15265. National City Bank (New Rochelle, NY)

Bank Information

Episode Type
Run → Suspension → Closure
Bank Type
national
Bank ID
6427
Charter Number
6427
Start Date
March 20, 1933
Location
New Rochelle, New York (40.911, -73.782)

Metadata

Model
gpt-5-mini
Short Digest
33f8484b

Response Measures

Borrowed from banks or large institutions, Capital injected, Full suspension, Books examined

Other: Depositors' committee organized stock-subscription plan to form First National Bank to liquidate assets; conservator then receiver appointed.

Receivership Details

Depositor recovery rate
45.0%
Date receivership started
1934-02-01
Share of assets assessed as good
49.1%
Share of assets assessed as doubtful
38.6%
Share of assets assessed as worthless
12.3%

Description

Articles describe heavy withdrawals and deposit shrinkage in March 1933 leading to restricted operations, appointment of a conservator and suspension; the bank remained in receivership with assets liquidated and a new First National Bank organized from subscribers. Receiver Edward D. Loughman was appointed and the bank's assets were being liquidated through 1934. Thus a run led to suspension and permanent closure/receivership.

Events (5)

1. September 17, 1902 Chartered
Source
historical_nic
2. March 20, 1933 Run
Cause
Bank Specific Adverse Info
Cause Details
Large withdrawals and sustained run driven by deposit leakage, shrinkage of deposits, and impaired collateral/loans (losses and inability to meet RFC/other borrowings).
Measures
Depositors' committee organized stock-subscription plan; liquidation of notes and use of collateral to pay prior loans; attempts to form First National Bank to assume assets.
Newspaper Excerpt
the most severe blow of with public ment from Washington RFC loans. sustained run the bank brought total deposits down to
Source
newspapers
3. March 21, 1933 Suspension
Cause
Government Action
Cause Details
Conservator (Rennie, then Loughman) appointed and bank suspended pending reorganization following the run and regulatory action during the banking holiday.
Newspaper Excerpt
the following day all banking this Institution suspended until plan could be formuHis appointment confirmed, Mr. Rennie resigned his position president of National Bank, order to devote his ento task of reorganization of the National City Bank.
Source
newspapers
4. February 1, 1934 Receivership
Source
historical_nic
5. February 5, 1934 Receivership
Newspaper Excerpt
NAMED BANK RECEIVER NEW ROCHELLE, Feb. ward D. Loughman, Federal servator the National City Bank, of New Rochelle, appointed receiver of that institution by T. comptroller of the currency. He liquidate the old frozen assets and later coverage refers to Loughman as receiver and disposing assets (HOLC bonds, leasing property).
Source
newspapers

Newspaper Articles (10)

Article from The Standard-Star, August 3, 1933

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

LOANS BY NATIONAL CITY, 'FREE' COLLATERAL Obligations Met With Funds Raised Through Liquidadation of Notes MOVE PROTECTS ASSETS Depositors Supporting New Plan Now Total Nearly 8.000 in Number The closed National City Bank New Rochelle, victim run today climbed rung nearer daylight when paid off $730.000 loan the Reserve Bank York and collateral ued twice that today that the closed bank has paid off $300.loan the Chase National Bank and $200,000 Reconstruction Finance Liquidation Progressing Most funds loans off realized through the liquidation and other of the closed institution. bank officials ported that liquidation the paper at an increasingly satisfactory also by the cials that further proceeds from liquidation will be applied the Chase loans. It pointed that all which by collateral valued at least twice the amount the loans, would have whether the bank placed the hands of receiver assets transferred the proposed First National Bank under the organization Liquidate Obligations It pointed by spokesman Depositors Committee of bank that cials the institution have ceeded liquidating old As colposted the Federal Reserve Bank, the and the Chase recaptured will be placed into the process of liquimoney borrowed from the three institutions during the terrific run old bank prior bank Meanwhile the Depositors' Committee reported steady subscripof stock depositors, flecting Increased confidence in the proposed First National Bank plan The number of shares subscribed today had the 8,000 mark after remaining in the vicinity 7,500 for several weeks. Committee Will Meet The Depositors' Committee will meet tomorrow night the bank for the purpose formulating and handing out final instructions to voluntary workers, preparatory to instituting personal drive among the depositors to subscribe the shares of stock necessary to insure the success of the plan.


