Article Text
WHO CLOSED PEOPLES? (Continued from Page generally misunderstood and the subject of as much speculation and controversy as ever. SIMON'S WIERD AMBITION Max L. Simon has admitted to one outstanding own The fantastic hope but one which cherishes. He has confessed that the purpose of his attacks on Dow D. Drukker, one of the owners of this newspaper, has been to discredit Drukker and everything with which Drukker was connected for the purpose of forcing him to sell The to Simon on the latter's own terms. Since Drukker had been influential in creating the present Peoples Bank and was chairman of Its board of directors, the Peoples became one of the objects of Simon's attacks. Simon has published number of small newspapers in Bergen County at different times. A few years ago he started the Eagle, printed in Garfield with an office in Passaic and with Paterson edition. Since its birth the Eagle has been devoted mainly to eulogies of Simon's friends and advertisers, for had incurred his and attacks on men who any reason will or that of Harry H. Weinberger. The Sunday Eagle's circulation has been small. It has never much advertising. Simon wanted circulation and advertisIng. His personal reputation is unsavory. have been told very circumstantial stories of his personal escapades which indicate his character. He has been indicted in Passaic County and is at present under bail on charge of having hired other men to set fire to the plant of Elizabeth daily newspaper which he had tried to conduct. LAW UNTO ITSELF For 40 years have had wide acquaintance with newspapers and newspaper men. In the offices of all reputable newspapers certain cardinal rules are strictly observed. These rules are that both sides of every story shall be told fully, that no charge or attack on any person shall be printed without giving him an opportunity to answer it, If he is accessible; to give everybody the benefit of all reasonable doubts, and that It is more important to tell the truth than to print sensational story. The Sunday Eagle violates every one of these rules. It the type of publication which years age too called a "yellow" Such publications are known among reputable newspaper men as "scandal sheets" or by leas complimentary names. know of no other publication in New Jersey today of the Sunday Eagle type. Since the Peoples Bank has been closed. Simon has avowed himself the champion and defender of the rights and interests of the depositors and stockholders. Week after week he has elamored editorially for information which he might have easily obtained. Sunday after Sunday his paper has carried pages of Insinuation and innuendo concerning the management of the bank, intimating that there was something wrong. In these weekly screeds he has attacked the officers of the bank for not more quickly readjusting its affairs and securing its openIng. He has denounced these men for not making public every step and detail of their plans and efforts for reorganization reopening, although he has known that they could not do so, and the reason why they could not do 80, WHO CREATED THIS SUSPICION? Th these weekly tirades there has been continued the same kind of attack on the bank and those responsible for its management that for four years previously had created prejudices, distrust and suspicion in the minds of bank depositors. Despite his present protestations of friendship for the depositors and stockholders in the Peoples, Max L. Simon and the Sunday Eagle are largely If not mainly responsible for the fact that for three months the bank has been closed, its 20,000 depositors have been deprived of the use of their money, and the Investments of its stockholders have been imperiled. Whether because of the Sunday Eagle attacks or independent them, there was conducted for months persistent campaign of rumors and whispers about the Peoples. Depositors celved telephone messages from mysterious "friends" advising them to take their money out of the bank. The effect of all this was that for more than year previous to March last, beginning almost immediately after the last merger, in which the City Trust and Lincoln National were morged with the Peoples, there had been constant decrease in its savings deposits-a continuous seepage of the life blood of the bank. There were no runs, with crowds clamoring at the bank's doors for as other banks have had in recent troublous years. Runs on banks are things of the moment, which are over in few hours if the bank is sound. 15 MONTHS OF SEEPAGE At the Peoples, week after week, month after month, for fifteen months, the deposits in the bank were drained away by almost continuous withdrawals. With only occasional pites, for fifteen months, the amount of withdrawals and the number of savings accounts closed weekly and monthly exceeded the amount of deposits and the number of new counts opened. Many of those who withdrew their savings and closed their Accounts gave excellent reasons for doing so. Hard times, unemployment, rent and insurance premiums unpaid, sickness, the need for money to live on-Passaic people have suffered as greatly as the people of most industrial cities in the five years since factories and mills began closing or going on part time. Banks everywhere have had this experience. But in the lines of depositors who came to the Peoples to withdraw their savings and close their accounts were many who, when questioned, just muttered and refused to answer, or gave halting explanations which clearly were not the true reasons. And not few of these depositors frankly told the tellers and bank officers that they were taking out their money because they had been told the bank was not safe. "Somebody telephoned me that had better take my money was the explanation frequently given. WHO DID THE DIRTY WORK? Who were responsible for these telephone messages, for the recurrence of street rumors, for the whispering campaign of gossip, suspicion and innuendo, is probably known only to those who did the dirty work. Whether anybody, even Simon intended deliberately to wreck the Peoples Bank and jeopardize the savings and investments of thousands of people, is a question which cannot answer, and which must be left to the consciences of those who accomplished this result. Whether any considerable number of those who carried tales and aided in the whispering compaign were part of conspiracy and conscious that they were making mischief, is doubtful. There are always plenty of people ready and willing to peddle gossip, to repeat rumors and scandals, for no other reason than that they enjoy gossiping and have nothing else to There are others who take pride in repeating such things, often with elaborations, to impress other people with sense of their own importance and knowledge. And there are any number of people who are always ready and willing to disten to and believe any sort of charge or slander or rumor to the detriment of banks and big business institutions, or other people more successful than themselves. CHARACTER AND WEALTH few generations ago, when character was considered more Important than wealth, we respected