18549. First National Bank (Carnegie, PA)

View Charter #4762 on SPMC

Bank Information

Episode Type
Run → Suspension → Closure
Bank Type
national
Bank ID
4762
Charter Number
4762
Start Date
April 27, 1925
Location
Carnegie, Pennsylvania (40.409, -80.083)

Metadata

Model
gpt-5-mini
Short Digest
41c2e282

Response Measures

Full suspension, Books examined

Other: State Banking Department took possession of the Trust company; receiver later appointed for First National.

Receivership Details

Depositor recovery rate
83.9%
Date receivership started
1925-05-12
Date receivership terminated
1929-10-15
OCC cause of failure
Governance
Share of assets assessed as good
57.9%
Share of assets assessed as doubtful
26.0%
Share of assets assessed as worthless
16.1%

Description

Both the Carnegie Trust Company (taken over by the state) and the First National Bank of Carnegie closed on/about April 27–28, 1925. The First National reportedly closed on their own accord to prevent a run, did not reopen, and a receiver was later handling liquidation and suits. Underlying cause repeatedly cited was the frozen condition of coal-related assets (stagnation of the bituminous coal industry).

Events (5)
1. June 23, 1892 Chartered
Source
historical_nic
2. April 27, 1925 Run
Cause
Local Banks
Cause Details
Run threat/withdrawal pressure arose after the Carnegie Trust Company was closed by the State Secretary of Banking and depositors began presenting passbooks; panic stemming from another local bank's closing.
Measures
Board closed the bank on their own accord to prevent a run; later cash transferred to Mellon National Bank vaults for safekeeping.
Newspaper Excerpt
The First National closed a few minutes after opening this morning, officials stated later that they took action on their own accord to prevent a run on the bank.
Source
newspapers
3. April 27, 1925 Suspension
Cause
Local Shock
Cause Details
Bank remained closed in the wake of the Carnegie Trust collapse and because of the frozen condition of coal-related assets resulting from stagnation in the bituminous coal industry.
Newspaper Excerpt
The First National closed a few minutes after opening this morning...officials stating later that they took action 'on their own accord to prevent a run on the bank.'
Source
newspapers
4. May 12, 1925 Receivership
Source
historical_nic
5. May 23, 1925 Receivership
Newspaper Excerpt
The cash in the First National Bank of Carnegie was transferred to the large steel vaults in the Mellon National Bank of Pittsburgh. Receiver R. F. Marburger did this in compliance with instructions from the Treasury Department at Washington. ... pending the liquidation of the bank, which probably will require some time.-Carnegie (May 23, 1925).
Source
newspapers

Newspaper Articles (17)
1. April 28, 1925 The State Journal Frankfort, KY
Article from The State Journal, April 28, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BIG BANKS CLOSE DOORS. PITTSBURG. April 27 (By A. State and Federal Banking Officials today began investigating the affairs of two Carnegie Banks, The Garnegie Trust and The First National Bank of Carnegie. which closed their doors this morning. The Trust Company was the first to close on orders from Peter G. Cameron, State Secretary of Banking. In a statement Mr. Cameron said: "The reserve fund of the Carnegie Tinst Company has been below legal requirements for some days." The First National closed a few minutes after opening this morning, officials stated later that they took action "on their own accord to pre vent a run on the bank." Both institutions of which John T. Bell is Pres ident. are located at Carnegie, Penna

2. April 28, 1925 The Times Leader Wilkes-Barre, PA
Article from The Times Leader, April 28, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Two Carnegie Banks Close (Contlued from Page 1) "the fund of the Carnegie Trust has been below legal quirements for some days. The First National closed few minutes after opening this officials stating later that they took "on their own pre. vent run on the stitutions which are located Pa. to his the funds the Carnegie were legal requirements, Cameron been company build up the to the required amount, it has failed owing to the frozen condition result of the stagnation that has tained bituminous coal Pennsylvania for In statement Bell said the sound the bank would be reopened business but did not indicate The Trust surplus last report of April deposits of 000,000 and assets listed as $5,664.The First National has capital surplus profits $165,000. Its report April showed deposits

3. April 28, 1925 The Saginaw News Saginaw, MI
Article from The Saginaw News, April 28, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

CARNEGIE COAL CO. PROPERTY RETURNED Associated PITTSBURG. April made Tuesday nouncement of the Carnegie that the property been returned to its Coal Co. had H. Sanford and original by John of the banks Bell. president suburb. which Carnegie Monday the closed the coal time the property of the transfer were The terms Depositors the Carnegie Trust Tuesday began their passbooks the bank in response from Peter Camerrequest the state banking secretary who has taken charge bank's First of the National Bank Carnegie remained closed officers the board directors announcing taken action their had the Mr Bell said First National Bank of Carnegie nancially throw its doors open to depositors within days. Cameron closing the Carnegie Trust said its reserve fund "had been below legal for some ing that the situation direct result the stagnation that has obtained in coal industry in for some months.

