20921. Mechanics' Savings Bank and Trust Company (Nashville, TN)

Bank Information

Episode Type
Run → Suspension → Closure
Bank Type
state
Start Date
March 27, 1893
Location
Nashville, Tennessee (36.166, -86.784)

Metadata

Model
gpt-5-mini
Short Digest
e04a4511

Response Measures

Partial suspension, Books examined

Other: Later general assignment (bank failure) after discovery of cashier's embezzlement; assignment/receivership noted.

Description

Panic after failure of Commercial National Bank and collapse of local cotton brokers (Dobbins & Dazey) led to runs/withdrawal pressure. Bank first invoked the state 60-day notice (partial suspension of withdrawals) in late March 1893 to head off a run, then in mid-April (Apr 17-18) made a general assignment (failure) after discovery of large embezzlement by cashier John Schardt. OCR typos corrected (e.g., Mechenics' → Mechanics').

Events (3)

1. March 27, 1893 Suspension
Cause
Local Shock
Cause Details
Banks in Nashville faced panic after Commercial National Bank's suspension/failure and related commercial failures; Mechanics' invoked 60-day notice to forestall withdrawals.
Newspaper Excerpt
the directors saw that a run was possible, and to prevent demoralizing excitement, decided to take advantage of the statute... Payments were accordingly stopped, and an explanatory notice was posted
Source
newspapers
2. March 28, 1893 Run
Cause
Local Shock
Cause Details
Run pressure followed the failure/suspension of Commercial National Bank and the collapse of local cotton brokers (Dobbins & Dazey), producing panic and rumors.
Measures
Directors invoked state law requiring sixty days' notice of withdrawal (stopped payments for immediate withdrawals; posted explanatory notice to demand 60 days).
Newspaper Excerpt
There was a mild run for a while on the First National Bank... After a number of persons had entered the Mechanics' Savings Bank and Trust Company's office and several small checks had been cashed, the directors saw that a run was possible
Source
newspapers
3. April 17, 1893 Receivership
Newspaper Excerpt
The Mechanics' Savings Bank and Trust Company made a general assignment at 2:30 o'clock this morning. The failure was caused by the shortage of John Schardt, the Cashier, who is charged with being over $50,000 short.
Source
newspapers

Newspaper Articles (11)

Article from New-York Tribune, March 28, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