Article from The Standard-Star, August 7, 1933

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

NEW BANK MAYORS' HELP IN PLEASES CORDIAL RATE WAR ASKED Enthusiastic Reception Given Campaign: Subscriptions Pass 8,300 Mark Subscription of stock in the proposed new First National Bank of New Rochelle today passed the 8,300 mark and was steadily Raymond McGovern the depositors committee and Edward chairman of the special campaign committee. reported. Mr. Cordial enthusiastic about the reception the stock subscription campaign was being given by depositors. He planned to call meeting of the Fourth Ward division the campaign committee for some time this week, probably Thursday, to reports on the campaign in that section. Edward D. Loughman, new conservator the closed National City Bank, today visited the West branch of the institution routine He accompanied Shea, vice-president of by the closed bank. Lehman Wants Support for $300,000 to Aid Commission in Its Work By The Associated Press Aug. Herbert H. Lehman today called upon the State Conference of Mayors support his public utilities program now before the legislature means of hastening the reduction gas and electricity out the state. In letter to William P. Capes, secretary the conference, the governor asked particularly support bringing about the actment of his bill to make the utilities companies pay part of the cost rate such the 200 before the Public Service Commission. The Governor also asked the ference to support his proposal for working capital fund which would enable the Public Service Commision to take extra hands and facilitate fixing temporary emergency reductions


Article from The Standard-Star, August 7, 1933

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

NEW BANK DRIVE MAYORS' HELP IN PLEASES CORDIAL RATE WAR ASKED Enthusiastic Reception Given Campaign; Subscriptions Pass 8,300 Mark Subscription of stock in the proposed new First National Bank of New Rochelle today passed the mark and was steadily creasing Raymond McGovern the depositors committee and Edward Cordial chairman of the special campaign reported Mr. Cordial enthusiastic about the reception the stock subscription campaign was being given by depositors He planned call meeting of the Fourth Ward division the campaign committee some time this probably Thursday, reports on the campaign in Edward D. Loughman servator the closed National City Bank, visited the West branch of the institution routine accompanied by of the closed bank. Lehman Wants Support for $300,000 to Aid Commission in Its Work By The Associated Press ALBANY Aug. Governor Herbert H. Lehman today called upon the State Conference Mayors support his public utilities program now before the legislature means hastening the reduction of gas and electricity rates through out the state In letter to William P. Capes, secretary the conference the governor asked particularly for support in bringing about the his to make the utilities pay of the cost of rate the 200 before the Public Service Commission The Governor asked the ference support his proposal for working capital fund which would enable the Public SerCommision to take on extra hands and facilitate the fixing temporary emergency reductions in


Article from The Standard-Star, October 24, 1933

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BANK STOCK BRINGING SUPPORT 125 Volunteer Workers to Gather Thursday Night to Map Drive Windup STOCK SUBSCRIPTIONS Previously Listed 13,122 New Pledges 29 Total to Date 13,151 Necessary to Open 15,000 Enthusiasm over the "Open the New Bank Before Thanksgiving drive was revealed today when man who has already subscribed to more than hundred shares of stock for cash, today asked George S. Vrionis, trust officer of the National City Bank, to convert $300 in Liberty Bonds to cash, 80 that he can take 10 more shares. One hundred and twenty-five volunteer workers have been asked to attend meeting in the National City Bank building Thursday at P. M. Two are sought from each of the fraternal and civic in the city, and letters have gone out from Edward Cordial, chairman of the campaign committee, asking them sit in. "We have reached point where we find it necessary to appeal again to the depositors who have subscribed and to ask them if they will talk and persuade friend who not yet subscribed do letters signed by LeRoy Franz, chairman of the depositors' committee, say. "If each the 2,000 depositors who have already subscribed would take additional shares, it would open the bank With total of 13,151 subscribed today, only 1,849 needed to finance the proposed First National Bank of New Rochelle, an institution through which the assets of the closed National City Bank will be liquidated.