4. April 28, 1925 The Titusville Herald Titusville, PA
Article from The Titusville Herald, April 28, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

PITTSBURGH, April and federal banking officials today began Investigating the affairs the Carnegie banks, the Carnegie Trust pany and the First National Bank com- of Carnegie, morning. which closed their doors this The trust company was the first to close on orders from Peter Cameron. state secretary of banking. statement, Cameron said: reserve fund of the Carnegie Trust company has been below legal for some days." minutes The First National closed few after opening this morning, officials stating later that they took action their accord prevent run the Both institutions. of which John Bell are located in Carnegie,

5. April 28, 1925 The Des Moines Register Des Moines, IA
Article from The Des Moines Register, April 28, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

PENNSYLVANIA BANKS CLOSED Official Blames Stagnation of Coal Industry. (By The Associated Press Pittsburgh, April and federal banking officials have begun investigating the affairs of two Carnegie banks, the Carnegie Trust company First National Bank of Carnegie, which closed their doors this morning The trust company was the first close, orders from Peter Cameron, state secretary of banking In statement, Mr Cameron said, fund the Carnegie Trust company has been below the legal requirements for some days The First National closed few minutes after opening this morning Officials stated later that they took the action their accord, prevent run on the bank Both institutions. which John Bell president, are located in CarPa. Adding to his statement that the reserve funds the Carnegie Trust company were below the legal said "Although every effort has been made by the company build up the reserve the required amount. has failed to so, owing to the frozen condition of Its assets, which, direct the has obtained in the bituminous coal industry Pennsylvania some months, the company being the holder obligations of coal companies aggregating considerable sum.

6. April 28, 1925 The Gettysburg Times Gettysburg, PA
Article from The Gettysburg Times, April 28, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Coal Company's Property Returned (By Associated Press.) Pittsburgh, April 28.-Announcement was made today that the property of the Carnegie Coal Company has been returned to its original owners, J. H. Stanford and J. T. M. Stoneroad, by John A. Ball. president of the two banks at Carnegie which closed their doors yesterday. At the time Mr. Ball purchased the coal property. The company was capitalized at $8,000,000. Depositors of the Carnegic Trust Company today began leaving their pass books at the bank in response to request from the state secretary of banking. who has taken charge of the bank affairs. The First National Bank of Carnegie also remained closed today. officers announcing that the board of directors had taken this action "on their own account to prevent a run on the bank." Mr. Ball said the First National Bank of Carnegie "is financially sound and may throw open doors to depositors within a few days."

7. April 28, 1925 Lancaster Daily Intelligencer Lancaster, PA
Article from Lancaster Daily Intelligencer, April 28, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BANK PRESIDENT DRAINAGE CASE BEFORE COMMON RETURNS CARNEGIE PLEAS COURT TODAY COAL CO. PROPERTY Reamstown Farmers Contest Over Method of Handling Water in Fields The suit of John Fritz against B. Frank Detterline, neighboring mers of Reamstown, in which the plaintiff seeks to recover damages he alleges he suffered, when the defendant, said, changed the course of the water tried today before Judge Hassler Common Pleas Court. The jury visited the properties Reamstown yesterday afternoon heard this Fritz alleged that the early Spring of changed the water course on his make flow onto the plaintiff's farm. flooding and damsome of planted aging for and claimed $25 for $25 for the $25 $75 for tobacco and for $10 for wheat defendant declared he The not responsible for the damage or He declared that water drainage. the State Highway Department adjoining his constructed property, is higher than the Fritz farm, the sald diverting over his property the and onto Fritz's Employer Wins the was verdict this morning in Judge of Pleas Hassler's court of the suit of against Frank Burkrecover wages of alleged to alleged he employed Blough by Burkholder sell wage of receive said he hired week. Blough autos not salary. He cent commission. (continued on page nineteen) It Was Purchased Two Days Ago by John A. Bell April ment today that property the Carnegie had original owners, Sanford Stoneroad president of the doors yesterday Bell purchased coal two days ago Italized $8,000,000. The terms the not Depositors of the Carnegie Trust Company leaving pass books request from Peter secretary the banking charge the bank's First tional Bank mained closed today nouncing the board directors taken this count to the Mr. Bell National Bank of and throw its to depositors within Secretary Cameron Carnegie Trust Company said serve fund below legal for some adding that direct result of the stagnation has obtained in the bituminous (Continued on Page Nincteen)