ANOTHER NASHVILLE FAILURE. THE BANK OF COMMERCE MAKES AN AS SIGNMENT THE MECHANICS' BANK DEMANDS SIXTY DAYS' NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF DEPOSITSCREDITORS OF BOTH LIKELY TO GET THEIR MONEY - PRECAUTIONS AGAINST RUNS ON OTHER INSTITUTIONS. [BY TELEGRAPH TO THE TRIBUNE.] Nashville, Tenn., March 27.-The Bank of Commerce of this city did not open its doors to-day at 9 o'clock, the usual time: and an hour or two later, after a conference of the directors had been held, an assignment was made. John T. Lellyette was named as assignee. The bank was a small one, its assets and liabilities being approximately as follows: Assets-Notes discounted, $76,000; real estate and cash, $21,700; total, $97,700. Liabilities-Capital stock paid in. $27,500; deposits, savings account, $14,000; deposits, special account, $15,000; general deposits, $19,000; profit and loss, $22,200; total, $97,700. The Mechanics' Savings Bank and Trust Company, capital $250,000, took advantage of the State law permitting sixty days' notice to be demanded before deposits can be withdrawn. At least a dozen small banks in adjacent towns are said to Le in temporary financial straits. The assignment of the Bank of Commerce was filed late in the afternoon. The closing of the doors was brought about by an apprehension that a run on the bank would be made in the course of the day. Under the State Banking laws the bank could have required small depositors in the savings department to give sixty days' notice of their intention to withdraw deposits. This, however, would not have prevented the withdrawal of regular deposits, which would leave the small depositors at a disadvantage. The directors there. fore decided, in the interest of all depositors alike, to close the bank. The failure of certain persons, who owe the bank large sums, to meet these obligations was the principal cause of the suspension. None of the directors or officers of the bank are indebted to the institution. Mr. Brooks, the cashier, thinks the stockholders, as well as the depositors, will be paid in full if the amounts due the bank can be collected, and that if only 50 per cent of the indebtedness can be collected the depositors ought to get all that is due them. The suspension of the Commercial National Bank on Saturday afternoon occasioned considerable excitement, which had, however, quieted down by this morning, a change of feeling largely due to the belief of various bankers that the depositors of the Commercial Bank would not lose anything. Before beginning business to-day all the banks had fortified themselves with money sufficient to meet all demands that might be made, and had arranged for large amounts in addition. There was a mild run for a while on the First National Bank, but the amount deposited largely exceeded the amount checked out. This was the case at all the banks in the city, men of means pouring ample funds into the vaults. At no time was there the least excitement. The depositors who felt panicky simply drew out their money and went quietly away. The First National was more crowded all the morning than any other bank. Everything was quiet at the American National Bank, and the doors were open till 4 o'clock. Several of the wealthy stockholders signed a notice, which was conspicuously displayed, pledging and binding their personal estates to satisfy any obligations of the bank. After a number of persons had entered the Mechanics' Savings Bank and Trust Company's office and several small checks had been cashed, the directors saw that a run was possible, and to prevent demoralizing excitement, decided to take advantage of the statute which gives a bank organized under the State laws the privilege of demanding a sixty-day notice from depositors before they can withdraw their deposits. Payments were accordingly stopped, and an explanatory notice was posted, which closed with an announcement that the bank would keep its doors open and continue to do business as usual, save that the sixty days' notice of withdrawals would be required for the present, and a denial of the rumor that the bank had sustained a loss by the suspension of the Commercial National Bank. After this business proceeded quietly as usual. United States Bank Examiner J. M. McKnight arrived in the city this morning, and at once took charge of the affairs of the Commercial Bank. S. J. Keith, president of the Fourth National Bank, said to-day that the situation was not nearly as bad as it might appear. Although one small bank had closed its doors permanently and another had availed itself of the sixty days allowed savings banks, yet it was evident that the other banks were amply prepared to take care of themselves. He added that the business condition of the city was entirely healthy.


Article from Freeland Tribune, March 30, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

NASHVILLE'S PANIC. Thousands of Excited Citizens Almost Mob the Bank. NASHVILLE, March 28.-The streets in the vicinity of the banking houses of this city echoed all day the vociferations of a panic stricken throng. Never before were such scenes witnessed here. The failure of the Commercial National bank on Saturday afternoon did not become generally known until after dusk. Nothing else was talked about, and it was known to half the town that a raid would be made on the money piles of the various institutions that would make some of them tremble if not topple over into financial ruin. The First, Fourth, American National, Merchants, Mechanics 'Savings Bank and Trust company and the Union Bank and Trust company, all of College City. and the City Savings bank, the Capital City bank and the Nashville Safe Deposit Trust and Banking company, just around the corner of Cherry, on Union street, opened up their doors. It was rumored later that the Mechanic's had been caught in the commercial collapse. The officers soon saw that a run which they could not stand was imminent. The directors resolved to take advantage of the state banking law, which gives banks organized under it the privilege to demand a 60-day notice from depositors before they can withdraw their dc. posits.


