16437. Ocean Bank (New York, NY)

Bank Information

Episode Type
Suspension → Closure
Bank Type
state
Start Date
November 20, 1881
Location
New York, New York (40.714, -74.006)

Metadata

Model
gpt-5-mini
Short Digest
601d04f1

Response Measures

None

Description

Articles (Nov–Dec 1881) describe internal embezzlement by the paying teller and directors' fraudulent discounts, the bank being 'in the hands of a receiver.' No explicit run is described. Therefore this is a suspension/closure (receivership) driven by bank-specific adverse information / internal fraud.

Events (2)

1. November 20, 1881 Receivership
Newspaper Excerpt
Such was the history of a bank whose capital was entirely paid in, the amount being a half million ... in the hands of a receiver, the stock was only worth ten per cent.
Source
newspapers
2. November 20, 1881 Suspension
Cause
Bank Specific Adverse Info
Cause Details
Large embezzlement by the paying teller (McGutcheon) and directors' fraudulent discounts on fictitious securities leading to insolvency and placement in receivership.
Newspaper Excerpt
The Artisans' Bank was robbed by its directors, and so was the Ocean Bank. The latter had suffered severely from depredations of its paying teller, and was afterwards 'cracked' by burglars. It might have survived, but the directors concluded to finish the work ... in the hands of a receiver, the stock was only worth ten per cent.
Source
newspapers

Newspaper Articles (2)

Article from The Dallas Daily Herald, November 20, 1881

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

# BANKS THAT WERE ROBBED. Wholesale Plunder of Money Institutions by Cashiers, Directors and Burglars-No Punishment-Hundreds of Thousands Gone Beyond Recall The New York correspondent of the Hart- ford Times sends to his paper an interesting account of the many bank swindles and de- falcations which have occurred in this city. After writing of the overdraft which Bald- win, the defaulting cashier of the suspen- ded Mechanics' National Bank of Newark, claims to have granted Nugent, the corres- pondent says: Business men when extremely short use every effort to obtain the privilege of over- draft, which when granted generally leads to ruin. I well remember the instance of Paying Teller MeGutcheon of the Ocean Bank, who yielded to such an appeal and certified a check for a friend. The appeal was continued, and in hope of obtaining the money thus wrongfully lent other fa- vors were granted. At last the amount be- came so large that the teller became the slave of his former friend and was obliged to keep up the accommodation until the in- evitable explosion took place. The bank lost $90,000 and the teller was ruined. The Grocers' Bank was robbed by its pay- ing teller, George Clark. No punishment could be inflicted. The Tradesman's Bank was robbed by one of its clerks of $40,000. The criminal was shattered by dissipation and died in the hospital. The Fourth Na- tional Bank also occupied a place in the list, the loss being about $30,000. The paying tel- ler of the American Exchange Bank wound up his career by robbing the bank of $90,000. The City Bank is one of the best managed of these institutions, its president being Moses Taylor, whose fame as a financier is widely extended. Yet in this admirable concern the heaviest defalcation ever known in this city took place. The cul- prit's name was Leverich. He came of high family, and showed his dignity by the extent of his peculation, which was more than $400,000. It was admitted that noth- ing could be done, and there the matter ended. Paying Teller Ellis, of the Park National Bank, robbed the latter of $61,000 with equal impunity. One instance of a bank clerk's punish- ment for peculation, is found in the case of the Fulton Bank. The note clerk, who was the son of the cashier, spent $60,000 of bank funds. The thief actually got four years in State prison. One of the most curious bank defalcations of the day occurred in the Gallatin National Bank. A leading em- ploye had for a long time used the bank funds for the purchase of "business paper." He was an expert judge of credit, and found the traffic very profitable. One day, how- ever, his account was found short. He at once admitted the fact, and turned out a quantity of "gilt-edged" to balance the discrepancy. The Artisans' Bank was robbed by its di- rectors, and so was the Ocean Bank. The latter had suffered severely from depreda- tions of its paying teller, and was after- wards "cracked" by burglars. It might have survived, but the directors concluded to finish the work, and this they did in a very effectual manner. Their method was to discount loans on fictitious securities, such as paper railroad bonds, and the result was, that in the hands of a receiver, the stock was only worth ten per cent. Such was the history of a bank whose capital was entirely paid in, the amount being a half million. The Grocers' Bank was robbed in the same manner, and the shareholders found themselves the victims of sharp prac- tice on the part of those to whom they had committed their interests. Having referred to a case of punishment among defaulting clerks, I may add to it the sole instance of penalty inflicted on a dishonest cashier. This was found in the Atlantic Bank. The entire capital of this institution ($300,000) was swamped by its cashier (Taintor), who was deeply engaged in stock speculation. He dabbled in Pacific Mail till all was gone and then the doors were closed. The outraged stockholders succeeded in placing the thief under a four years' sentence in the penitentiary. As an additional illustration of the loose method of banking in this city, it may be added that ten savings banks have failed within a few years. The term "failed" is used conven- tionally. The correct statement is that they have been robbed by their officers and three millions of the earnings of the have in this manner been wasted. For this atrocious series of crimes no penalty has been inflicted, nor indeed has any arrest been made.