8. April 28, 1925 The News-Journal Lancaster, PA
Article from The News-Journal, April 28, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Frozen Condition Of Assets Said To Result From Poor Bituminous Conditions MISS PRATT SPEAKS MAY REOPEN SOON Miss Julia Williamson, who with Girl Scout Work Philadelphia and Miss Sarah Pratt, general of the speakers the last the were series held Junior League North Duke street, ernoon. There was large attendance members. Williamson gave an interesting talk social work in its relation community groups. She stressed the point that people working groups learn along with others and be the assistance others. Group work, she said, builds up friendship, but warned the league to beware organization. Speaking Girl Miss Williamson said, "Their ideal service They get excellent trainfirst aid and are kept out These girls the best They are given chance try out their wings and good training for future life the domestic overlooked." The Girl Scout the speakhelp all classes girls. that the world working together for ports for scouts order that they may from another and camp with each other. Pratt told of the work the attention the that there between and rang ing age from to Kepler hall, which ideal place for the city stay until becomes acquainted. 1,005 transients housed last year. She also told of the various classes connected with the association, each of which has its own peal some girl. The annual election of officers the league be held next Monday the league rooms. This afternoon weekly be conducted by the Visiting Nurse Association with Norman Snyder Miss Mary Beates charge, assisted by Mrs. Myron Jones Pittsburgh, April federal banking to-day beinvestigating the affairs the Carnegie banks, the Carnegie Trust Company the First National Bank Carnegie, which closed their doors morning. The trust company the first close orders from Peter Cameron, state of banking. In statement Mr. Cameron reserve fund the Carnegie Trust Company has been below legal requirements The First National closed few minutes after opening this morning, officials stating later that they took action their accord vent run the Both stitutions which John Bell president. located Carnegie. Adding his statement that the reserve funds the Carnegie Trust Company were legal requireSecretary Cameron Blames Coal Situation. "Although every has been made by the company build the the has failed owing the condition its assets which, direct result that obtained the coal industry Pennsylvania for Mr. Bell said the sound the bank reopened for he did not indicate when. The Carnegie Trust Company has capital surplus last report April showed. deposits more than and assets listed The First National capital surplus and divided profits $165,000. port April 1925 showed deposand total assets $2,127,881.

9. April 28, 1925 The Morning Herald Uniontown, PA
Article from The Morning Herald, April 28, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

CARNEGIE BANKS UNDER PROBE OF INVESTIGATORS President Says Institutions Are Sound Financially. INDUSTRY BLAMED By Associated Press PITTSBURGH, Apr. 27. State and federal banking officials today began Investigating the affairs of the Carnegie banks, the Carnegie Trust company and the First National Bank of Carnegie, which closed their doors this morning. The Trust company was the first to close, on orders from Peter G. Cameron, state secretary of banking. Mr. Cameron said "the reserve fund of the Carnegie Trust company has been below legal requirement for some days." The First National closed B few injuctes after opening this morning, officials stating later that they took Action QD their own accord to prevent a run on the bank. Both institutions, of which John A. Bell la president, Rre located in Carnegie, Pa. Secretary Camoron sald "although selection of the famous every effort has been made by the company to build up the reserve to the required amount, It has fulled to do 80 owing to the frozen conditions of Its assets which, In turn, is a direct result of the stagnation which has obtained in the bittiminous coal industry in Penusylvania for several months the company being the hold. era of obilgations of coal companies aggregating a considerable suni. Be cause of these conditions, it WGS the duty of the secretary of banking to take possession of the business and property of the Trust company in order that the interest of the depositors and ed." other creditors might be protectreach of everyone. Late today Secretary Cameron ap pointed Frank Jackson, Apollo, Pa., special deputy agent to assist la con. Unuing or liquidating the affairs of In " statement, Mr. Bell said a meeting of the officials of the First National may be held in a few days and that the bank was sound financial ly. He said the bank would be reopened for business but he did not indicate when. The Carnegle Trust company has a capital and surplus of $700,000, its financial report of April 9, 1925, show ed with deposits of more than $4,000,000 and assets listed M8 $5,664,650. The First National has & capital $100,000 and surplus and undivided of profits of $185,000. It's report of April 6, 1925, showed deposits of $1,759,932 and total assets $2,127,881. SITUATION IS PRECARIOUS CHICAGO, April 27. Commenting on the closing of two banks In the Pittsburgh coal region the Black Dta mond, coal trade publication, today said that the situation throughout the union carlous. bituminous coal fields is pre. Every day the wage scale agree ment signed in February of last year remains in effect It adds to the com plication of every unionized bitu minous mining companies and those financial Black interests back of It, said the Diamond. The central competitive district consisting of Western Pennsylvania, Illinois, Kentucky, Illinois and In diana is at a 35 per cent labor die adventage in competing with the nonunion field under the present wage agreement says the publication which has resulted In two-thirds of the for. mer business going over to non-union fields which produces at 40 cents a ton advantage.