Article from The Standard-Star, January 22, 1934

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

New Bank's Successful Climax To Months Of Hard Work A 10 Opening HUGE TASK FINDS OUTSTANDING MEN AIDING MOVEMENT Long Uphill Grind Crowned With Charter Grant as Reward By ELDORUS DAYTON Writer The First National Bank of New Rochelle rose like Phoenix, youthful freshness own dead ashes. Behind origin of this new banking institution tale conquest, story of the victory hope, perseverance and purpose the doubts and fears which harassed the munity since the failure the National City Bank to reopen in March. Bank "Holiday" Declared It was back on that momentous day, March that, unknowingly. circumstances were created which were eventually lead the death one of City's leading banks and the birth of new one in place. that the same date on which Franklin Delano Roosevelt took over the helm of the Ship State, Governor Herbert H. Lehdeclared bank because "the spread of hysand the restrictions upon the banking of the country through the measures adopted in many states. "Holiday" Extended The holiday had been declared for period of two days. but 48 hours and the period was extended the new Federal Government took hold the situation On March situation was somewhat alleviated when supply cash for payrolls, food and medicine released by order the Treasury WilSecretary H. first break in the was the Mark cloud the banking crisis. Sound Banks Open rife fever of expectancy as on March throughout the city Roosevelt announced President 100 cent solonly those banks per would open their doors. Speculation among depositors of the various banks institutions would be the fortunate ones. Two days later local banks were preparing applications open forerunner their transmission Hope grew on Washington. March sound institutions in New York City threw open their doors. institution in New The first unlatch sealed portals chelle Bank for Savings the People's with permission to March $25. It was grant up the New Roclosely followed by and the Cenchelle Trust Company National Bank the 15th. Two days this the Huguenot Trust Company threw open its Wait Hopefully The depositors National City Bank waited confithat the financial center in dent had their would which they money resume business soon officers had gone through the mosions of certain technicalities. But March 18 the National City Bank was operating only on restricted basis, and on March 20 Robert R. Rennie, its president conservator according telephonic communifrom Washington, and the following day all banking this Institution suspended until plan could be formuHis appointment confirmed, Mr. Rennie resigned his position president of National Bank, order "to devote his ento task of reorganization of the National City Bank". to be submitted to plan, ington for commenced undergo process of formulation. Committee Gathers The first meeting deposttors' committee, the harbinger of scores depositors meetings which were to follow and which to result in the opening of the new institution because the indefatigibility its members. was held March 24 Members the late W. M. Roy Frantz, Dr. Guion Edwin Knapp Mayor Walter Otto, James McDonald. Dr. Marino, William Merrill Frederick L. Moran. the late John H. Ranges, former Mayor Harry Scott, McDonald and Raymond Mr. Mullaney later was replaced by Mr. Frantz chairman of the and former Mayor Scott succeeded to the latter while he absent during the months Frantz served up the time of the opening of the Work On Reorganization Shortly policy of censured publicity was adopted while work went ahead plan. Between March 24 and May 26 there was little given the anxiously waiting depositors. That did not that nothing was being done later six reorganization plans were up within that space of time and presented Washington. The Federal Govto ernment turned down all of them. On May 26, Conservator Rennie and William vice-president of the closed institution, went Washington personally to take to up the matter acceptable reorganization plan. The condition the bank had been to large drain cash period days and economic conditions which securities pledged for loans and other collatthe Prodigious shrinkage in deposits shown by published statements the City Bank. The peak on Dec. when records showed total 1928, Twelve deposits months later they had maintained almost the level, Depression Takes Toll The took its of depression Oct. 1932 the by deposits been reduced to The last state1933 showed time deposits of certified deposits and cashiers checks, government total of The most severe blow of with public ment from Washington RFC loans. sustained run the bank brought total deposits down to although exact figures had ever been made public. The leakage of more than five millions cash more than bank which had three millions frozen in mortgages could stand. In adopting reorganization plan was necessary to find out that which would give ready amount of cash and yet slowly liquidate the assets of the old institution The "Spokane plan" of subsidizing an entirely new bank, with depositors of the old institution pledging 10 per cent of their deposits stock, the total amount of $450.000. gradually effecting the amortization of the assets, was adopted S. Accepts Plan On June Federal Government accepted the program, and the following day letters went out to depositors and were printed in newspapers. By June several workers had volunteered their services sell stock. Within days 1.310 shares had been pledged. the result of general gathering of depositors in Columbus School. Within the space of single month. total amount stock subscriptions had leaped 6,500. interim Mr. Rennie had publicly announced he would not officer in the new bank, but would in the best intearests of the depositors conservator. and open letter had gone out and list directors Soon after William C. Merrill pledged take 1,000 shares of the and large corporations they supporting the "Spokane were by subscribing to stock. Bar Group Acts On July the New Rochelle Bar Association the United States Government for more information that its members could instruct and advise clients plans to form First National Bank New By July 7½ per cent of the depositors had subscribed more than per the stock open the proposed bank. Ten later Rennie signed conservator. was said the depositors' committee felt resignation do much instill confidence among depositors new plan. Former Mayor Scott was named replace LeRoy Frantz, who had labored of the deposisince its inception and who at the end of July leaving the city vacation The On July 27 and 28 the Chamber of Commerce and 33 merchants threw their support behind the depositors which enlarged by more members. few days the Bar Association, through Judge Jacob Ruskin, reported that the the proposed bank and the release of 30 per cent of more than