16481. Phenix National Bank (New York, NY)

Bank Information

Episode Type
Run Only
Bank Type
national
Bank ID
1374
Charter Number
1374
Start Date
May 14, 1884
Location
New York, New York (40.714, -74.006)

Metadata

Model
gpt-5-mini
Short Digest
df4e90fb

Response Measures

Accommodated withdrawals

Description

Multiple contemporary accounts (May 14–15, 1884) describe a run on Phenix National Bank in New York that was quelled the same day: the bank paid out regularly, officers reassured customers, and the clearing house meeting settled the trouble. No suspension or receivership is reported.

Events (3)

1. July 1, 1865 Chartered
Source
historical_nic
2. May 14, 1884 Run
Cause
Rumor Or Misinformation
Cause Details
Widespread belief/rumors that the bank was unsound (sparked by the bank's refusal to certify broker checks unless funds were on deposit), causing depositors to demand cash.
Measures
Paying tellers paid out money as called for; president Dutilh and officers reassured customers at the door; Clearing House meeting settled the trouble and reports indicate the bank was paying regularly.
Newspaper Excerpt
The Phenix National Bank found itself besieged about noon with a multitude clamoring for money... The belief got abroad that the bank was unsound, and the turmoil began in front of its doors.
Source
newspapers
3. March 28, 1911 Voluntary Liquidation
Source
historical_nic

Newspaper Articles (4)

Article from New-York Tribune, May 15, 1884

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

GENERAL FEATURES OF THE DAY. CROWDS IN AND ABOUT WALL STREET. HOW THE ANNOUNCEMENTS OF THE FAILURES WERE RECEIVED. Much earlier than usual Wall Street was alive On the way to the street the brokers had of companions when a they had had one. Several yesterday. hundreds thousand neighborhood persons day before of had in the streets in the the before 10 the the men gathered Stock who Exchange sought o'clock, floor had and to elbow their way through a dense crowd. The majority. of course, were mere curiosity-seekers. They betrayed this afterward by standing for hours and staring at the buildings in which were the offices of the firms whose failures were announced at intervals between 10 o'clock and noon. Others had a more vital interest. These did not spend much time in looking about them; they pushed past the starers and disappeared in the brokers' offices. The brokers went upon the floor of the Exchange in larger force than usual. There they took part in occurrences, but the demonstrations not different on an day. In fact, tension ordinarily many were exciting busy widely when from those the was the business of was comparatively carried greatest on with the little Exchange noise. The happenings which set the outside crowd to rushing madly and aimlessly about subdued their brokers. Announcements were made from the rostrum every few minutes, but it was only after the news a failure was thus communicated that half alhundred men would dash wildly through the doors,and communicate their madness to the wondering multitude outside. Then a great tide in the human sea would set toward the office of the broken firm, to swirl and eddy in front of it for the rest of the day. WALL STREET ALMOST IMPASSABLE. Long before noon Wall-st. was almost impass able. Seen from the steps of Trinity Church it was black with human beings as far as the vision reached. Carriages, cabs and stages which turned into it occasionally had to make their way slowly through the path which opened in front of them. Here and there a surging mass, denser and more ex. cited than usual, was seemingly thrown up against the front of a house. Thus the offices of the brokers who had gone down e distinguished. The first of the firms was Nelson Robinson & Co., at No. 18 Wall-st. Then followed Goffe & Randle, at No. 5 New-st.; then O.M. Bogart & Co., at No.108 Broadway : and at this spot, at Broadway and Pine-st., the crowning excitement of the day was reached when about half-past 11 the Metropolitan Bank closed its doors. At ten minutes before 11 the last violent irruption from the Exchange took place. A hundred men burst almost simultaneously from the doors into New-st., gasped Hatch & Foote' as they dived into the crowd, and disappeared in all directions. Nearly all the banks 111 the vicinity of Wall-st. were crowded with people eager to reach the windows of the paying tellers. The failure of Nelson Robinson & Co., a firm composed of a son-inlaw and two sons of George I. Seney, and the fact that the Metropolitan Bank had been under suspicion for a week, started a run on that concern. The paying teller paid out money as it was called for, or certified the checks presented in the usual order of business until twenty minutes after 11 o'clock. Then he shut his window, and the announcement was made that the bank had suspended. The heavy doors in front were closed, policemen were stationed at the head of the steps to keep back the multitude, and communication between the bank officers and their customers was cut off. Till nightfall people jostled each other off the iron steps their anxiety to read the notices tacked on the door, which told simply where drafts drawn by correspondent bankers would be honored. THE CROWD EAGER FOR NEWS. On the part of the crowd there was a disposition to believe any story which told of disaster. A chance word of conversation, which had a questionable sound was picked up repeated, developed with lightning-like rapidity into a damaging ru mor. and accepted for fact, The Phenix National Bank found itself besieged about noon with a multitude clamoring for The bank began some time ago to money. reduce its broker business, and in pursuit of this policy had refused to certify checks unless there was money actually on deposit. The belief got abroad that the bank was unsound, and the turmoil began in front of its doors. President Dutilh took his station at the head of the steps in front of the bank, shook the bands of those of his customers whom he knew, and a hundred times gave the information that the bank was all right, and that those who wanted their money could have it. In an hour or two the excitement here was allayed. THE LAST ANNOUNCEMENT OF A FAILURE. The last announcement of a failure in the Board as made at 2,30. It was that of Hotchkiss & Burnham. The gavel had been kept going almost incessantly while the chairman of the Board was closing transactions under the rule" on a account of the suspended firms. but vigorous rapping than usual at the time mentioned called nearly every member on the floor to the vicinity of the rostrum. The intelligence was received with shouts of " Oh!" and whistlings, and a rush into the street. Afterward little attention was paid to the announcements. As the hands of the clock approached 3 there came a great erescendo of sound, which wasswelled into a deafening din by the signal gong. A quick hush followed the stream of enectators