10. April 28, 1925 The Pantagraph Bloomington, IL
Article from The Pantagraph, April 28, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Stagnation In Coal Industry Is Blamed For Closing of Two Banks at Carnegie, Pa. Associated April and federal banking officials vestigating the affairs of two the Carnegie Trust company and the First National of which closed their doors this morning. The trust company was the first close orders of the has the few minutes that stitutions of which John T. Bell president, are located in Carnegie. statement the reserve the Trust company the legal said: has the failed frozen which in direct stagnation the coal the being the holder of and other might be

11. April 28, 1925 The Roanoke Times Roanoke, VA
Article from The Roanoke Times, April 28, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

INVESTIGATE AFFAIRS OF TWO CARNEGIE BANKS (By The affairs two negie Carnegie the First National Bank Carnegie which closed this The the first to ron said: reserve fund the CarTrust has equirements for some National closed minutes officials action took "on vent run the are located in Adding his reserve Secretary though made failed to do owing frozen condition of assets is of the nation that has the minous Pennsyl. some being the aggregating

12. May 23, 1925 The Daily Notes Canonsburg, PA
Article from The Daily Notes, May 23, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

IN THE LOWER VALLEY An aged mother had all her savings in the Trust Co. Her children have not told her of the bank disaster because she has weak heart, and she can't read English so she won't read it in the Signal Item. A school teacher who had her savings in the Trust Co., sent a check to her mother for her birthday. The check came back, so cost the teacher twice the amount she sent. Many business men had to redeem checks given their employes. Carnegie Borough répairs and improvements have to be partially suspended this year owing to the bank failure. A woman who sold her home had all her savings in the Trust Co. and is now penniless. Scores of similarly distressing cases are reported. Last Friday the cash in the First National Bank of Carnegie was transferred to the large steel vaults in the Mellon National Bank of Pittsburgh. Receiver R. F. Marburger did this in compliance with instructions from the Treasury Department at Washington. SO as to assure absolute safety of the funds pending the liq uilation of the bank, which probably will require some time.-Carnegie

13. July 29, 1925 The Patriot-News Harrisburg, PA
Article from The Patriot-News, July 29, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

DISAGREE ON SUITS TRUST PROBE Pinchot's Investigators Want Actions Started in Bell Bank Finally Blocks Move By Associated Press to The Patriot Pittsburgh, July for and against the filing of criminal suits in connection with the recent failure of the Carnegie Trust Company, of which John Bell was president, marked an allday here today Attorney General George W Woodruff and the various investigators inquiring into the bank's affairs. Investigators for GoverPinchot urged that suits filed, while representatives of the State Banking Department insisted that banking code be adhered and that no hasty action be taken. No reached. State representatives intended to file suits today tomorrow but the Attorney General learned the conference that the proposed charges had not been checked. May Act This Week After the conference Mr. Woodruff said the investigation had not reached the stage to bring criminal suits, although there was possibility of such action being taken this week. Those who ferred with the attorney general were Maj. C. McGovern, special investigator for the Governor; Frank Gollmar, deputy attorney general; L. McGee, accountant; Maj. E. Lowry Humes, special counsel for the Banking Department, and Frank W Jack son, bank receiver. He also talked with seven members of the tive committee and counsel for the small depositors protective organization of Carnegie, who laid their case before him. The first suits growing out of the closed First National Bank of Carnegie, also Bell institution, were filed in Pleas Court by Marburger today ceiver for the bank, against George W. Wood and Chidester. Defendants are charged with delivering notes to $30,000 to the bank in 1922 and failing to pay them.