half of the total number needed open. On Aug. Edward D. Loughman. New York City attorney, appointed by the Federal government to occupy the position vacated by Mr. Rennie. At the time of the announcement was pointed out that Mr. Loughman had had no connection with the never been shareholder depositor, and never legal pacity officer depositor shareholder of the bank. Cordial Leads Campaign Soon the depositors committee sought old Liberty Loan campaigner would the drive for 15,000 shares successful conclusion. Edward Cordial named chairman of the camcommittee. Only two days after he named. Aug. were apparent and the total had leaped Aug. 8,631. Reports the West Side branch sent the total soaring above the mark. In order culminate the campaign with one final drive cityplanned toward the close of August, with the closing of the West Side branch. A plan devised the idity of subscription by asking merchants to receive stock cash. Pass 10,000 Mark As plans gigantic meeting being Sept. the total stock subscription over the 10,000 mark. mass meeting held the auditorium Albert Leonard Junior High and sult thermometer outside the bank building bubbled over after Supreme Justice William Bleakley, Kuvenal MarchMayor Otto Mr. Cordial The curtain had scarcely been lowered enthusiastic scene when second rally at Columbus School Oct. shares taken by subscribers summed than 13,000. final drive "Open the New Bank Before ThanksgivOn Oct. 26. volunteer and representatives !raternal organizations civic associations gathered in the National City Bank building. and circular letters askink additional help from previous subscribers already taken 10 per cent of their original deposit mailed out. Within short time shares totalled more than 13,500, with letters flooding the bank from point in including Hawaii, response to the plea for further succor. Pass 14,000 Mark On Nov. shares from 2,022 subscribers. 565 of which were for and 41 partly for cash and partly for had been signed On Nov. the total hurdled up. the 14,000 mark. With stock subscriptions still 14.314. and more than 600 needed complete the stock sub scription 15,000 the ganization committee Nov. 18. announced that the would be closed 10 days later. adding that bank will be open humanly thereafter organization committee at that time formed of William Merrill, William Daly, Harry Scott. Dr. C. Guion and LeRoy Frantz, its chairman Five days later. although stock were virtually standstill, only having been recorded in the hours. developments began to come rapidly filed with the Comptroller of in Washington an application for Hearing On Lease Another of the hearing the lease the National City Bank to the institution. the District filed. At the same time WILLIAM DALY application powers made to the Federal Reserve Bank. only required three days for the name "First National Bank Rochelle be approved. Next came the end drive with 14,382 shares subscribed. The deficit made the following day Noteman. signed his name block of shares sent the total soaring the mark. the total necessary back projected institution which liquidate the assets of the old tional Watson Named President Immediately attaches the bank began work the necespapers forward to the Capital. While hearing the lease was adjourned, the organizacommittee that Ernest H Watson Nutley officer Reconstruction Finance had been named president of the new bank. the same time the organization committee expressed the hope that the new would throw open its doors before Christmas, but this hope was later dissipated On Dec. depositors began flocking in to sign proofs claim. procedure necessary before funds could transferred from the old bank to meet their per Three days later LeRoy Frantz named viceserve year while William Shea, an officer the old bank was named trust officer. and E. Milton Berry, cashier Lease Approved The directors named following Daly Guion and all whom with the exception of Watson, had been instrumental from the first the struggle release the frozen Simultaneous with this came the approval the lease by Alfred Coxe. Federal Judge. From the beginning stockholders of the old bank been sented by commit- including Humphrey J. its chairman. Lester Albertson Robert Forbes, Dorothea Kreit Henry M Edward Baker and Frank Shrenkeisen. signed petition to review the lease, claiming the option for purwas not fair amount. Despite this protest from the stockholders committee. the lease, had been approved by Judge Coxe. While pleas went out from Federal Conservator Loughman for depositors come in and sign up their proofs of there amount of paper work to be effected by attaches of his staff in connection with reorganization of the insti- tution Hope Runs High triangularly placed offices the Comptroller the office RFC and headquarters of the Federal Reserve Bank. Finally late Saturday afternoon the application for Charter and reorganization first suggested by William Shea trust officer the institution became none other than Raymond McGovern director of the new member the law Dunlap Otto counsel for bank. made public the that the charter had granted and that bank open today. Mr. McGovern had spent many frequently far the hours, working the legal tech nicalities connected getting the Commendation for indefatigible effort in the bank opening must be given to citizens volunteer committee working under which Mr. personnel included: Albert Salerno Harry Abraham George Oscar Maxwell Katz. Jack Harry Sydney Magnus, Ruskin, Edward Boettner. John GunthThomas William Arthur Dealy, Ben- Christmas and the bank did not open, but hope high as Shea McGovern and Watto Washington two later. The returned New Rochelle reported that details of opening the bank had approved and the new president stayed in the Capital receive blanks for formal application for Charter and other necessary He flew back New Rochelle soon after with the data On Jan. had returned the Capital again with the necesarticles signed. One National First National officials went termined to charter for the they had to go fore President Technicalities held the immediate granting the cause the office of the Comptroller of were certain sufficient had been left for Loughman liquidation of assets National City Needed More "Cushion" Conferences resulted the opinion by the Comptroller Currency that the National City Bank have apply for further RFC loan of to give the For several days were shuttled back and forth Fannie Lejamin William George Kirch Charles Arthur and Lewis James Dandri and Galgano. Old Employes Work Hard Attaches the staff of Federal Conservator all the old also workployes ed assiduously to work out mountains data connection with of the old bank the liquidation the reorganization the new. William BenThey Martin Butti, George Vrionis, Charles George Shufelt and the bookkeepand former employes the National City kept on by


