Article Text
THE SAVINGS BANK CASE.-The Farmers and Mechanics' Savings Bank of this city on the 7th day of December, 1876, failed, and shortly thereafter appointed a trustee to wind up its affairs. It was heavily indebted, owing the depositors $53,063 G3, and its assets were far less than its debts. Some. time after it ceased business, a suit was brought by John A. Marshall to have a receiver appointed to take charge of the assets of the bank, administer them as far as they would go, and then to charge the di rectors of the bank with the worthless assets upon the ground of negligence on their part in not seeing that the money of the bank was better secured. The assets were administered and paid 61 per cent. of the in lebtedness. And, thereupon, much evidence having been taken pro and con, Commissioner Armstrong reported that Messrs. Robert Bell, jr., Emanue! Francis, William Cogan, Andrew Jamieson and the estate of John W. Stewart were severally liable for $38,574.32, they having been directors of the bank from its organization until the appointment of a receiver." That Lewis Stein, John P. Agnew, and John C. Graham's estate were severally liable for $5,917.09, they having been directors from May 13th. 1873, to the receiver's appointment. And that L. McKenzie and Jefferson Ta ey's estate are severally liable for $21,682.71 The ground of the report was that the dis counts were negligently made, or that there was gross negligence in not collecting or exacting further security for them. Of course many of the items making up the several sums above named, run through the account against all the parties. The cause was argued at the September term last, of the Circuit Court, upon exceptions to Commis sioner Armstrong's report, by Col. F. L. Smith for the bank and by Messrs. S. F. Beach, G. A. Mushbach, John M. Johnson, and A. and C. E. Stuart, for the directors. To-day Judge Keith's opinion was received here, saying: "That degree of negligence is not proven, which, under the decision, is necessary to make the directors liable." A decree is therefore ordered in favor of the directors and overruling the commissioner's report. Col. F. L. Smith, who is Mr. Marshall's attorney is not in the city to-day, so the course he will pursue in the matter could not be learned, but it is generally believed he will take the case to the Court of Appeals. Mr. Leonard Marbury, who is the receiver of the defunct bank, says he is in favor of appealing the case.