for what they were or what they accomplished, rather than for their wealth. In more recent generations we of America came to give more thought to money than to character and to pay tribute wealth, no matter how it had been obtained. There was period in which the worship of the dollar was our leading religion, and those who had the most dollars, regardless of how they got them, became our high priests and prophets. Today the pendulum has swung so far in the other direction that all men who have won money and success are more or less under suspicion, with many people ready to believe the worst possible of them. regardless of whether they have succeeded by honest, constructive effort and ability, or by dishonesty and chicanery. So in Passaic there were undoubtedly many who helped bring about the present difficulties of the Peoples Bank by their willingness, if not eagerness, to believe any sort of wild tale or charge about the bank or concerning the men who guided its destinies. And week after week these rumors and slanders were kept alive and new ones started by the Sunday Eagle. Suspicion and distrust of the bank and its officers were craftily and persistently encouraged by inspiring in the minds of the people of Passaic, distrust and hatred of citizens who were connected with the affairs of the bank. GARBLED FACTS Incidents and facts were garbled and warped out of all resemblance to the truth to give them sinister meanings. The most absurd motives were imputed to the simplest things. Efforts were even made to arouse racial prejudice and discord by the distortion of entirely innocent statements and happenings. The Eagle was willing to print anything that would help to sell papers, to advance the interests of the editor and gratify his personal ambitions, regardless of the cost or the question of who might have to pay, The 20,000 depositors in the Peoples Bank may properly say today to Simon and Weinberger: did you do this orue! thing to us? Did you not know that in seeking to gratify your own ambitions and hatreds, you were putting our savings into jeopardy and causing us misery, suffering and privation? The 1,400 or more small stockholders the Peoples Bank may properly say today to Simon and to Weinberger: "What have we ever done to you that you should seek to ruin us by destroying the value of our Investments' Whether Max L. Simon, Harry H. Weinberger and other men whose mouthpiece Simon has been, knew that their attacks were imperiling millions of dollars of savings and investments depositors and stockholders in the Peoples Bank, or whether he and they, whoever they were, were callously indifferent what the effects of his and their attack might be: whether they knew a cared who might suffer or how great the sufferings his and their victims might be, leave to the judgment my readers and to their own consciences, if they have consciences. There are laws under which men who wreck banks by misusing or appropriating their money, may be sent to prison. The laws are especially severe upon men who break into banks and steal money belonging to the depositors, and public opinion everywhere brands such as public enemies. CRIME OF ANOTHER KIND But banks may be as effectively robbed and wrecked by gossip and slanders as with crowbar and dynamite. The savings of bank depositors may be as badly jeopardized by creating suspicion and distrust which leads to runs on the bank and wholesale withdrawals of deposits, as by embezzlement and thefts. There is law against spreading prejudicial rumors and slanders about banks, and severe penalties for its violation. Nobody knows this better than the men, whoever they may be, who kept the whispered campaign against the Peoples Bank alive for more than a planned and kept up the telephoned messages to depositors. For this reason, they carefully covered their tracks. For this reason, the depositors who told of these telephoned messages were unable or unwilling to tell who had done the telephoning. It is doubtful if the whole truth about this campaign against the Peoples will ever be known. And while there is law against repeating or publishing malicious gossip against or about banks, there is no special law to punish the creating of suspicion, distrust and prejudice against men who manage banks or have influence in them. There are laws of libel and slander, but libel and slander are not easy of proof to jury, and editors advised by clever lawyers, find ways of printing such things in such way that if they were taken to court, would make It very difficult to prove that the publication was really slanderous or malicious. We all know many things that we cannot prove to others. NOT EVERYBODY CRIES. 'POLICE' Then, too, the character of the Sunday Eagle and the reputation of Simon made it difficult to believe that intelligent persons would be by his tirades. Some of the men he has most viciously attacked even now refuse to believe that Simon or the Sunday Eagle have affected the opinions of any number of people. And among men of affairs, there is always the disinclination to go to law except in extreme cases. people of small affairs, narrow views, and narrow lives who for the police and run to court when they have grievances against their neighbors. Nobody knows this psychology better editors publications like the Sunday Eagle, and they go to the limit in taking advantage of this knowledge. There are, fortunately, not many such publications or editors. know of no other paper in New Jersey which fills its news and editorial columns with personal abuse of individuals. which habitually prints only one side of the and which is more interested in making story sensational than the question whether or not it is true. Passaic and the depositors and stockholders in the Peoples Bank are the victims of what we used to call "yellow journalism", which makes its strongest appeal to the poorest and least successful people in the community, for the sake of selling papers, and which devotes itself to tearing down reputations and institutions which others have built. In articles to follow propose to tell in detail the whole story the Peoples Bank, of the men who built it, of the men and influences which have tried to wreck it and the methods they have used. WHAT WILL BE PROVED These articles will prove that Harry H. Weinberger furnished Max Simon with material and inspiration for attacks on the Peoples Bank and its management. They will tell howe documentary evidence was doctored to give color to some of these charges. They will explain the reasons for Passaic's bank mergers, and how local bankers and financiers were making considerable personal sacrifices to protect the interests of stockholders and depositors while they were being attacked Simon, and, how their work was made more difficult because of his baseless charges and insinuations. In these articles will tell the whole truth about "the Drukker gang". the Drukker was robbing the city paving contracts, and why Max L. Simon hates Dow Drukker and has for years sought to destroy him and the institutions with which he has been connected by guerilla attacks him and them.