Article from The Daily Item, February 5, 1934

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

Three Bandits Linked To Two Jobs Mt. Vernon Beer Tavern, Larchmont Delicatessen Lose $150 Total MOUNT VERNON Feb. Three armed bandits held up Edward Tighe, bartender at the lumbus beer tavern on Third Street, early yesterday and caped with $50 the cash register. Tighe alone in the place at in the when the stepped out of an automobile and walked into his place. One them glass of beer and another pulled gun, ordered the bartender to put up his hands, and third through the till. The bartender caught glimpse of the registration on the fleeing the bandits left, and notified police. The stolen was found abandoned in 218th Street in the Bronx. LARCHMONT Feb 5. Bandits who up Mount Vernon beer were believed responsible for holdup delicatessen store at Addison Street Chatsworth Avenue, just before midnight, Saturday. Max Lipp, owner of the store, said men walked in and asked him for some ham. As was cutting it, they pulled guns and ordered him to turn over his money, or they would "blow him out the He asked them to leave him some change, and the bandits. he said. left all the silver the till and took the bills. estimated at about $100. They then escaped in an NAMED BANK RECEIVER NEW ROCHELLE, Feb. ward D. Loughman, Federal servator the National City Bank, of New Rochelle, appointed receiver of that institution by T. comptroller of the currency. He liquidate the old frozen assets STEALS TELEPHONE SEATTLE. Feb. The person stole pay telephone from the counter of drug here will have white elephant on his hands as well as financial disappointment. The phone waiting to be installed and had not been service.