Article from The Portland Daily Press, May 15, 1884

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

The New York Panic. The news of the failures in New York were bulletined at the Merchants Exchange yesterday, and the board was quickly surrounded by merchants and other members of the Exchange. When the news came that the Phenix National Bank had failed, there was more than the usual interest manifested, as that bank is the New York correspondent of the Traders' National of this city. Mr. Edward Gould, the cashier of the Traders, said he could hardly believe the report, as the Phenix was a very conservative institution. Mr. Wm. E. Gould, cashier of the First National, telegraphed his correspondent in New York and received the following answer at 4 p. m.: New YORK, May 14. To W. E. Gould, Cashier First National Bank, Portland, Me.: Phenix all a mistake. Was a run on them, but paying regularly. Meeting of Clearing House has settled all the trouble. F. B. SCHENCK, Cashier. The feeling among the business men here was that the failures would probably clear the atmosphere, and once more put the business of this country on a legitimate basis.


Article from New-York Tribune, May 15, 1884

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

HOPEFUL VIEWS OF JOHN A. STEWART. John A. Stewart, president of the United States Trust Company, said last night to a TRIBUNE reporter: The action taken by the banks to-day is the wlsest step possible under the circumstances and should in my estimation do much toward restoring confidence in business circles. It will prove beneficial to all. As you may know, all those banks which can show sound financial condition will be protected in any demand to the extent of 75 per cent on the securities held. This will band them together, and the public will feel that each bank will be supported by the others to almost the full extent of its capital. As to the situation generally, I think you have seen the worst of it, and two or three days will see the end of the present panicky feeling. When things have guieted down a healthier and better tone will prevail. I feel sure that in a short time, I might almost say within ten days, money will be going begging again. Those on the Stock Exchange have received a sharp lesson, but one that was needed, and has long been needed. Now as to the bank troubles of to-day. The Second National has passed the crisis of the attack. There 18 now no manner of doubt but that it 18 a perfectly solvent institution. Mr. Scriba's statement of itself ought to have reassured foolish and scared depositors, but I think the action of the directors in keeping open beyond their ordinary closing hour removed the last lingering doubt in the minds of the most timid. It was a wise step under the circumstances. The Phenix Bank practically weathered its storm this afternoon. I believe, by the way, that the true inwardness of run upon it may be traced to its treatment of the brokers. A week ago the bauk refused to certify any checks unless the money was actually on deposit. The brokers felt annoyed at this and seized the first opportunity to give their annoyance a practical shape. In future this will be the course adopted by all banks."