Article from Grant County Herald, December 1, 1881

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

# Bank Robbing in New York. Looking at the bank record of this city it is surprising to observe the immunity with which our banks have been plundered by their confidential servants. I have referred to Paying Teller McGutcheon, of the Ocean Bank, who escaped all penalty. The Grocers' Bank was robbed of an equal amount by its paying teller, George Clarke, who spent the money in stylish extravagance. His case was a flagrant one, and yet no punishment could be inflicted. The Tradesmen's Bank was robbed by one of its clerks of $40,000. In this case an arrest was made, but nothing further was done. The criminal was shattered by dissipation and died in the hospital. The Fourth National also occupies a place in the list, the loss being about $30,000. The paying teller of the American Exchange Bank was noted for his rapidity and accuracy in counting money. He was in fact a prodigy in this specialty, but he wound up his career by robbing the bank of $90,000. The City Bank is one of the best managed of these institutions, its President being Moses Taylor, whose fame as a financier is widely extended. Yet in this admirable concern the heaviest defalcation ever known in this city took place. The culprit's name was Leverich. He came of a high family, and showed his dignity by the extent of his peculation, which was more than $400,000. It was admitted that nothing could be done, and there the matter ended. Paying Teller Ellis, of the Park Bank, robbed the latter of $600,000 with equal impunity. The only instance of a bank clerk's punishment on record in this city for peculation is found in the case of the Fulton Bank. The note clerk who was son of the cashier, spent $60,000 of bank funds. I cannot give the details of the procedure here, but there was a peculiar feature in the crime which authorized an indictment. The thief actually got four years in the State Prison, This was at the rate of $15,000 a year, and for such pay many would be willing to take a similar term. One of the most curious bank defalcations of the day occurred at the Gallatin National Bank. A leading employe had for a long time used bank funds for the purchase of "business paper." He was an expert judge of credit, and found the traffic very profitable. One day, however, his account was found short. He at once admitted the fact, and turned out a quantity of "gilt edged" to balance the discrepancy. There can be little wonder at such robbery among the clerks when officers are so frequently dishonest. The bookkeepers and tellers are well satisfied that their employers steal at every opportunity, and hence it may be asked, Why should they not do the same? The Artisans' Bank was robbed by its Directors, and so was the Ocean Bank. The latter had suffered severely from the depredations of its paying teller, and was afterward cracked by burglars. It might have survived, but the Directors concluded to finish the work, and this they did in a very effectual manner. Their method was to discount loans on fictitious securities, such as paper railroad bonds, and the result was that in the hands of a receiver the stock was only worth 10 per cent. Such was the history of a bank whose capital was entirely paid in, the amount being a half million. The Grocers' Bank was robbed in the same manner, and the shareholders found themselves the victims of sharp practice on the part of those to whom they had committed their interests. - New York Letter.