Article from The Standard-Star, March 28, 1934

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

SUIT AGAINST BANK RECEIVER ADJOURNED. DISMISSAL IS MOVED Special to The NEW YORK March 28. Argument of motion by counsel for Edward D. Loughman as receiver for the National City Bank of New Rochelle for dismissal of the suit brought against him by Augus tus S. Wittnebel Rochelle was adjourned yesterday to April The case was before Fed eral Judge John M Woolsey the United States District Court here but was put by agreement Wittnebel received 935 shares of the capital stock as assessment of $18 700 because of prevent Mr interfering with his effort to inspect the books of the In his complaint Wittnebel made charges of fraud and honest practices by the bank and asserted that the is necessary him to obtain information for possible civil or criminal LICKED TOWN COPS EL PASO Clarence 230-pound Indian from calero M administered


Article from The Standard-Star, August 15, 1934

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BANK'S RECEIVER TAKES HOLC Judge Allows National City to Exchange Splitrock Mortgage Special The Standard-Star NEW YORK. Aug. 15 Federal Judge Robert B. Patterson in the United States District Court here, yesterday, signed an order permitting Edward D. Loughman, receivfor the insolvent National City Bank of New Rochelle, to accept bond of the Home Owners' Loan Corporation in exchange for mortgage held by the bank. The mortgage in question is that of the Splitrock Corporation and totals. with interest, to the petition presented by the firm of Dunlap, Otto & McGovern. counsel for Mr. Loughman, The order permits that bond for received and that the balance be made up by note of Thomas Good for $125


Article from The Standard-Star, September 14, 1934

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BANK'S RECEIVER TO FINISH HOUSE Federal Judge Coxe Permits Leasing of Home by National City Federal Judge Alfred C. Coxe in the United States District Court, New York City, yesterday signed order permitting Edward D. Loughman, receiver for the in solvent National City Bank of New Rochelle, to make lease of property at 12 Wyndham Road, Yonkers, owned by the bank The property is improved by one family stucco dwelling which has been uncompleted and unoccupied for two years Through his attorneys, Dunlap, Otto nd McGovern. McLoughman petitioned for permission to least the house to T. J. Cullen for a period of two years at $1,800 year The order also allows fr. Loughman to spend not more than 900 to complete the building and to make necessary repairs and to pay $135 in commissions to the real estate agent who has arranged the lease. The lease has been approved by the Comptroller of the Currency


Article from The Standard-Star, September 14, 1934

Click image to open full size in new tab

Article Text

BANK'S RECEIVER TO FINISH HOUSE Federal Judge Coxe Permits Leasing of Home by National City Federal Judge Alfred C. Coxe in the United States District Court. New York City, yesterday signed an order permitting Edward D. Loughman, receiver for the in solvent National City Bank of New Rochelle, to make lease of property at 12 Wyndham Road, Yonkers, owned by the bank. The property is improved by one family stucco dwelling which has been uncompleted and unoccupied for two years. Through his attorneys, Dunlap, Otto and McGovern. McLoughman petitioned for permission to least the house to J. Cullen for period of two years at $1,800 a year. The order also allows fr. Loughman to spend not more than $1,900 to complete the building and to make necessary repairs and to pay $135 in commissions to the real estate agent who has arranged the lease. The lease has been approved by the Comptroller of the Currency.