Article from Passaic City Record, April 1, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

THREE BANKS FAIL. A Panic in Nashville (Tenn.) Commercial Circles. Three banks in Nashville, Tenn., which had been regarded as substantial failed to open their doors on the morning after the failure of Dobbins & Dazey, the big cotton brokers. In consequence there was a panic in commercial circles and confi dence in the stability of other institutions was shaken. The first announcement was that the Commercial National Bank had failed. This was soon followed by the reports that the Mechenics' Savings Bank and Trust Company and the Bank of Commerce were in difficulties. A run on all the banks was feared, and to avoid this the banks made assignments, thus protecting equally the interests of all the creditors. The Commercial National Bank had enjoyed the utmost confidence of the people of Nashville. The suspension is the direct result of the failure of Dobbins & Dazay, cotton brokers. The amount stated as the indebtedness of that firm to the Commercial was $30,000. It has since been learned that the bank's total loss on Dobbins & Dazey's paper, their foreign exchangeani overdraft amounted to $263.000. The Bank of Commerce made assignment naming John T. Lellyett as assignee. This action was precipitated by the general apprehension of a run on the bank, which the officers believed would be made. The deposits were not large, aggregating only about $50,000. The Mechanics' Bank suspended withdrawals by depositors for sixty days. The three failures will break about thirty small banks in tae country towns and the losses in all will reach one million and a half dollars. Two small State banks failed that day. The failure will stagnate busi. ness and the loss from that source will be equally as great.


Article from The Weekly Union Times, April 7, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

End of the Nashville Bank Panic. NASHVILLE, TENN. -The financial situation in this city was perfectly quiet Friday. The Banks did little business besond the receipt of deposits, there seeming to be no desire to check out. But little demand from country banks for currency was made, though when made it was promptly supplied. The Mechanics' Savings Banks and Trust Company is receiving deposit and in a day or two will resume payments.


Article from Fisherman & Farmer, April 7, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

THREE BANKS FAIL. A Panic in Nashville (Tenn.) Commercial Circles. Three banks in Nashville, Tenn., which had been regarded as substantial failed to open their doors on the morning after the failure of Dobbins & Dazey, the big cotton brokers. In consequence there was a panic in commercial circles and confi lence in the stability of other institutions was shaken. The first announcement was that the Commercial National Bank had failed. This was soon followed by the reports that the Mechenics' Savings Bank and Trust Company and the Bank of Commerce were in difficulties. A run on all the banks was feared, and to avoid this the banks made assignments, thus protecting equally the interests of all the creditors. The Commercial National Bank had enjoyed the utmost confidence of the people of Nashville. The suspension is the direct result of the failure of Dobbins & Dazey, cotton brokers. The amount stated as the indebtedness of that firm to the Commercial was $30,000. It has since been learned that the bank's total loss on Dobbins & Dazey's paper, their foreign exchangeand overdraft amounted to $263,000. The Bank of Commerce made assignment naming John T. Lellyett as assignee. This action was precipitated by the general apprehension of a run on the bank, which the officers believed would be made. The deposits were not large, aggregating only about $50,000. The Mechanics' Bank suspended withdrawals by depositors for sixty days. The three failures will break about thirty small banks in tue country towns and the losses in all will reach one million and a half dollars. Two small State banks failed that day. The failure will stagnate business and the loss from that source will be equally as great.


Article from The Abbeville Press and Banner, April 12, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

THREE BANKS FAIL. A Panic in Nashville (Tenn.) Commer. cial Circles. Three banks in Nashville, Tenn., which had been regarded as substantial failed to open their doors on the morning after the failure of Dobbins & Dazey, the big cotton brokers. In consequence there was a panic in commercial circles and confidence in the stability of other institutions was shaken. The first announcement was that the Commercial National Bank had failed. This was soon followed by the reports that the Mechenics' Savings Bank and Trust Company and the Bank of Commerce were in difficulties. A run on all the banks was feared, and to avoid this the banks made assignments, thus protecting equally the interests of all the creditors. The Commercial National Bank had enjoyed the utmost confidence of the people of Nashville. The suspension is the direct result of the failure of Dobbins & Dazay. cotton brokers. The amount stated as the indebtedness of that firm to the Commercial was $30,000. It has since been learned that the bank's total loss on Dobbins & Dazey's paper, their foreign exchangeand overdraft amounted to $263,000. The Bank of Commerce made assignment naming John T. Lellyett as assignee. This action was precipitated by the general apprehension of a run on the bank, which the officers believed would be made. The deposits were not large, aggregating only about $50,000. The Mechanics' Bank suspended withdrawais by depositors for sixty days. The three failures will break about thirty small banks in the country towas and the losses in all will reach one million and a half dollars. Two small State banks failed that day. The failure will stagnate business and the loss from that source will be equally as great.


