaisdell of the committee indicated he believed the bank's receivers might well take the matter to the courts after having received permission from the legislature to sue.
The claim arose from an assessment on stockholders levied by order of the comptroller of the United States in settling the bank's affairs. The bank's books showed, Welch said, that there were two of its certificates of stock in the name of the treasurer of the state. The stock had at one time been held by two state hospitals.
Welch held that the state was legally responsible but that its moral obligation was even greater. It was because the moral aspect would have no weight in a law court, he said, that he desired to have the matter settled by the legislature.