14. July 30, 1925 Standard-Speaker Hazleton, PA
Article from Standard-Speaker, July 30, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

ARGUE ON CRIMINAL SUITS IN BANK CASE Pinchot Probers Want Suits Filed-Banking Department Insists on Banking Code. HARRISBURG, July 29.-Appointment of B. B. Blackburn, president of the First National Bank, Oakmont, and J. H. McGinnity, trust officer and secretary of the Pittsburgh Trust Company, Pittsburgh, to appraise the assets of the Carnegie Trust Company, Carnegie, was announced today at the Department of Banking. The institution was taken over by the Department last April. PITTSBURG. July 29. Arguments for and against the filing of criminal suits in connection with the recent failure of the Carnegie Trust Company, of which John A. Bell, was president. marked an allday conference here today between Attorney General George W. Woodruff and the various investigators inquiring into the bank's affairs. Investigators for Governor Pinchot urged that suits be filed. while representatives of the State Banking Department insisted that the banking code be adhered to and that no hasty action be taken. No decision was reached. State representatives intended to file suits today or tomorrow, but the Attorney General learned at the conference that the proposed charges had not been checked. After the conference Mr. Woodruff said the investigation had not reached the stage to bring criminal suits, although there was a possibility of such action being taken this week. Those who conferred with the Attorney General were Major C. C. McGovern. special investigator for the Governor: Frank I. Gollmar. deputy attorney general; W. L. McGee, accountant: Major E. Lowry Humes, special counsel for the Banking Department and Frank W. Jackson. bank receiver. He also talked with seven members of the executive committee and counsel for the small depositors' protective organization of Carnegie, who laid their case before him. The first suits growing out of the closed First National Bank of Carnegle, also a Bell institution. were filed in common pleas court today by R. F. Marburger, receiver for the bank, against, George W. Wood and P. M. Chidester. Defend-

15. October 17, 1925 Pittsburgh Post-Gazette Pittsburgh, PA
Article from Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, October 17, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Bell Bank Receiver Sues for $1,800 Note R. Marburger, receiver for the closed First National Bank of Carnegie, formerly headed by John A. Bell, filed suit yesterday in Common Pleas Court against Thomas from whom he recover $1,800 said to be due the bank on dated March last. The averred that a loan was at the bank the amount sought and that 60-day was given in When the note fell due at the expiration the 60 payment defaulted Mr Marburger alleged in his action.

16. December 8, 1925 The Pittsburgh Press Pittsburgh, PA
Article from The Pittsburgh Press, December 8, 1925

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BANK RECEIVER SUES SOSSONG FOR $1,525 Another sult the collapse the Bell lions Carnegie common pleas receiver for the First National bank Carnegie, asked $1,252.06 of W. Sossong of Carnegie, the result two notes the latter had there. The two notes were for and $2,000, but credits which Sossong to his account cut the sum due $1,252.60. Attorneys Moorehead and Knox represented Marburger.

17. July 30, 1926 Pittsburgh Post-Gazette Pittsburgh, PA
Article from Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, July 30, 1926

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

0. K. PIPE SALE FOR BELL BANK RECEIVER Acceptance of 54 Per Cent of Proceeds of Hallenbeck Material Authorized. Federal Judge R. M. Gibson terday M. R. Kevil, ceiver of the First National Bank of Carnegie, accept 54 per cent of the proceeds of the of certain pipe Hallenback of owned by Louis, and 54 per cent of the collection of all other assets sale of discharge of the edaims of the bank against him as acceptor of certain trade acceptances drawn by the Interstate Pipe Company on him. The order forth that all rights of the receiver of against the company and against John pipe A. in as surety on the trade acceptances be reserved. The other cent of the receipts the pipe, to Mr. Kevil, paid the town National Bank, which holds other on Hollenback. The Railway Equipment have the successful bidder for the pipe.