Article from The Morning News, April 17, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

A CASHIER SHORT $40,000. The Mechanics' Sayings Bank of Nashville Robbed. NASHVILLE, TENN., April 16.-This - afternoon there was given to the public the fact that John Schardt, cashier of the Mechanics' Savings Bank and Trust Company, was short in his accounts from $40,000 to $80, OCO. Schardt is at home sick and notallowed to talk. Immediately after 12 o'clock to-night the bank will make a general assignment, which is now being prepared. It is & caso of stealing and affects none of the other banks of the city. Schardt has een cashier about three months, Before that he had been teller of the bank and thoroughly trusted. It is stated that the discovery of a probable shortage occurred yesterday, when a check for $4,000 was presented, and the teller could find no credits for the amount. Schardt, at the time being, was at his home sick. The president and directors were notified and an examination entered upon, and it was discovered that there was a shortage. THE PLAN HE WORKED. The plan be worked was this: He would take deposits, enter them upon the pass book and not put them upon the books of the bank. It is also stated that Schardt has confessed to having used $40,000 of the bank's money. He is under bood for $20,000, and carries $80,000 insurance, which it is also stated has been transferred to the bank. Until an assignment is filed and the directors talk nothing more definite can be obtained. During the financial flurry caused by the failure of the Commercial National Bank, this bank suspended for one day paying depositors. Upon examination the directors became satisfied that it was sound and resumed bug. iness. No trouble is anticipated to-morrow among other banks, as they have passed through the ordeal of the past week. Schardt lost the money he took speculating in bucket shops. He was a heavy speculator and lost beavily. He is about 30 years old and has a family. It is understood that the guaranty company. which made his bond, represented here by Theodore Cooley, will have him arrested to-morrow. There 18 a current report, which is currently believed, that Schardt will not recover from his sickness.


Article from St. Paul Daily Globe, April 17, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

A Tennessee Savings and Trust Company Driven Into Bankruptcy. The Cashier Uses $65,000 of Its Funds in Playing Bucket Shops. Two Men Killed in a Bloody Battle Between Italians and Hungarians. The Latter Become Dismayed and Flee Precipitately From the Field. NASHVILLE, Tenn., April 16.-This afternoon there was given to the public the fact that John Schardt, cashier of the Mechanics' Savings Bank and Trust Company. was short in his accounts from $40,000 to $80,000. Schardt is sick at his home and not allowed to talk. The directors of the bank have been in session all day and are still in session behind closed doors, and will not talk, From one, however, it is learned that it is believed the shortage is $65,000. Immediatsly after 12 o'clock tonight the bank will make a general assignment, which is now being prepared. It is a case of stealing, and affects none of the other banks of the city. Schardt has been cashier about three months. Before that he had been the teller of the bank, and was thoroughly trusted. It is stated that a discovery of a probable shortage occurred yesterday, when a check for $4,000 was presented and the teller could find no credits for Schardt at his home sick, being the amount. the at president the time and directors were notified, an examination entered upon, and it was discovered that there was a shortage. The plan he worked was this: He would take deenter them upon the pass book and them upon the posits, not put books Schardt of the bank. It is also stated that had confessed to having used $40,000 of the bank's money. He is under bond for $20,000. and carries $80,000 insurance,which, it is alsostated, has been transferred to the bank. Until the ashas been filed signment definite and the direct- be talk. nothing more can the obtained. ors During financial failure of flurry the recently, caused by the National bank. bank for one day an suspended Commercial paying this deposit- the ors. rectors Upon became examination satisfied it was diand resumed business. No is trouble sound anticipated tomorrow have with the other banks, as they through the few weeks. passed past safely Schardt lost ordeal the money of the He he in was speculator, took a heavy speculating bucket and lost shops. old heav- and ily. He is about thirty years has It is a family. which understood made the his company, here bond, Guaranty represented arrested by `Theodore tomorCooley, will have him is current a and believed, row. quite generally There sickness. that report, Schardt will recover from said tonight the A director not his that $50,000 if did not go over the bank pay depositors as holds the bond of stealings the bank would the in Guaran- full, for of North on Schardt, unof $26,000. divided tee $20,000 Company profits and there America Schardt's are have a year, to keep for peculations over been but them going he covered was on was never seen This bank was shops. up, clever and enough organized around with bucket under five or six years ago, a stock of $50,000, It was state $15,000 capital laws deposits. and always had about as until a three or four days ago looked on in safe institution, and the stock sold the market from 130 to 150. Schardt succeeded in pulling the wool over the of the officials when they made an examination eyes at the time of the failure of the Commercial National bank. NASHVILLE, Tenn., April 17.-2a.n is reported that Schardt, the cashier, has committed suicide, but the rumor has not yet been confirmed.


