Click image to open full size in new tab
Article Text
POLITICS AND SAVINGS. The Incongruity of the Two Aptly Illustrated. A LITTLE YORKVILLE BANK One of Harry Genet's Commercial Adventures and Its Sorry Results. In the year 1869, when Harry Genes was rejoicing in his political strength and accumulating fortunes, one of his speculative humors turned in the direction of Yorkville, which he deemed to be sadiy in need of a savings bank. It seemed to him a proper thing that the industrious people of that section of the city should have some little convenient institution in which to deposit such a proportion of their weekly earnings as circumstances would permit them to lay by. Mr. Genet was a philanthropist, 100, and, seeing a hard time abead (for others, if not for himself), he yearned to implant an early disposition for economy among the working classes of Yorkville. Thus It happened that the Yorkville Savings Bank sprang into existence under a very favorable charter, which permitted the officers to accept deposits as well as sav. ings. The list of organizers was selected mainly from the ranks of Mr. Genet's acquaintances, and not a few of them will be recollected by those familiar with the city polities of that day. Their names were as follows:-President, Harry Genet: Vice Presidents, John McQuaue and Thomas Crombie; Secretary, John Gillelan; Trustees, Bernard Kelly, John B. McKeon, Thomas Donsbue, Jeremiah Feore, John S. Mastertoo, William H. Johnson, Peter McGinnis, Laurence R. Kerr, Gilbert Palmer, Prank S. Tuomey, Edward A. Moore, Isaac Edwards, John M. Hall, Michael McCunn, with the loug officers first named. ON ITS LEGS. So the philauthropic plan was inaugurated, and an office was opened on Third avenue, near Eighty-eighth street. Mr. Genet contributed a safe, furnished by Messrs. McBride Davidson & Co., for which that worthy officer was duly rewarded by a vote of thanks from the trustees. The Industrious people of York. ville were invited to deposit their carnings with the new and promising concern, and for the convenience of the hardest working classes the doors were kept open on three evenings of each week. As an infant the bank flourished moderately, but history must record the painful truth that its second childhood fell where its first should have begun. Outsidethe few good souls who devoted themselves to its management and the depositors, little was known of the bank until the time when Mr. Genet found it convenient to leave the city. For some time before that, personal matters had so occupied his time that it may be supposed the interests of the bank were allowed to languish. When he left he sent in a formal resignation, which was accepted. An examination soon alterward showed that the bank's affairs did not altogether balance. and a few thousand dollars were wisely contributed by the officers "10 keep the thing going." SOMETHING WRONG AGAIN. But these generous men bad not reached their last point of sacrifice. Among the (at one time) assets of the concern were $10,000 bonds of the Alabama and Chattanooga Railroad. These defaulted in interest after the second instalment and became virtually of no value. Nevertheless both the bonds and accrued interest were carried as assets and so reported to Albany. Au "examination took place in December, 1875, when is was discovered that the bonds were worthless and the officers were ordered to replace them. The then President, Mr. Laurence R. Kerr, donated $6,000 in cash for this purpose, and she balance was made up by two mortgages-one from Frank S. Tuomey, the then Vice President and Clerk of the Common Council, for $4,000, and another from John McQuade for a similar amount. From this time the bank eked out an existence, with no visible means of support. The Yorkvillers did not seem to feel the same amount of confidence in " that Mr. Genet and his friends had done. Perhaps the largest business done with any single depositor was with one Horace F. Tilden, and that was afterward regretted, as will appear below. On the 6th of last June another examination was made by the Bank Superintendent, and deficiency of $700 appeared. Thereupon Judge Landon was applied to at Schenectady and on June 10 an order Was granted suspending the business of the bank. Later on in the same month Mr. Vedder Van Dyck was appointed receiver, and he alterward employed Mr. C. H. W. Sibley, an accountant, to make an analysis of the little institution. ANXIOUS DEPOSITORS. For a few months past those who have been awaiting adividend from the assets of the bank have become naturally irritated at the silence of the receiver. The official examination showed but a small deficiency, and high hopes were entertained of a large dividend. The report made to Superintendent Eilis showed liabilities of $20,587 69 and assets of $19, 866 08. or the latter sum $8,000 lay in the two bonds and mortgages of Tuomey and McQuade, ciready mentioned; safe and fixtures, $2,500; cash, $2,729 81, and overdratts claimed to be good by officers, $6,646 27. The bank's statement of the preced ng January claimed surplus of $504 65. Amoug the assets as then reported Bonds and mortgages, $8,500; Long island City bonds, $5,702 50; cash in other banks, $2,462 92, and cash on band, $2,841 24. The writer undertook yesterday to discover what remained of the once beautiful institution, and where the remoant was buried. At No. 1,530 Third avenue, the former office, he found a placard stating that the receiver's office was at No. 291 Broadway, room 29. At this address, and until Mr. Vedder Van Dyck himself answered to the appellation of receiver, there was nothing observable to denote that the Yorkville Savings Bank had ever been heard of in that locality. Such au experience alone would be sufficiently discouraging to depositors, but a conversation with Mr. Van Dyck was enough to dispel all hope He began by saying that the absence 01 Mr. Sibley had somewhat deferred his making report to the Court. He said he had collected from all sources some $2,200 in cash. This included what he had lound in the office of the bank, in other banks and recovered from overdrafts. He thought the turniture and safe would realize about $500 at auction sale and there were the two mortgages for $4,000 each, which completed the list of assets. But of the two concluding items there were some explanations to be made. WHO OWNS THE SAFE? The members of the old set, of which Mr. Genet was one, were never put to much expense in obtaining little articles for their personal use. So it happened that Mr. Genet presented his bank with a safe, and was duly thanked by the trustees. When Messrs McBride Davidson & Co. got into the hands of re. ceiver, in 1875, the Inter brought RUIS against the savings bank for the price of the safe, $2,500. He claimed that it had been sold to Mr. Genet the Prestdent, not to Mr. Genet the politician. This suit isstill pending, and It may not matter much to the depositors whether that sale will bring at auction $500 or $2,500. THE MORTGAGES. The receiver then went on to explain that both of the $4,000 mortgages were contested by the mortgagors. They were given in the early part of 1876, and in the early part of 1877 Mr. Tuomey handed in his resignation, and requested that bis mortgage be returned, as he wished to sell the property. The mortgage had been recorded, but Mr. Tuomey claimed that 11 and never been intended, and ollered a new one for the same amount, in order to satisfy the first of record. The Executive Committee referred the subject to Mr. Alexander Thain to "draw up and ex. amine. Mr. Thain newly elected member of the