Article from Arizona Weekly Citizen, May 17, 1884

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Condensed Telegrams. 'incinnati grand jury hae found fif. ou. indictments growing out of the recent riots. Payson has introduced a bill in Conto restrict the ownership of real gress estate in the Territories to American citizens. An indictment has been found against T.C. Campbell, a C neinnati lawyer who defended William Bowen, the murderer of Kirk. The charge is bribery. He gave bail in the sum of $1,000. H. L. Wells, a witness for the defense in the Hill-Sharon case, who contessed to having sworn falsely, has been arrested for perjury. The California Legislature adjourns sine die at Tuesday noon. The Anti-Monopolist national convention was opened Wednesday at Boston. It is probable that Benjamin F. Butler will be nominated for President. The Grand Lodge O. F., of Cali fornia, began its thirty-second session in San Francisco on Tuesday, with Grand Master W. W. Morrow in the chair. Charles M. Bayard, stock broker of Philadelphia, has failed. Liabilities not stated. The Atlantic bank, of Brooklyn, N. Y., closed its doors on Wednesday. The New Jersey Democratic State Convention met on Wednesday and was presided over by Senator McPherson, who counseled harmony and laying aside all small issues. Don Fernando Pacheco, aged 60; weight 425 lbs., died at Martinez, Cal., Monday. The following New York banks have closed their doors: Manhattan National, Metropolitan National, Phenix National and Second National. Francisco bankers believe the will no New San York panic except have to stiffen effect upon the Pacific coast rates somewhat. They maintain that the country is in condit on to stand a much greater shock than this. For several days past the passenger rates from Denver to the Missouri have been in a very unsettled condition, but not until Tuesday has a cut been openly declared. The agents of the Burlington, Missouri, Union Pacific, Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe announce a cut unprecedented in the history of Western roads, viz: $5 to Kansas City; $8.50 to St. Louis: $14.50 to Chicago, and $28 to are in New York. They easteru fact selling point tickets from any principal for Kansas City at the same rate as to as the eastern But the result as Roads are free to that pro named. passengers rate. point Kansas carrying roads issued is City. through refused above a cir- Pool commissioner Daniels has cular ordering the restoration of rates to take effect on the 15th instant. This order however will surely be ignored. Capt. Monroe of the steamer City of Rome, stated that on April 23, while passing six sailing vessels, almost becalmed, within two or three miles of each other, a full rigged ship was observed two or three miles away, displaying signals which as interpreted by me, meat "ship wrecked crew safe," but no signal was or if was not seen, nor was displayed urgency displayed, the name or nationality of the ship given. Had the signal of distress or urgency been seen it would have had immediate attention as the day was calm. Signal dropping is difficult to make out, but it would have been easy for the vessul to have put out a boat which could have been intercepted by the City of Rome, but not until after his arrival at Liverpool, and hearing that a State line steamer was overdue that the incident became connected in his mind with the indistinct signal, when he at once reported his conjecture. "I certainly," he be the last man said, "would to render neglect the duty of every seaman to as sistance to any one in distrees at sea, having on more than one occasion been indebted to others for the preservation of my OWD life." The first and fourth officers on watch, on duty at the time of eignaling, certify their adherence to Munroe's statement.