Article from The Sun, April 18, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

ANOTHER NASHVILLE BANK FAILS. The Cashier Had Embezzled About Fifty Thousand Dollars. NASHVILLE, April 17.-The Mechanics' Savings Bank and Trust Company made a genoral assignment at 2:30 o'clock this morning. The failure was caused by the shortage of John Schardt. the Cashier. who is charged with being over $50,000 short. The assignment shows about $200,000 assets in notes and overdrafts. against $150.000 liabilities of deposits and indented ness to other banks. Schardt assigned to the bank a life insurance of $80,000. Many of the notes and overdrafts counted in the bank's assets are considered to be of small value. Other banks are steady and confident. and there seems to be no uneasiness in bank circles. Schardt was insured in a guarantee company for $20,000, which sum is counted in the assets of the bank. Schardt died to-night about 9 o'elock from congestion of the brain He had been unconscious since 2 o'clock this afternoon.


Article from St. Paul Daily Globe, April 18, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

DEATH OF A DEFAULTER. Schardt's Illness Was Fatal, and the Bank Assigned. NASHVILLE, Tenn., April 17.-John Schardt, the defaulting cashier of the Mechanics' Savings Bank and Trust company, died tonight about 9 o'clock from congestion of the brain. He had been unconscious since 2 o'clock this afternoon. The bank made an assignment at 2 o'clock this morning for the benefit of all its creditors, with James T. Pryor, as assignee. The assets are placed at $200,000 nominal, and the The deposi$150,000. liabilities tors number 1,000, but the amount due depositors is not stated, as the assignment was made in haste. Deposits received Saturday afternood will be returned as they were not entered upon the books of the bank. The officers of the bank express confidence in the belief that the assets will pay all of the debts. Schardt transferred to the bank life insurance policies amounting to $80,000 and certain notes and real estate, and the assets, exclusive of these transferred by Schardt, amount to $161,000. The largest debt due by the bank-$86,000-is secured by mortgages and collaterals. The other banks of the city transacted business as usual today. and there was no excitement whatever. The failure was due to the defalcations of the cashier, and not from extraneous causes. The capital stock of the bank was $50,000.


Article from The Sun, April 20, 1893

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

A Defaulting Cashier Dies. Nashville, Tenn., April 18.-John Schardt, the defaulting cashier of the Mechanics' Savings Bank and Trust company, died tonight from congestion of the brain. The bank assigned this morning for the benefit of all its creditors, with James T, Pryor as assignee. The assets are placed at about $200,000, nominal, and the liabilities $150,-